_James ABERNATHY ____+
| (1783 - 1853)
_Richard B. ABERNATHY _|
| (1817 - 1860) m 1839 |
| |_Elizabeth _____ ____
| (.... - 1835)
_James Thomas ABERNATHY _|
| (1842 - 1900) |
| | _____________________
| | |
| |_Lucinda Ann CASSADY __|
| (1821 - 1860) m 1839 |
| |_____________________
|
|
|--Irena ABERNATHY
| (1888 - ....)
| _____________________
| |
| _______________________|
| | |
| | |_____________________
| |
|_Mary Elizabeth _____ ___|
(1855 - 1925) |
| _____________________
| |
|_______________________|
|
|_____________________
__
|
__|
| |
| |__
|
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1740 - 1826) |
| | __
| | |
| |__|
| |
| |__
|
|
|--Isabel ABERNATHY
| (1788 - ....)
| __
| |
| __|
| | |
| | |__
| |
|_Mary HAMILTON ______|
(1770 - 1838) |
| __
| |
|__|
|
|__
__
|
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1740 - 1826) |
| |__
|
_George ABERNATHY ___|
| (1810 - 1874) m 1831|
| | __
| | |
| |_Mary HAMILTON ______|
| (1770 - 1838) |
| |__
|
|
|--Jacob J. ABERNATHY
| (1850 - ....)
| __
| |
| _____________________|
| | |
| | |__
| |
|_Dorcas SLATER ______|
(1810 - 1875) m 1831|
| __
| |
|_____________________|
|
|__
still living - details excluded
_William T. ABERNATHY _+
| (1830 - ....) m 1851
_James H. C. ABERNATHY _|
| (1853 - ....) m 1873 |
| |_Eliza Ann STUBBS _____
| (1830 - 1860) m 1851
_Arthur Allen ABERNATHY _|
| (1874 - ....) m 1907 |
| | _______________________
| | |
| |_Hester Emma KERSHAW ___|
| (1854 - ....) m 1873 |
| |_______________________
|
|
|--James ABERNATHY
|
| _______________________
| |
| ________________________|
| | |
| | |_______________________
| |
|_Delia LEURIG ___________|
(1881 - ....) m 1907 |
| _______________________
| |
|________________________|
|
|_______________________
1850 Census, Prairie Tp., Davis Co., shows James Abernathy born in South Carolina, no wife, but with an apparent daughter Mary Smith with her daughter Rebecca Smith, and an apparent son William T. Abernathy. An earlier census exists, for 1847, listing James Abernathy in a household consisting of 2 persons. Since his son Hugh and his presumed daughter Mary are evidently listed separately with their spouses, the one remaining Abernathy still living with James would be William T. The land that James Abernathy entered in the 1840's was sold to William T. Abernathy in 1848. When William later sold the land in 1855, a graveyard was mentioned. Eventually, the graveyard was located, and proved to contain only one resident, James Abernathy himself. The stone was broken, but the lettering appears to be perfectly legible, and gives the death date 1853, as well as a gloomy inscription, "In the midst of Life is Death". With this information, it becomes apparent that the James Abernathy (born about 1790, in Indiana, according to this census, the birthplace certainly not believable) of about the same age listed in the 1860 census of Rush Co., IN, must be someone else! The existence of two James Abernathy's of the same generation with connections to Rush Co. immediately suggests that the Abernathy family must be more complicated than has previously been supposed. It is not reasonable that both James are the sons of the elder Hugh Abernathy!
James Abernathy obtained patents for three parcels of land in Rush Co., IN:
W 1/2 NE 1/4 Sec. 22, T 14 N, R 9 E, 15 nov 1830; E 1/2 SE 1/4 Sec. 11, T 14 N, R 9 E, 17 apr 1833; SW 1/4 Sec. 15, T 14 N, R 9 E, 05 aug 1834.
None of the patents indicate a previous place of residence.
The second parcel listed above, in Section 11, was sold by James Abernathy and his wife Elizabeth 02 apr 1831 to Nathan Porter of Kenhawha (Kenawha) Co., VA for $150.
The W 1/2 of the parcel listed above in Section 15 was sold by James Abernathy (no wife listed, so she was presumably already dead) to Hugh Abernathy 28 nov 1835 (Rush Co. Deeds, vol. F, p. 601) for $350 "and for mutual love and affection". This deed refers to Hugh Abernathy as the son of James Abernathy. Hugh Abernathy and his wife Rebecca sold this 80 acres 19 apr 1839 to William M. Fleener for $700 (vol. K, p. 20). The E 1/2 of the same parcel was sold by James Abernathy to William M. Fleener 03 may 1840 for $550 (vol. K, p. 492).
James Abernathy also purchased 80 acres adjacent to his property in Section 22, the E 1/2 NW 1/4 Sec. 22, T 14 N, R 9 E. He sold the two properties in Section 22 on 13 may 1845 to William Lytle of Butler Co., OH for $1600 (vol. O, pp. 112-114). The sale notes the existence of a cemetery in the E 1/2 NW 1/4 Sec. 22, which is excluded from the sale. This cemetery, if it can be located, should be the burial place of James' wife. The date of this sale probably marks the departure of James Abernathy from Rush Co.
So far, it is assumed that this James Abernathy is the son of Hugh Abernathy and his wife Mary who came from South Carolina to the area that is now Union County, Indiana by 1809. This area has been, successively, Dearborn, Franklin, Fayette, and finally Union Counties, and records concerning Hugh and his family should be sought in all of these jurisdictions. The first patent, in the name of Hugh Abernathy and William Rusing (probably father of the husbands of two of Hugh's daughters), is dated 1809, in Section 21, T 10 N, R 2 W. The accounting of all the parcels of land owned by Hugh Abernathy has not been completed, but we note that he and his wife Mary sold to James Abernathy in 1817, land in Sec. 32, T 13 N, R 13 E, in present-day Union County (Deeds vol. B, p. 430).
Hugh Abernathy "of Franklin County, Indiana" made his will 20 Jan 1825. It was probated in Union County in 1826. Letters Testamentary were granted in recess by the probate court there before the August term, 1826, to Robert Abernathy and Robert Rusing. The will, as abstracted in the Hoosier Journal of Ancestry, 7(4): 24, shows the following heirs:
Widow Mary;
Children: 1. John 2. Robert 3. Isabel Bowlan 4. Nancy Rusing 5. Jane Morrow 6. Sally Rusing 7. Nelly 8. James 9. William 10. Benjamin 11. Richard 12. Thomas 13. Moses 14. Kelam 15. Mary (deceased?), her son William Burns 16. George 17. Samuel
The will mentions the "farm where I now live", in the E 1/2 NE 1/4 Sec. 10, T 10 N, R 2 W.
How many children did James Abernathy have? By combining the various census records, evidence for 7 children is found:
1. A daughter born 1811-1815, gone by 1840 2. Hugh Abernathy, b. 1814 3. A daughter born 1816-1820, gone by 1840 4. A son born 1816-1820, and here presumed to be Richard Abernathy b. 1817, already in Iowa in 1839 5. A son born 1821-1825, still in the household in 1840, but no evidence that he survived beyond that date 6. Mary, b. about 1824 7. William T. Abernathy, b. about 1830.
Since four children were born between the middle of 1810 and the middle of 1820, the date of James' marriage was likely about 1811, and the marriage would likely have been recorded in Franklin Co., IN. The records there may not be complete, and he is not listed. Records for adjacent Ohio might also be checked.
The following tracts in Davis Co. were purchased from the Federal Land Office by James Abernathy:
25 may 1846, W 1/2 SE 1/4 Sec. 13, T 68 N, R 12 W; 16 jun 1846, SW 1/4 NE 1/4 Sec. 13, T 68 N, R 12 W.
[5287] Burial ground in W 1/2 SE 1/4 Sec. 13, T 68 N, R 12 W, mentioned in sale of land 23 jul 1855 by William T. Abernathy and his wife Eliza Ann to Asa Blanchard. As of 11/2003, stone broken but still readable.
__
|
__|
| |
| |__
|
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1740 - 1826) |
| | __
| | |
| |__|
| |
| |__
|
|
|--James ABERNATHY
| (1783 - 1853)
| __
| |
| __|
| | |
| | |__
| |
|_Mary HAMILTON ______|
(1770 - 1838) |
| __
| |
|__|
|
|__
_James ABERNATHY ____+
| (1783 - 1853)
_Richard B. ABERNATHY _|
| (1817 - 1860) m 1839 |
| |_Elizabeth _____ ____
| (.... - 1835)
_James Thomas ABERNATHY _|
| (1842 - 1900) |
| | _____________________
| | |
| |_Lucinda Ann CASSADY __|
| (1821 - 1860) m 1839 |
| |_____________________
|
|
|--James Cleveland ABERNATHY
| (1885 - ....)
| _____________________
| |
| _______________________|
| | |
| | |_____________________
| |
|_Mary Elizabeth _____ ___|
(1855 - 1925) |
| _____________________
| |
|_______________________|
|
|_____________________
Biographical sketch in 1878 atlas of Morgan Co., IL gives dates, says his mother died when he as about 7, he was "bound out" to a farmer for a few years after that. In 1870, he is a farm hand on the Caleb Isenhower farm in Jackson Tp., Van Buren Co., IA (p. 274).
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____
| (1740 - 1826)
_James ABERNATHY ____|
| (1783 - 1853) |
| |_Mary HAMILTON ______
| (1770 - 1838)
_William T. ABERNATHY _|
| (1830 - ....) m 1851 |
| | _____________________
| | |
| |_Elizabeth _____ ____|
| (.... - 1835) |
| |_____________________
|
|
|--James H. C. ABERNATHY
| (1853 - ....)
| _____________________
| |
| _____________________|
| | |
| | |_____________________
| |
|_Eliza Ann STUBBS _____|
(1830 - 1860) m 1851 |
| _____________________
| |
|_____________________|
|
|_____________________
__
|
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1740 - 1826) |
| |__
|
_George ABERNATHY ___|
| (1810 - 1874) m 1831|
| | __
| | |
| |_Mary HAMILTON ______|
| (1770 - 1838) |
| |__
|
|
|--James Milton ABERNATHY
| (1844 - ....)
| __
| |
| _____________________|
| | |
| | |__
| |
|_Dorcas SLATER ______|
(1810 - 1875) m 1831|
| __
| |
|_____________________|
|
|__
Cemetery record notes Co. H, 13th Iowa Infantry, Civil War. 1895 census listing, Roscoe Tp., Davis Co., IA, says born in Van Buren Co. (For the 1895 census, they are living adjacent to the Hale family.) The Van Buren Co. death register erroneously shows the date of death as 24 may 1901, even though the cemetery record and the Civil War pension file indicate 1900. The death register includes the 1901 date in a group of entries "reported June, 1900".
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____
| (1740 - 1826)
_James ABERNATHY ____|
| (1783 - 1853) |
| |_Mary HAMILTON ______
| (1770 - 1838)
_Richard B. ABERNATHY _|
| (1817 - 1860) m 1839 |
| | _____________________
| | |
| |_Elizabeth _____ ____|
| (.... - 1835) |
| |_____________________
|
|
|--James Thomas ABERNATHY
| (1842 - 1900)
| _____________________
| |
| _____________________|
| | |
| | |_____________________
| |
|_Lucinda Ann CASSADY __|
(1821 - 1860) m 1839 |
| _____________________
| |
|_____________________|
|
|_____________________
__
|
__|
| |
| |__
|
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1740 - 1826) |
| | __
| | |
| |__|
| |
| |__
|
|
|--Jane ABERNATHY
| (1792 - ....)
| __
| |
| __|
| | |
| | |__
| |
|_Mary HAMILTON ______|
(1770 - 1838) |
| __
| |
|__|
|
|__
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____
| (1740 - 1826)
_James ABERNATHY ____|
| (1783 - 1853) |
| |_Mary HAMILTON ______
| (1770 - 1838)
_Richard B. ABERNATHY _|
| (1817 - 1860) m 1839 |
| | _____________________
| | |
| |_Elizabeth _____ ____|
| (.... - 1835) |
| |_____________________
|
|
|--Jasper ABERNATHY
| (1846 - 1860)
| _____________________
| |
| _____________________|
| | |
| | |_____________________
| |
|_Lucinda Ann CASSADY __|
(1821 - 1860) m 1839 |
| _____________________
| |
|_____________________|
|
|_____________________
_Richard B. ABERNATHY _+
| (1817 - 1860) m 1839
_William M. ABERNATHY _|
| (1843 - 1920) m 1868 |
| |_Lucinda Ann CASSADY __
| (1821 - 1860) m 1839
_Asa Frank ABERNATHY _|
| (1870 - ....) |
| | _Asa BLANCHARD ________
| | | (1804 - 1881)
| |_Lucy L. BLANCHARD ____|
| (1850 - 1913) m 1868 |
| |_______________________
|
|
|--Jessie L. ABERNATHY
| (1893 - ....)
| _______________________
| |
| _______________________|
| | |
| | |_______________________
| |
|_Jamba _____ _________|
(1874 - ....) |
| _______________________
| |
|_______________________|
|
|_______________________
Purchased federal land in Cheyenne Co., CO in T 15 S, R 44 W. In that county 1910 (p. 170) and 1920 (p. 234B), not yet found in 1900. 1916: mentioned living at Arapahoe, Co.
1940 census: Joel S. Abernathy age 84, and his wife Ella, age 78, Denver, CO, ED 16-102, block 235-236, sheet 18A.
Buried in Fairmount Cemetery, Denver, Block 72: Abernathy, Ella E. 1862-1945, Joel S. 1855-1949. There is a family tree on FamilySearch.org, with minimal but useful information.
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____
| (1740 - 1826)
_James ABERNATHY ____|
| (1783 - 1853) |
| |_Mary HAMILTON ______
| (1770 - 1838)
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1814 - 1894) m 1835|
| | _____________________
| | |
| |_Elizabeth _____ ____|
| (.... - 1835) |
| |_____________________
|
|
|--Joel Smith ABERNATHY
| (1855 - 1949)
| _Reuben SMITH _______
| | (1767 - 1840) m 1788
| _John B. SMITH ______|
| | (1792 - 1849) m 1815|
| | |_Sarah Beach CLARK __
| | (1773 - 1834) m 1788
|_Rebecca SMITH ______|
(1816 - 1905) m 1835|
| _John CHAPMAN _______
| | (1763 - 1850) m 1788
|_Elizabeth CHAPMAN __|
(1797 - 1853) m 1815|
|_Rebecca PEACE ______
(1767 - ....) m 1788
__
|
__|
| |
| |__
|
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1740 - 1826) |
| | __
| | |
| |__|
| |
| |__
|
|
|--John ABERNATHY
| (1774 - 1848)
| __
| |
| __|
| | |
| | |__
| |
|_Mary HAMILTON ______|
(1770 - 1838) |
| __
| |
|__|
|
|__
_James ABERNATHY ____+
| (1783 - 1853)
_Richard B. ABERNATHY _|
| (1817 - 1860) m 1839 |
| |_Elizabeth _____ ____
| (.... - 1835)
_Ira W. ABERNATHY ___|
| (1849 - ....) m 1871|
| | _____________________
| | |
| |_Lucinda Ann CASSADY __|
| (1821 - 1860) m 1839 |
| |_____________________
|
|
|--John ABERNATHY
| (1875 - ....)
| _____________________
| |
| _Lower HALE ___________|
| | (1807 - 1853) m 1830 |
| | |_____________________
| |
|_Armilda HALE _______|
(1845 - 1913) m 1871|
| _____________________
| |
|_Lucinda WEBB _________|
m 1830 |
|_____________________
__
|
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1740 - 1826) |
| |__
|
_George ABERNATHY ___|
| (1810 - 1874) m 1831|
| | __
| | |
| |_Mary HAMILTON ______|
| (1770 - 1838) |
| |__
|
|
|--John Flax ABERNATHY
| (1838 - ....)
| __
| |
| _____________________|
| | |
| | |__
| |
|_Dorcas SLATER ______|
(1810 - 1875) m 1831|
| __
| |
|_____________________|
|
|__
1880: Grant Tp., Clark Co., MO, p. 231A. Middle initial from his marriage record. 1870: Prairie Tp., Davis Co., IA, p. 132, with wife Eve, no children at this date.
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____
| (1740 - 1826)
_James ABERNATHY ____|
| (1783 - 1853) |
| |_Mary HAMILTON ______
| (1770 - 1838)
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1814 - 1894) m 1835|
| | _____________________
| | |
| |_Elizabeth _____ ____|
| (.... - 1835) |
| |_____________________
|
|
|--John S. ABERNATHY
| (1847 - 1916)
| _Reuben SMITH _______
| | (1767 - 1840) m 1788
| _John B. SMITH ______|
| | (1792 - 1849) m 1815|
| | |_Sarah Beach CLARK __
| | (1773 - 1834) m 1788
|_Rebecca SMITH ______|
(1816 - 1905) m 1835|
| _John CHAPMAN _______
| | (1763 - 1850) m 1788
|_Elizabeth CHAPMAN __|
(1797 - 1853) m 1815|
|_Rebecca PEACE ______
(1767 - ....) m 1788
Evidently he had reached the age of majority by the time his father prepared his will, 20 jan 1825, because the next two sons, George and Samuel, were singled out as being underage.
__
|
__|
| |
| |__
|
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1740 - 1826) |
| | __
| | |
| |__|
| |
| |__
|
|
|--Kellam ABERNATHY
| (1803 - ....)
| __
| |
| __|
| | |
| | |__
| |
|_Mary HAMILTON ______|
(1770 - 1838) |
| __
| |
|__|
|
|__
living - details excluded
_John S. ABERNATHY _____+
| (1847 - 1916) m 1869
_George Rufus ABERNATHY _|
| (1871 - 1951) m 1893 |
| |_Eva Catherine CHRISTY _
| (1851 - 1948) m 1869
_Ellis Hugh ABERNATHY _|
| (1894 - 1984) m 1922 |
| | ________________________
| | |
| |_Viola BARROW ___________|
| (.... - 1908) m 1893 |
| |________________________
|
|
|--Lasca J. ABERNATHY
|
| ________________________
| |
| _________________________|
| | |
| | |________________________
| |
|_Eva Lasca GRAY _______|
(1900 - 1974) m 1922 |
| ________________________
| |
|_________________________|
|
|________________________
_James ABERNATHY ____+
| (1783 - 1853)
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1814 - 1894) m 1835|
| |_Elizabeth _____ ____
| (.... - 1835)
_John S. ABERNATHY _____|
| (1847 - 1916) m 1869 |
| | _John B. SMITH ______+
| | | (1792 - 1849) m 1815
| |_Rebecca SMITH ______|
| (1816 - 1905) m 1835|
| |_Elizabeth CHAPMAN __+
| (1797 - 1853) m 1815
|
|--Lavina Olga "Vina" ABERNATHY
| (1872 - 1960)
| _____________________
| |
| _____________________|
| | |
| | |_____________________
| |
|_Eva Catherine CHRISTY _|
(1851 - 1948) m 1869 |
| _____________________
| |
|_____________________|
|
|_____________________
_James ABERNATHY ____+
| (1783 - 1853)
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1814 - 1894) m 1835|
| |_Elizabeth _____ ____
| (.... - 1835)
_Joel Smith ABERNATHY _|
| (1855 - 1949) m 1881 |
| | _John B. SMITH ______+
| | | (1792 - 1849) m 1815
| |_Rebecca SMITH ______|
| (1816 - 1905) m 1835|
| |_Elizabeth CHAPMAN __+
| (1797 - 1853) m 1815
|
|--Luella M. ABERNATHY
| (1890 - ....)
| _____________________
| |
| _____________________|
| | |
| | |_____________________
| |
|_Ella E. TIBBS ________|
(1863 - 1945) m 1881 |
| _____________________
| |
|_____________________|
|
|_____________________
Middle initial could be Y? In 1870, he is a farm hand with the John Q. Hairgrove family in Jackson Tp., Van Buren Co., IA (p. 285).
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____
| (1740 - 1826)
_James ABERNATHY ____|
| (1783 - 1853) |
| |_Mary HAMILTON ______
| (1770 - 1838)
_William T. ABERNATHY _|
| (1830 - ....) m 1851 |
| | _____________________
| | |
| |_Elizabeth _____ ____|
| (.... - 1835) |
| |_____________________
|
|
|--Madison L. ABERNATHY
| (1852 - ....)
| _____________________
| |
| _____________________|
| | |
| | |_____________________
| |
|_Eliza Ann STUBBS _____|
(1830 - 1860) m 1851 |
| _____________________
| |
|_____________________|
|
|_____________________
Apparently dead by 1825, although some genealogists say she survived until 1852. There is a bequest to her son William Burns in the will of Hugh Abernathy, but not one directly for her, implying that she had already died.
__
|
__|
| |
| |__
|
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1740 - 1826) |
| | __
| | |
| |__|
| |
| |__
|
|
|--Mary ABERNATHY
| (1805 - 1825)
| __
| |
| __|
| | |
| | |__
| |
|_Mary HAMILTON ______|
(1770 - 1838) |
| __
| |
|__|
|
|__
The first wife of Reuben Peace Smith, named as Mary Smith in the deed of 1849 in which Reuben Smith sells back to his father 50 acres of land in Prairie Tp., Davis Co., IA which he had purchased in 1847 from his father. Her probable identity as Mary, daughter of James Abernathy, is deduced from her residence with James Abernathy in the 1850 census, but no probate or land records have yet been located to confirm this hypothesis.
__
|
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1740 - 1826) |
| |__
|
_James ABERNATHY ____|
| (1783 - 1853) |
| | __
| | |
| |_Mary HAMILTON ______|
| (1770 - 1838) |
| |__
|
|
|--Mary ABERNATHY
| (1824 - 1856)
| __
| |
| _____________________|
| | |
| | |__
| |
|_Elizabeth _____ ____|
(.... - 1835) |
| __
| |
|_____________________|
|
|__
__
|
_Hugh ABERNATHY _____|
| (1740 - 1826) |
| |__
|
_George ABERNATHY ___|
| (1810 - 1874) m 1831|
| | __
| | |
| |_Mary HAMILTON ______|
| (1770 - 1838) |
| |__
|
|
|--Mary Ann ABERNATHY
| (1830 - ....)
| __
| |
| _____________________|
| | |
| | |__
| |
|_Dorcas SLATER ______|
(1810 - 1875) m 1831|
| __
| |
|_____________________|
|
|__