| YEAR | SHERIFF | DISTRICT |
| 1860 | William Gregory | |
| 1860 | Walter Cool | Holly |
| 1865 | Charles McClure Dodrill | |
| 1865 | William G. Gregory | Fork Lick |
| 1868 | Charles McClure Dodrill | Fork Lick |
| 1868 | Austin Rader | |
| 1871 | Austin Rader | Glade |
| 1871 | Walter Cool | |
| 1873 | Samuel Given | Glade |
| 1877 | Patrick F. Duffy | Fork Lick |
| 1881 | Hayes W. Rader | Glade |
| 1885 | Samuel Given | |
| 1889 | Isaac W. Curry | Fork Lick |
| 1893 | Peter J. McGuire | Glade |
| 1897 | Levi Skidmore, Jr. | Fork Lick |
| 1901 | Patrick F. Duffy | Fork Lick |
| 1905 | Levi Skidmore, Jr. | Fork Lick |
| 1909 | Charles W. Morton | Glade |
| 1913 | Orville C. Ferrill | Hacker Valley |
| 1917 | Stephen R. Woodzell | Fork Lick |
| 1921 | Ward R. Woods | Glade |
| 1925 | Alva L. Gregory | Fork Lick |
| 1929 | John B. Skidmore | Fork Lick |
| 1933 | Orville C. Ferrill | Hacker Valley |
| 1937 | Dock Cutlip | Holly |
| 1941 | Denzil Hines | Fork Lick |
| 1942 | Alva L. Gregory | Fork Lick |
| 1945 | Homer F. Bickel | Hacker Valley |
| 1949 | Ova M. Carpenter | Fork Lick |
| 1953 | Earl Morton | Glade |
| 1957 | Ola Miller | Holly |
| 1960-1964 | Mrs. Esta Dodrill (Mrs. Willard) | Fork Lick |
| 1965 | Henry K. Hatton | Fork Lick |
| 1969 | Pete Sparacio | Fork Lick |