VERMONTWEBSITE  

 
 

 
   
 
   The following accounts were contributed by descendants or relatives of the persons described therein. 

        Johan Ernst (Defuh) Dafoe, my 4th Great Grandfather and his five sons, Conrad, Abraham, John , Jacob and George lived in Pownal,Vermont and belonged to the large Palatine Family of Dafoes. Some Dafoes joined the revolution, others stayed out of it. Johan, however, protested the acts of Ethan Allen and was marked as a troublemaker. When many of the Loyalists were rounded up in 1776, Johan was one who was put in jail. There he got to know Benjamin Franklin' son, William, who much to his father's anger remained loyal to the King. 

        JohanDafoe's children were not so outspoken and continued for a time to participate peaceably in the life of their communities. But that was before Bennington. When Burgoyne swept south through New York, Johan escaped jail and joined him in the British cause. In the words of his son, Conrad: "In the year 1777, He (Johan) broke out of Gaol (jail) and went into Burgoyne's camp and very shortly after fought in the Battle of Bennington where he was unfortunately taken prisoner and put in confinement and irons which situation he suffered for nearly 12 months." 

       Not all captured Loyalists were treated harshly. Abraham was freed and allowed to return to his crops. An old friend of the family, Samuel Anderson stated: "Johan fought like a good and brave soldier, under my command, with three of his sons, (Abraham,Conrad and George) and that one of his sons, George was killed in the battle." 

       The loss of George was a terrible blow to the family that must have caused great bitterness against the American cause. But even more telling was the manner of his death and what happened to his wife and children afterward. George was a reluctant soldier. He had been married six years and had three small children. George's luck ran out on August 16, 1777 when his unit was riding with Gen.Stark's regulars on a routine patrol through the countryside. Burgoyne was thought to be nowhere nearby. Quite by accident Stark ran into Burgoyne's German troops and he threw all his troops against them. The Militiamen had to make a choice. George was wounded by a musket shot.  By thus declaring themselves under fire, George and his company became traitors. George was taken to a barn and laid on the straw to await whatever nursing his family could give. With his sister Mary and a neighbor, Alisha Young by his side.  He died there a few days later. 

       George's wife could not attend him, for she lay dying herself a few miles away. Her death was a result of Bennington as was George's. Her story came out in a letter from Lower Canada Official (Where the Dafoes were deported to after the War) Eleazer Fitchto his colleague Isaac Ogden , June 1, 1793: "After the Battle, a mob went to his home, turned his widow out of door, and took everything from her, even the small things she had made for her lying in, for she was being then big with child, she had to travel five miles before she could find someone to receive her into their home, the fatigue of which together with her grief of mind brought on her labour and she and the child died. 

       This was the culminating tragedy of Bennington for old Johan Dafoe and his family and they soon left America for Lower Canada. Johan Ernst (Defuh) Dafoe (1726-August 12, 1789 ) was my 4th Great-Grandfather and Conrad (Coenraet) Dafoe (March 14, 1753- May 1853) was my 3rd Great Grandfather. Conrad's Grandson and my Great Grandfather, David Conrad Dafoe returned to the United States about 1880. 

Contributed by Jerry Dafoe

 

 

 

        The Battle of Bennington was fought on land granted to my husband's family. The British crossed this land on there way to Fort Ticonderoga (needless to say, they never made it). James Lake joined General Burgoyne's forces at this point on 6 Jul 1777, serving as a private. He then went with Burgoyne on to Saratoga, where he became a prisoner of war on 24 Oct 1777 and remained such until the end of the war. 

       The Lakes were quintessential fence sitters. They tried very hard not to take sides in the disputes that raged around them. But they saw injustice in the way Ethan Allen and his Green Mountain Boys tried to drive New York settlers off their land in favour of his New Hampshire comrades. It was Allen's decision to aid the Colonial cause which ultimately turned the Lakes into Loyalists--they couldn't abide Allen's tactics and felt they couldn't support any side which would accept Allen and his cohorts. The family is inordinately proud of their ancestors for not allowing themselves to be allied with the local bullies. 

Contributed by Maureen Lake