The following is from Edward B Haines' 1873 "History of Towanda" 1
Prior to 1841, Catholic services were held in various places; but in that year Rev Father John V O'Reilly and the congregation put up a wooden church on the site of the present church. In 1869 the old church was demolished, and the present elegant Gothic structure erected. The new church is built of brick, with stone basement. It is 50x100 feet, with a tower and spire one hundred and ninety feet high. The total cost will be about $75,000. There are about three hundred families in the parish. The Rev Father Patrick Toner is priest in charge, and to his efforts the congregation owes the beautiful structure they now worship in, which is by far the finest church edifice in Bradford county. The church is named Sts Peter and Paul. There is a school held in the basement of the church, taught by Miss Quigley; number of scholars, fifty. There is also a cemetery of about one acre, about one mile from town.