Clan Sliochd Sean Rob Mhic Alasdair Oig of
the Stewarts of Gartnafuaran, Balquhidder, Perthshire, ScotlandItems in RED below have updates pending
In Lower Duart and Grodich in Glen Finglas
Cadet Branch IV of the Stewarts of Gartnafuaran
Discuss this family with fellow researchers at:
Click on any of the following to be taken to that section or page.
Contents of this page |
Links to other pages on the Stewarts of Balquhidder web site
|
This page is part of the Stewarts of Balquhidder Research Group Web Site jointly hosted by myself, Ryk Brown, and my research partner, Chuck Speed. The research presented on this page is not ours alone. It is the product of all the Fellow Researchers of the Stewarts of Balquhidder Research Group. We are indebted to them for their generous contributions. This page is intended as a place for researchers to freely and cooperatively share our research with each other. The first-time reader is advised to begin with the introduction found on the Principal Families Page before proceeding on with this page.
The Stewarts of Sliochd Sean Rob Mhic Alasdair Oig were a cadet branch of the Stewarts of Gartnafuaran. Please refer to the Gartnafuaran page for a full introduction. This family also had one cadet line who resided in Duart in Glen Finglas. It is essential for researchers of this family to refer to the Stewarts in Glen Finglas page for a full introduction to the Stewarts who resided in Glen Finglas.
This line is being researched by Susan Sauv� and Mairead Connor Conan.
In 1620 Glen Finglas was subdivided into eight landholdings. The Gartnafuaran family received two of those portions. It is believed that portions were a half-interest in each of the properties of Duart and Grodich. The Gartnafuaran share of Glen Finglas would have been granted initially to the head of the family, who would have been Alexander Stewart, 5th of Gartnafuaran (or possibly his father). The Glen Finglas properties, along with the other Gartnafuaran properties would have been distributed amongst Alexander's sons. From evidence explained below, it would appear that the Glen Finglas properties were given to Alexander's youngest son, Alexander Dubh Oig Stewart, whose name means "Young Black Alexander". Young Black Alexander is believed to be the patriarch of this branch of Stewarts.
Stewarts of the South accounts for this branch as follows:
"Sliochd Sheun Rob is Alastair Oig two brothers about three generations ago they came from Wester Invernenty in Balquhidder. formerly the property of the family of Gartnafuare, afterwards that of Glenbuckie & Brainchoil, and now the property of the heirs of the late Red Duncan Stewart, Minister of Balquhidder.
1 Line
The descendants of Sean Rob [are] (judging by the chronology of 2 Line, it is suggested that the following are the grandchildren of Sean Rob.)
Robert, [a] tenant in Duart [in] Glenfinglas, [who is] one of the eight tenants of the name of Stewart in that place, and [who] pays rent of one hundred guineas. [He] left four sons:
- Thomas emigrated some time ago to North America and had a large family
- Alan in the West Indies [who is] doing well
- John, [who] possesses the farm which his father had. [He is an] active [and] well-doing young man. Unmarried.
- Robert, a cattle-dealer in Glenfinglas. Unmarried
Robert Stewart, formerly [a] tenant of Auchinaird (Auchnahard) [in] Glenfinglas [and] again of Coillechat near Doune, [which is] Auchessy's property, and formerly belonged to the ancient family of Musket (Muschet). [This Robert is a] cousin to the former Robert. [He] left three sons:
- two in the West Indies
- "
- and the third [is a] schoolmaster at Bannockburn near Stirling
There was another cousin of his, a Duncan Stewart, who resided at Balfron, Stirlingshire as a cotton spinner, and who formerly lived at Bailechoalish [in] Appin [in] Argyleshire. [He] left two sons:
- the one a shoemaker,
- the other a tailor,
who have both families - two sons each under age who now live in Balfron.
John Stewart, late innkeeper [at] Easter Bridge of Turk [on the] Earl of Moray's property, [in] Callander parish [at the] foot of Glenfinglas. [He was] formerly a soldier and pensioner, [and] left two sons, [namely]
- James (sic), [an] innkeeper [in] Callendar who has one son
- Alexander, [a] crofter, under McFarlane of Coillechra [in] Callendar parish and on Loch Catherineside who has also one son.
2 Line
James, [a] brother to "Sean Rob" came to Glenfinglas about three generations back (ca. 1720) and became tacksman of Grodich at Glenfinglas
- His grandson, Alexander Stewart, [a] tenant in Grodich, left three sons
- Charles, [a] tenant of Garkechnie [on] Erskine of Cardross's estate [in] Port [of Menteith] Parish, Perth county, pay �40 of rent, who has four sons,
- two grown up to men, the one with himself and
- the other in the way of service
- two remaining under age
- "
- James, [the] second son of Alexander, and brother to Charles. [James was a] tacksman of Crochavie [in] Aberfoil parish [in the] Lordship of Mentieth! Duke of Montrose's property! pays �130 of rent!!! (not sure what's up with all the exclamation marks, but they are preserved from the original) who left five sons, [namely]
- Alexander, who died last year, one of my most familiar acquaintances on earth, and a very great favourite, a clever [and] active man and a good scholar
- Charles, the present tacksman of Crochavie, a person who might well pass in the Golden Age! (reference uncertain) If all men were of his disposition there would be no occasion for many of abilities either in the cabinet or in the field - the lamb might eat with the wolf [and so on]. I intend to spend the remainder of my life with him so being that he marries a woman of a similar disposition to himself.
- Duncan, master gardener with Mr Peel Member of Parlaiment [for] South Wales. He also superintends the farming and is a very clever active man. Few may be said to excel him. He is unmarried.
- Robert (the subsequent reference indicates that he lives with his brother Charles)
- John, [who is] of a second marriage. [He and his brother Robert] live with their brother Charles.
I have been acquainted with their father and grandfather for the period of thirty five years.
- Duncan, [a] brother to James Stewart, [is a] tenant of Crochavie was tacksman of Lochend [in] Perth County, [in] Port [of Menteith] Parish, [on] Erskine of Cardross' [estate]. [Duncan is] a respectable farmer [and has] three sons [who are] under age. [He pays] �120 rent.
- Alexander Stewart that was in Grodich, had a brother who was [a] tenant in Auchinaird [in] Glenfinglas, who left a son called
- Robert, late resident in Gartmore. This Robert left four sons, [namely]
- one a printer in Campsie who has a family of three sons under age
- another a printer at Bonhill [in] Dunbartonshire who has a family of two sons
- another at the Shaws near Glasgow
- and another who is a soldier serving in Ireland and has a large family
Several problems arise in trying to interpret this entry from Stewarts of the South. Firstly, the name of this branch does not make sense: Sliochd Sheun Rob 'is Alastair Oig. Sliochd means "seed" or "descendants". Sean means "old" and Oig means "young". The Gaelic word "is" (pronounced "eesh") means exactly the same as its same-spelled English counterpart: "is". So the full name of this clan translates literally to "Descendants of Old Rob (who) is Young Alexander." This makes no grammatical sense. How could Old Rob be the same person as Young Alexander? The Gaelic word is is also used sometimes as an abbreviation of agus which means "and". This would make the clan name "Descendants of Old Rob and Young Alexander" which makes much more grammatical sense, especially when the next words in the text are "two brothers". We could suggest that this branch was named after two brothers: Old Rob and Young Alexander. But such a suggestion presents us with other interpretive problems. Firstly, we have no record of any other cadet branch being named after two people. Secondly the text that follows further on would seem to suggest that the founding brothers in Glen Finglas were Sean Rob and his brother James (patriarchs of lines 1 & 2 above) -- not Alexander. The absence of punctuation in the original document further compounds our interpretation. Should the original be interpreted as:
"Sliochd Sheun Rob 'is Alastair Oig, two brothers. About three generations ago they came from Wester Invernenty..."
or
"Sliochd Sheun Rob 'is Alastair Oig. Two brothers -- about three generations ago they came from Wester Invernenty..."
Our preference is to follow the second of these renderings and interpret the two brothers as Sean Rob and James (as noted above). So what is the relationship between Sean Rob and Alastair Oig?
Another possibility is that is is an error for 'ic which is an abbreviation for mhic which is another form of mac and means "son of". (Mhic is usually used in patronymics when several generations are listed. On its own it is also used sometimes as a generic "descendant of".) If this is the case then the clan name would mean "Old Rob, son of (or descendant of) Young Alexander." This makes sense grammatically and is much more in keeping with customary naming. However, we have viewed the original document and there's no question that the original hand-written text contains an 's', not a 'c'. Thus, such error must have been committed by the original author and cannot be blamed as a transcription error.
As uncomfortable as it is to call into doubt the spelling or the Gaelic of the original author, 'ic remains the only rendering that makes sense given the rest of the entry (above) and the external evidence from old parish records and monumental inscriptions.
This brings us immediately to our next challenge: who are Old Rob and his father/ancestor, Young Alexander? The term oig is also used in two ways. It can be understood as "Young Alexander" or "Alexander The Younger". The first rendering is often used two distinguish between a father and son who have the same first name -- thus, "Alexander and his son Young Alexander". Whereas the designation "The Younger" is often used of landed families to indicate a younger son who is eligible to inherit the estate. In our present case it would appear that both interpretations fit.
The most likely candidate for Alastair Oig is Alexander Stewart, the youngest son of Alexander Stewart, 5th of Gartnafuaran (as noted above). This Alexander (The Younger) is identified in the Gilderoy Trial documents as "Alasdair Dubh". Thus we have combined his two nicknames to identify him as Alasdair Dubh Oig Stewart.
Identifying Alasdair Dubh Oig Stewart, son of Alexander Stewart, 5th of Gartnafuaran, as the source of the patronymic name of this clan makes chronological sense too given that Alexander Sr. is the most likely recipient of the Gartnafuaran portion of Glen Finglas. And when we compare the description in Stewarts of the South against OPR data then it would appear most likely that Sean Rob was his son, not a later descendant.
Mitchell's Monumental Inscriptions presents the following entries from Kilmahog Cemetery that pertain to this family:
44 Robert STEWART farmer (in) Duart (in) Glenfinglas, died 16 AUG 1818, age 85, by son John in Duart, pelican plucking its breast, rake, scythe, share and coulter, emblems of mortality. (Mitchell notes: MacGregor notes �per Mrs Stewart in Milton, the three families (in inscriptions 44-46) Alexander STEWART who had Auchnahard and left Glenfinglas was brother of John (grandfather of STEWART of Milton,)�) [This would be Alexander who moved to Glasgow]
45 1878. Robert STEWART 18 AUG 1818, age 85, wife Janet FISHER 27 DEC 1829, age 73, son John in Duart 31 JAN 1871, age 80, daughter Sybla 22 NOV 1836, age 40, son Robert 2 MAY 1883, age 89. (Mitchell notes: MacGregor notes that this family was not related to the other STEWARTS in Duart.)
46 1793. pelican plucking its breast, in her nest (crest of the STEWART family). John STEWART and Mary MCINTYRE.
And in Port of Menteith Cemetery:
44 James BUCHANAN, wife Jane STEWART, 9 MAY 1834, age 26, mother Jane SANDS died (at) Stirling 23 JAN 1860, age 83, daughter Mary 14 JUL 1843, age 13.
45 Duncan STEWART and Mary SANDS in Lochend, daughter Elizabeth 7 MAR 1826, age 15.
46 (next to 45) Duncan STEWART died (at) Lochend 1828, wife Mary SANDS died 1857, seven children.
47 (next to 46) 1834. Charles STEWART, 2 SEP 1833, age 31.
Combining the information above with OPR data (and supplemented with IGI data where we have not yet had the opportunity to view the OPR films) we present the following accounting of the Gartnafuaran Stewarts who resided in Duart and Grodich.
This study presents only the Scottish male line descendants until the point of emigration. Further information on female lines and North American descendants of this line can be found in Susan Sauve's report: Journal Report for Robert Stewart (1733-1818) and Three Generations of Descendants.
Glen Finglas Reservoir viewed from the south end of Duart
� Copyright
Colin
Smith and licensed for reuse under this
Creative Commons Licence.
Alexander Dubh Oig STEWART, b: ABT 1610 in Gartnafueran, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, son of Alexander STEWART, 5th of Gartnafuaran. Alexander Stewart, is probably the Allester Dow Stewart mentioned in the 1636 Trial of Gilderoy (although the The Edward S. Gray Papers say Allester Dow was Alexander�s father, Alexander). The trial records state that Gilderoy�s party broke into and stole articles from the dwelling house of Allester Dow Stewart at �Gartnafarrow.� James Stewart of Ardvorlich served on the jury in this trial. (Memorials of Troubles in Scotland, Spalding Club, vol. I, p.437). It is suggested that Alexander Dubh MAY be the Alexander Stewart, patriarch of this branch. It seems most likely that the Gartnafuaran portion of Glenfinglas would have been given to the head of the family at that time, namely Alexander Stewart, 5th of Gartnafuaran. He would have doled out his properties amongst his sons rather than giving the Glenfinglas property to a nephew or cousin. Thus the later Duart family in Glenfinglas most likely descends from a son of Alexander Stewart, 5th of Gartnafuaran. The present arrangement seems most likely given onomastics and chronology.Alexander's identity is inferred from our interpretation of the patronymic of this clan. It is believed that he was called Alasdair Oig ("Young Alexander") to differentiate him from his father. Alexander's spouse is unknown. He is suggested as the father of:
Sean Robert mhic Alasdair Oig STEWART , 3rd in Duart b: ABT 1650 in
Wester Invernenty, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, shown above as a son of
Alastair Dubh Oig Stewart in Duart and Grodich. Robert is described in
Stewarts of the South as: "Sliochd Sheun Rob 'ic Alastair Oig. Two
brothers -- about three generations ago they came from Wester Invernenty in
Balquhidder, formerly the property of the family of Gartnafuare...."
Robert was known as "Sean Rob 'ic Alasdair Oig", which means "Old Rob, son of
Young Alexander". This reference implies that Robert was born in Wester
Invernenty in Balquhidder parish which property was held by the main branch of
the Gartnafuaran Stewarts. He is described as coming to Duart in Glen
Finglas "about three generations ago" from an entry written ca. 1815. This
means he probably came to Duart somewhere around 1710-1720 which corresponds
closely with the date of the death of his nephew Alexander Stewart, 2nd in
Duart. It is believed that Alexander's young son either did not survive, or for
some other reason did not inherit Duart. Robert would have been next in
line and it is believed that this was the cause of his coming to Glen Finglas to
settle in Duart. It is suggested that he is most likely the "Robert
Stewart in Glenfinglas" who was one of the tutors to his brother's grandson,
Alexander Stewart in Duart, in 1708 (see above). The fact that Robert may
have been as old as 60 or 70 at the time of his arrival in Duart may be the
source of his nickname, "Sean" ("Old").
Stewarts of the South shows four lines of male descendants from Robert, three of whom are described as "cousins". Chronology would suggest that they are most likely grandsons of Sean Rob, thus Sean Rob must have had at least three surviving sons. Robert's wife is unknown and his sons are not known for certain. They are merely inferred from the references in Stewarts of the South. It is suggested that Robert was the father of:
Alexander Stewart, son of John Stewart in Easter Brig o' Turk is shown at left as having been a crofter under "McFarlane of Coillechra". This would be Hugh MCFARLANE Of Coilachra, probably born 1 SEP 1770 and baptized 4 SEP 1770 in Callander as the son of Hugh McFarlane and Mary McFarlane. Hugh married on 7 and 12 FEB 1801 in Aberfoyle and Callander to Ann STEWART, b. ABT 1770 in Aberfoyle, Perthshire, Scotland, in which they are described as "Hugh McFarlane Esq of Coillechea in this parish and Ann Stewart in the parish of Aberfoil". They had the following family:
It's intriguing to note that Hugh McFarlane marred a Stewart. Could she be related to this family and thus be the means by which Alexander Stewart became a crofter in Coillechra under McFarlane? The answer to this question will have to be left to future research, but a promising birth family for Ann is found here:
James STEWART and Katharine STEWART
John's marriage is incorrectly recorded in the IGI. The marriage as shown here is from Malcolm Gray's transcriptions. John is recorded as "in Aberfoyle parish" and Mary as "in this parish" (Callander). The marriage and children shown here are not confirmed. Whether John's suggested wife, Mary McFarlane was related to Hugh McFarlane of Coillachra has not been determined. (See side note above for information on McFarlane of Coillachra.)
If we have correctly accounted for this branch then John's eldest son's name is incorrectly recorded in Stewarts of the South as "James" instead of "John".
John is believed to have married on 14 AND 30 APR 1750 in Aberfoyle and Callander, Perthshire, Scotland to Mary MCFARLANE b: ABT 1725 in Callander, Perthshire, Scotland. John Stewart and Mary McFarlane had the following children:
Thus it is presently suggested that this John Stewart is incorrectly accounted in Stewarts of the South as "James (sic), [an] innkeeper [in] Callendar who has one son".
Coillechat
www.multimap.com
Robert STEWART , in Coillechat b: ABT 1720 in Callander, Perthshire,
Scotland. Robert is described in Stewarts of the South as:
"Robert Stewart, formerly [a] tenant of Auchinaird (Auchnahard) [in]
Glenfinglas [and] again of Coillechat near Doune, [which is] Auchessy's
property, and [the property] formerly belonged to the ancient family of
Musket (Muschet). [This Robert is a] cousin to the former Robert. [He] left
three sons: two in the West Indies and the third [is a] schoolmaster at
Bannockburn near Stirling." Robert and his sons have not been identified in
parish records.
Only two matches for a Margaret dtr of Robert in Kilmadock or Callander. The first is Robert Stewart younger of Glassingall and can be eliminated. The other is:
Robert STEWART and Catharine STEWART in DUART
The following Stewart births are recorded in the Kilmadock OPR as having taken place in Coillechat and may be related to this branch, but have not been accounted for.
Alexander STEWART and Katherine BUCHANAN, m 8 MAR 1749 in Callander, both in this parish
James STEWART and Katherine STEWART from Aberfoyle, m 22 AUG 1749 in Callander (Kath from Aberfoyle)
James STEWART and Ann STEWART from Callander, m 30 NOV/5 DEC 1782 in Kilmadock and Callander (James from Kilmadock and Ann from Callander)
Robert STEWART and Ann CLARK, m 27 NOV 1784 in Kilmadock (MacGregor claims this family for Invernahyle Line 2, but that is chronologically challenging and may be confused with another Haldane son of Robert.)
Robert BUCHANAN and Mary STEWART
Robert STEWART, 5th in Lower Duart b: 1733 in Duart, Glenfinglas, Callander,
Perthshire, Scotland, shown above as the son of "James" Stewart, 4th in Duart.
Robert was one of the eight Stewart tenants in Glenfinglas at the beginning of
the 19th century. Stewarts of the South and the Callander OPR give his
residence as Duart (often spelled "Dowart" in old records). However
private family records give the residence as "Tynamore" which is an Anglicized
spelling of the Gaelic Tighnamor, which simply means "big house". It
therefore seems most likely that this family of Stewarts lived in "the big
house" at Duart, as opposed to the Invernahyle Stewarts who resided in
Upper Duart and who presumably
lived in a smaller house. The reference to the "Big House" would further suggest that this Robert was the
senior tenant of Duart. Robert had an almost incomprehensibly large family.
Mrs. Stewart of Milton's account says: "In Lower Duart, the old man, I don�t know his name, was three times married, and had about twenty of a family. The only ones I recollect of were John and Robert both of whom were batchelors. Some probably went to America for Charles a nephew of theirs came from American and stayed with them. The rest of the family except John and Robert had left before I knew them." This is the only indication of any distinction between Lower Duart and Upper Duart.
Robert is described in Stewarts of the South as follows:
Robert, [a] tenant in Duart [in] Glenfinglas, [who is] one of the eight tenants of the name of Stewart in that place, and [who] pays rent of one hundred guineas. [He] left four sons:
1. Thomas (sic) emigrated some time ago to North America and had a large family
2. Alan in the West Indies [who is] doing well
3. John, [who] possesses the farm which his father had. [He is an] active [and] well-doing young man. Unmarried.
4. Robert, a cattle-dealer in Glenfinglas. Unmarried
Stewarts of the South records Robert's eldest (surviving) son as "Thomas", however this is an error for Charles. It seems likely that "Chas" has been misread as "Thos" in the transcription.
Mitchell's Monumental Inscriptions records Robert and his family in Kilmahog Cemetery:
44 Robert STEWART farmer (in) Duart (in) Glenfinglas, died 16 AUG 1818, age 85, by son John in Duart, pelican plucking its breast, rake, scythe, share and coulter, emblems of mortality. (Mitchell notes: MacGregor notes �per Mrs Stewart in Milton, the three families (in inscriptions 44-46) Alexander STEWART who had Auchnahard and left Glenfinglas was brother of John (grandfather of STEWART of Milton,)�) [This would be Alexander who moved to Glasgow]
45 1878. Robert STEWART 18 AUG 1818, age 85, wife Janet FISHER 27 DEC 1829, age 73, son John in Duart 31 JAN 1871, age 80, daughter Sybla 22 NOV 1836, age 40, son Robert 2 MAY 1883, age 89. (Mitchell notes: MacGregor notes that this family was not related to the other STEWARTS in Duart.)
46 1793. pelican plucking its breast, in her nest (crest of the STEWART family). John STEWART and Mary MCINTYRE.
The chronology in Stewarts of the South would seem to indicate that this Robert was the eldest grandson of "Sean Rob" from whom this branch derives its patronymic. Robert married firstly on 1 FEB 1759 in Kilmadock, Perthshire, Scotland to Isabella DOW b: ABT 1735 in Perthshire, Scotland. Isabella's birth family has not been identified. Her surname is probably an Anglicization of the Gaelic name "Dubh" which means "black" and is pronounced as "doo", "doof", or "doov". It can be Anglicized as "Dow", "Duff", "Dove", and other variants. Robert and Isabella had the following huge family:
Likely grandson of Archibald MCLAREN farmer at Blairgarry, 1720-1812. wife Janet MCFARLAND, 1746-APR 1830), bur Kilmahog #24
Mitchell notes Balq OPR Mary b 1822, Margt b 1820
Janet Stewart married on 13 AUG 1819 in Drymen, Stirling, Scotland to William CAMPBELL b: ABT 1780 in Scotland. They had the following family:
Apparently sixteen children wasn't enough for Robert (albeit not all of them survived). Robert married secondly on 29 DEC 1789 in Callander, Perthshire, Scotland to Janet FISHER b: 1756 in Scotland. Janet's birth family has not been identified. Robert and Janet had the following children:
Testament of Robert Stewart, d. 3 May 1883 at Duart. Charles Stewart, his grandnephew who was residing with him at the time the will was written, was to be Robert�s executor and sole heir with certain exceptions: Robert Campbell, nephew, also residing with him at Duart: L 420; Isabella Campbell or Home, niece, sometime residing at Woodend Lodge, Buchanan, now in Glasgow, sister of said Robert Campbell: L 140; Robert Campbell, nephew, shoemaker, Bridge of Turk: L 150; John Bruce, nephew, now or lately at 102 Hospital Street, Hutchestown (?), Glasgow: L 150; James Stewart, son of my nephew the late Robert Stewart and residing at Kippen, Cardross, Moss: L 35; Janet Campbell, niece, residing at Bridge of Turk: L 19, 19 shillings. This was written 13 Dec 1879. Witnesses: James Stewart, farmer, Duart, Glenfinglass; William McMichael
Later codicils provided for changes and re-distributions of inheritances:
Signed 4 Dec 1880, he provided that the legacy to John Bruce be revoked stating that he had given it to him before he left for America; reduced the amount to go to Robert Campbell, shoemaker; increased the amount to the Robert Campbell who resided with him; and increased the amount to Isabella Campbell.
Signed 2 Feb 1882, he noted that both his niece, Janet Campbell, who had resided at Bridge of Turk and his nephew, Robert Campbell, shoemaker, had died and their legacies were now lapsed. He increased the inheritances for his nephew, Robert Campbell at Duart, and his niece Isabella Campbell or Hume who was also residing with him at Duart and who he noted as Robert�s sister.
Signed 4 Jan 1883, he increased the amounts he would designate for Robert and Isabella Campbell.
The inventory of his estate showed that he owed the Earl of Moray � years rent at the time of his death. Charles Stewart was listed as the manager of his farm. James Stewart as the shepherd, and John McMartin as a shepherd. Charles Stewart, farmer, Duart, signed a disposition that Robert Stewart had had no children. Net estate after debts were paid was L 2,600.
Registered at Dunblane, 8 Jun 1883, Inventories of the Commissariot of the Western District of Perthshire, pages 319-345.
Grodich in Glen Finglas (now submerged). (Grodich = Grod Achadh =
"Ugly Field")
The former settlement of Grodich would have been just beyond the islet.
� Copyright
Dannie
Calder and licensed for reuse under this
Creative Commons Licence.
James STEWART ,1st in Grodich b: ABT 1655 in Wester Invernenty,
Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, shown above as the son of Alexander Dubh Oig
Stewart in Duart and Grodich. James is recorded in Stewarts of the
South as "James, [a] brother to "Sean Rob" came to Glenfinglas about three
generations back (ca. 1720) and became tacksman of Grodich at Glenfinglas".
James is also believed to be the "James Stewart in Glenfinglas" who was one of
the tutors to his brother's grandson, Alexander Stewart in Duart, in 1708 (see
above). James' wife is unknown. James is believed to be the father
of:
There are two reasonable candidates in the Port of Menteith OPR (where Gartmore is located) for Robert Stewart in Gartmore. Both of them have an eldest son named James. These two Roberts were married in 1757 and 1773, making their births likely in the range of 1710-1750. In searching the Callander OPR for a Robert Stewart, son of James Stewart, born in Auchnahard within that range we find there is indeed one such entry: Robert Stewart, son of James Stewart in Auchnahard, born and baptized on 30 SEP 1724 (there is no mother's name given in the entry). This entry almost certainly must be the birth of Robert Stewart in Gartmore. If so, then the chronology shown in Stewarts of the South cannot be correct.
Stewarts of the South claims that James Stewart, tenant in Auchnahard, was the brother of Alexander Stewart in Grodich. What seems chronologically more likely is that James was the brother of Alexander's father as we presently show here. James had one son:
There was another Robert Stewart recorded in Stewarts of the South as residing in Gartmore with four sons at the same time as this one. The other Robert Stewart was from the Edraleachdach family (Glenbuckie). Future careful research will be required to correctly distinguish between these two families.
Robert had the following children:
*NOTE - There was another Robert Stewart in Gartmore at the same time as this one and who also had four sons.
John? STEWART , 2nd in Grodich b: ABT 1685 in Grodich, Glenfinglas,
Callander, Perthshire, Scotland. John's actual first name is not known for
sure. What is known is that he had a son, Alexander, who was the grandson of
James Stewart, 1st in Grodich. He had the following children:
Possible births:
Alexander STEWART, b/b 26/31 DEC 1716 in Ardcheanochdan, s/o John STEWART and
Janet STEWART. This one looks very promising, especially given that his
first son was born in Ardcheanochdan, and it appears that this Alexander does
not belong to the Ardcheanochdan family above.
Alexander STEWART, b/b 13/16 FEB 1719 in Milntown of Strathgartney, s/o John
STEWART and Jean BUCHANAN
Alexander is presumed to have married Elizabeth STEWART b: ABT 1720 in Scotland, although no record of their marriage has been found. They had the following children:
There are two reasonable candidates in the Port of Menteith OPR (where Gartmore is located) for Robert Stewart in Gartmore. Both of them have an eldest son named James. These two Roberts were married in 1757 and 1773, making their births likely in the range of 1710-1750. In searching the Callander OPR for a Robert Stewart, son of James Stewart, born in Auchnahard within that range we find there is indeed one such entry: Robert Stewart, son of James Stewart in Auchnahard, born and baptized on 30 SEP 1724. This entry almost certainly must be the birth of Robert Stewart in Gartmore. If so, then the chronology shown in Stewarts of the South cannot be correct.
Stewarts of the South claims that James Stewart, tenant in Auchnahard, was the brother of Alexander Stewart in Grodich. What seems chronologically more likely is that James was the brother of Alexander's father. (As shown above.)
Mrs Stewart of Milton says
Of the Grodich Stewarts who left Grodich and came to Auchnahard, there were three of the name of John in succession � grandfather, father and son. That family eventually went to Aberdeen and became wine merchants there.
Alexander Stewart in Auchnahard had at least three sons:
1. James who married Cath. Stewart from Edinburgh � he was in the Braes of Balquhidder
2. John who was in the Braes afterwards. John died unmarried in 1872. He at one time managed farms in Glenlyon for his uncles. They had Cashlie & Auch. John then came to Lanrick and afterwards went to the Braes.
3. Charles
From Stewarts of Auchnahard:
Alexander STEWART in Auchnahard, b. ABT 1715 in Glen Finglas,
Callander, Perthshire, Scotland. No record of Alexander's birth has been
found. Mitchell's Monumental Inscriptions quotes Mrs. Stewart of Milton who recalled: "Alexander
STEWART who had Auchnahard and left
Glengfinglas was brother (-in-law?*) of John (grandfather of
STEWART of Milton)" John Stewart of Milton was a grandson of John Ban Mor STEWART by his son Robert Ban Mor. Alexander would have left
Glenfinglas ca 1745. However, this entry is noted in connection with
Robert STEWART in Duart 1733-1818 of
Gartnafuaran Branch IV. No other
evidence has been found to show the existence of Alexander. Onomastics
would suggest that he'd likely be a younger brother of John Ban Mor.
The
timing of his departure from Glen Finglas would strongly suggest that he was a
Jacobite who fled after The '45. It's also likely that he was not
married before leaving. If he had any descendants they would be
extremely hard to trace.
Alexander STEWART and Bettrice STEWART in Auchnahard, m 14 DEC 1742 or 18 MAY 1747 in Callander (both entries say "both in this parish")
*Old Scots custom did not distinguish between "brother" and "brother-in-law". The term "brother" was was used for both. If "full brother" was intended then the term "brother german" was used. When the term "brother" was used it could refer to full brother, half-brother, or brother-in-law.
I now suspect that Beatrix Stewart was the daughter of John Ban Mor and she married Alexander Stewart who may have been "in Bochastle" and of the Edraleachdach Family (Glenbuckie Branch V) or Gartnafuaran Branch IV. If it was Alexander in Bochastle then he could be said to have "left Glen Finglas" for Bochastle and Milton of Cambus.
This family is being discussed here: http://www.hostmybb.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?p=1648&mforum=stewart#1648
Alexander STEWART , 3rd in Grodich b: BET 1712 AND 1719 in Callander,
Perthshire, Scotland. Two possible births have been identified for this
Alexander ranging from 1712-1719 all with John as a father, but none with Robert
as a father. The first son shown below could be from a different family -- it's
hard to tell. It's also possible that Alexander was "out" in The '45 which would
explain the seven year gap between the first and second children. That no
marriage record can be found hampers our ability to determine if John Stewart
1743 belongs to this family or another.
Possible births:
Alexander STEWART, b/b 26/31 DEC 1716 in Ardcheanochdan, s/o John STEWART and
Janet STEWART. This one looks very promising, especially given that his
first son was born in Ardcheanochdan, and it appears that this Alexander does
not belong to the Ardcheanochdan family above.
Alexander STEWART, b/b 13/16 FEB 1719 in Milntown of Strathgartney, s/o John
STEWART and Jean BUCHANAN
Alexander is presumed to have married Elizabeth STEWART b: ABT 1720 in
Scotland, although no record of their marriage has
been found (actually at least three marriages have been found). Her birth
family has not been identified. They had the following children:
Charles is recorded in Stewarts of the South as: "Charles, [a] tenant of Garkechnie [on] Erskine of Cardross's estate [in] Port [of Menteith] Parish, Perth county, pay �40 of rent, who has four sons, two grown up to men, the one with himself and the other in the way of service, two remaining under age." OPR records indicate that Charles lived most of his early life in Grodich in Glenfinglas and that he and his wife and their young children did not move to Garkechnie until about 1800.
Charles married on 7 AND 10 AUG 1784 in Balquhidder and Callander, Perthshire, Scotland to Margaret STEWART b: ABT 3 MAR 1765 in Lichscridan, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, daughter of Patrick Stewart, 7th of Lednascriddan. They had the following children:
James Stewart in Chrochavie married secondly on 13 AND 24 JAN 1798 in Aberfoyle and Callander, Perthshire, Scotland to Janet STEWART b: ABT 1770 in Aberfoyle, Perthshire, Scotland. Her birth family has not been identified. The Callander OPR records James' second marriage: James STEWART in this parish and Jannet STEWART in the parish of Aberfoil enlisted for proclamation in order to marriage 14th and were married the 24th January 1798. James and Janet had the following children:
Robert Stewart is listed in Mitchell's Monumental Inscriptions in Brig o' Turk cemetery: 4. Robert STEWART, Culnagrein, died 60 JUN 1881, age 82, wife Margaret DRUMMOND, 28 JAN 1863, age 65, three children: Jane 31 JAN 1842, age 18, only son James, 28 MAY 1845, age 13, Isabella, 13 FEB 1852, age 15; Elizabeth, 23 JUL 1904, age 65.
Robert is referred to in Malcolm Gray's notes as "of Offerings" (sic, Offerans on Loch Vennacher). The source of this reference is unknown but is presumably from family records.
Robert married on 26 MAY 1827 in Callander, Perthshire, Scotland to Margaret DRUMMOND b: 1798 in Callander, Perthshire, Scotland, daughter of Duncan Drummond and Mary Stewart (daughter of James Stewart in Invercarnaig of the Stewarts of Auchnahard. They had the following children:
Mary Stewart later married on 1 JUL 1857 in Kilmichael, Glassary, Argylle, Scotland to Duncan CAMPBELL b: 1838 in Dalavich, Argyll, Scotland. They had the following children:
This John is believed to be the one referred to by Mrs Stewart of Milton as the latter of the two: "There were two Stewart families in Grodich. The earlier family are those who eventually went to Aberdeen. The latter went to Strathyre -- of this family was John who was nearly 100 when he died."
Duncan is recorded in Mitchell's Monumental Inscriptions for Port of Menteith Cemetery: "46 (next to 45) Duncan STEWART died (at) Lochend 1828, wife Mary SANDS died 1857, seven children." He is buried with his wife and adjacent to his daughters Elizabeth and Jean/Jane, and his nephew Charles. This reference indicates that they had seven (surviving) children. As there are 11 births recorded for this couple then we must presume that four of their children died young. We know that daughters Elizabeth and Jean/Jane predeceased their parents. Whether they are included among the seven referenced on their parents' gravestone is unclear. The fact that only one of the children of this family can be found in later census records may indicate that the remainder of the family emigrated.
Duncan Stewart is presumed to have married Mary SANDS b: 1770 in Kilmadock, Perthshire, Scotland, although no record of their marriage has been found. They had the following children:
James Buchanan married secondly on 16 DEC 1836 in Port of Menteith, Perthshire and Balfron, Stirlingshire, Scotland to Janet CAMERON b: 1803 in Port of Menteith, Perthshire, Scotland. Their descendants are beyond the scope of this research project.
Alexander Stewart, b 1838 in Kincardine was residing in 1851 with William Stewart, son of Duncan Stewart in Lochend (above). The only matching Alexander Stewart born in Kincardine is the following:
Alexander Stewart and Christian Gow (all births in Kincardine by Doune, Perthshire, Scotland)
1831 March 13 John, son to Alexr Stewart and Christian Gow.
1833 May 12 Kathrine, dr to Alexr Stewart and Christian Gow.
1835 Octr 25 Daniel, son to Alexr Stewart and Christian Gow.
1837 Octr 22 Alexr, son to Alexr Stewart and Christian Gow.
Two possible families can be identified for Robert Stewart in Gartmore, each with identical male onomastics. However the first of these has already been identified with the Stewarts in Edraleachdanch.
Robert STEWART and Elizabeth MCFARLANE, m 24 MAR 1757 in Aberfoyle
- Agnes STEWART, bap 13 FEB 1758 in Aberfoyle
- James STEWART, bap 29 JAN 1762 in Aberfoyle
- George STEWART, b/b 5/6 AUG 1764 in Letter, Callander
- David STEWART, bap 12 APR 1767 in Port of Menteith
- (Patrick STEWART, b abt 1770)
Robert STEWART and Margaret TAYLOR, m 7 DEC 1773 in Port of Menteith and Kippen, Stirling, Scotland. -- This one seems to be the best match
- Helen STEWART, bap 22 DEC 1774 in Port of Menteith
- James STEWART, bap 26 OCT 1776 in Port of Menteith
- George STEWART, bap 27 OCT 1778 in Port of Menteith
- William STEWART, bap 29 NOV 1780 in Port of Menteith
- Robert STEWART, bap 8 OCT 1788 in Port of Menteith
- John STEWART, bap 8 OCT 1788 in Port of Menteith
- David STEWART, bap 17 JUL 1792 in Port of Menteith
Another Robert Stewart can be found in Port of Menteith, but only one son can be found for him, whereas Robert in Gartmore had four sons.
Robert STEWART possibly m to Mary WRIGHT, 28 MAY 1781 in Port of Menteith
- Christian STEWART, bap 5 AUG 1782 in Port of Menteith
- Alexander STEWART, bap 23 MAY 1784 in Port of Menteith
- Margaret STEWART, bap OCT 1786 in Port of Menteith
The most promising candidate for Robert Stewart in Gartmore is the one who married Margaret Taylor (above). His eldest son is named James. An excellent match can be found for his birth with Robert STEWART, b/b 30/30 SEP 1724 in Auchnahard, son of James Stewart in Auchnahard (with no mother's name given). The challenge is that, if correct, Robert would have been 50 when he married and nearly 70 when his last child was born.
Charles Stewart, son of Duncan Stewart in Lochend can be found in later census records with the following family residing nearby (on the same census page):
Margaret STEWART, b 1784 in Port of Menteith, residing 1851 at 7 Monievrachie, P of M with Catherine STEWART (lodger) b 1845 in P of M and Mary MACFARLANE b 1809 in Pof M. all are paupers, next door to Charles STEWART (above) at #8
next entry:
Marjory STEWART (nee MacMillan) b 1824 in Pof M, res 1851 Stonefield PofM, dtr of widow Janet MacMillan b 1797 in Aberfoyle1841 - next on page with Charles above is Marion STEWART, b 1826 in Perthshire, res at Garnabrind No 1 with Margaret Buchanan age 90 b 1751 in Perthshire and Janet McMillan b 1796 in Perthshire (same family as above)
William STEWART, b 1799 in PofM, res 1851 Gartmore, ag lab, wife Margaret, b 1805 in St. Ninians Stirling
- Christina S, 1828 in PofM
- David S, 1832 in Pof M, ag lab
Mary STEWART, b 1761 in Balq, res1851 Gartmore, farmers widow (age 90),
- res with dtr Mary STEWART, b 1803 in Drymen, Stirling
Peter STEWART, 1802 in PofM, res 1851 Gartmore, sawyer (b 13/16 APR 1801 s/o James STEWART and Agnes MCNAB, or 13 FEB 1799 John Stewart and Margaret Blair))
The following Stewarts are found in Gartmore Cemetery:
23 Alexander STEWART in West Gartfarran (not to be confused with Gartnafuaran), died 1916, wife Catharine CLARK 1921, children: Anne 1880, John 1917, William 1935, Jane in South Africa 1946, Alexander 1937, James 1933, Arthur 1947, George 1926, Christina in Canada 1956, Alice 1967, by K. MCKINTYRE, died South Africa 1960.
24 (next to 23) William STEWART, 6 JAN 1867, age 68, wife Margaret MCALLISTER, 15 DEC 1879, age 78, daughter Helen, AUG 1844, age 4 years, son James JUL 1852, age 27, son David 20 APR 1855, age 22, daughter Jean 12 JUL 1899, age 52, daughter Christina 15 NOV 1891, age 64, (and her husband John HALDANE, merchant, 5 APR 1898, age 73).
62 John MONTGOMERY, 14 AUG 1882, age 78, wife Catharine STEWART, 24 JUN 1874, age 56, son Robert 1861, age 2 years, daughter Jane 19 OCT 1929, age 89, grandson Private John S. MONTGOMERY killed in action 21 MAR 1918, age 30. Duncan MONTGOMERY, 1 OCT 1920, age 19.
This family can be found in census records:
Cathrine Stewart, b 1816 in PofM, res Hill of Gartmore, m John Montgomery b 1805 PofM, mother Janet Stewart b 1791 in Gargunnock, Stirling
- Janet M, 1839
- Jean M, 1841
- Cathrine, 1843
- Duncan 1845
- Elis, 1848
- James, 1849
- Agnes, 1851
61 James MONTGOMERY, late farmer (at) Wester Third, died 3 APR 1864, age 62, sister Cathrine JAN 1832, age 33, brother Robert 9 FEB 1825, age 27. Duncan MONTGOMERY, farmer (at) Wester Third, died 19 FEB 1841, age 75, wife Jane STEWART, 1 NOV 1860, age 90.
54 John MCALLUM died (at) Gartmore 1836, age 70, wife Margaret STEWART, 1873, age 82, son John 1887 age59, by son Robert property agent in Glasgow.
From this entry we can construct the following family:
John MCCALLUM, b 1766 d 1836, and Margaret STEWART, b 1791
- John MCCALLUM, 1828
- Robert MCCALLUM, b 1830 in Monteith, res 1851 Gorbals, Lanark, gen lab, with family of widow Mary Campbell (McAllum)
- Mary MCCALLUM, b 15 JUL 1830 in Glasgow
- Mary McFarlane MCCALLUM, bap 19 DEC 1834 in Glasgow
They are found in 1851 in Gartmore:
Margaret STEWART, b 1792 in PofM, res 1851 Gartmore, spinner.
- Res with son John McAllum, 1828 in PofM
The best best matches for Margaret Stewart in the IGI are:
Robert STEWART and Mary WRIGHT
- Christian STEWART, bap 5 AUG 1782 in Port of Menteith
- Alexander STEWART, 23 MAY 1784 in Port of Menteith
- Margaret STEWART, OCT 1786 in Port of Menteith
or John STEWART and Margaret GRAHAM
- Margaret STEWART, b 6 JUN 1788 in PofM
James STEWART and Janet MCNAIR
James STEWART and Jean DUNCANSON
James STEWART and Agnes MCNAB
Alexander STEWART and Mary BLAIR
James STEWART and Janet FORRESTER
Possible Children of Robert Stewart in Gartmore
Robert STEWART and Jean TAYLOR, m 28 JAN 1746 in Bonhill, Dunbarton
Archibald STEWART and Janet Weir, m 14/21 1787 in Bonhill, Dunbarton (only birth for Arch s/o Peter is in Argyll)
Widow Mary STEWART, b 1799 in Ireland, res 1851 in Milton, Campsie, Stirling
Other Grodich births
James STEWART and Mary STEWART in Grodich
James STEWART and Isobel WRIGHT/MCINTYRE
Duncan STEWART and Jean STEWART in Groiddoch
James STEWART in Grodich
Donald STEWART and Janet MCGREGOR in Grodich
John STEWART and Jean STEWART in Groddich
Robert STEWART and Christian STEWART in Grodich
Duncan STEWART and Anne STEWART in Grodich
Donald STEWART and Christian MCFARLANE in Groddich
John STEWART and Mary STEWART in Groddich
Possible Descendants of Sean Robert Stewart in Duart
Fellow researcher Belinda Dettman has transcribed the following family which seems certain to fit into the tree above at an undetermined location.
James STEWART in Duart, b. ABT 1700. He married Margaret STEWART 22 Nov 1733 Callander, Perthshire, Scotland. [Entry in the Callander baptismal (!) register says: 1733. James and Margaret Stewart both in this parish listed themselves to be proclaimed in order to marriage 10th November and after orderly proclamation got Extract thereof to be married by the Mins. of Balquhidder 22d of the said.] He may be the James Stewart referred to in The Ardvorlich History regarding John Buidhe Mor in Auchnahard where it says "another James S married his daughter." Thus his wife Margaret Stewart may be the daughter of John Buidhe Mor in Auchnahard, but she seems a generation late. Children of James Stewart in Dowart and Margaret Stewart were as follows:
Janet; born 8 Aug 1736 in Dowart, Callander, Perthshire, Scotland.
Johne; born 13 Aug 1740 in Dowart, Callander, Perthshire, Scotland.
Marrian; born 15 Jul 1743 Callander, Perthshire, Scotland.
Duncan; born 17 Mar 1750 in Dowart, Callander, Perthshire, Scotland.
The following reference from Mitchell's MIs indicates that this family is related to Robert Stewart in Duart, but this family has not been identified in Stewarts of the South:
46 1793. pelican plucking its breast, in her nest (crest of the STEWART family). John STEWART and Mary MCINTYRE.
There are two families who potentially match this description:
John STEWART and Mary MCINTYRE/WRIGHT, m 29 MAY 1769 in Aberfoyle
- Margart STEWART, 18 FEB/12 MAR 1770 in Culntogl (Wright)
- John STEWART, b/b 7/13 MAR 1774 in Ardcheanochdan, Callander. (McIntyre)
- Henny STEWART, 11/12 OCT 1777 in Creaghvan (Wright)
- Janet STEWART, 2/2 NOV 1779 in Creaghvan (Wright)
- James STEWART, 3/6 MAY 1781 in Creglevan (Wright)
- Mary STEWART, 3/7 SEP 1783 in Creglevan (Wright)
- Elizabeth STEWART, 9/9 SEP 1785 in Creaglevan (Wright)
John STEWART and Mary MCINTYRE in Dallanlaggan and Auchleskine, m. 18 FEB 1758 in Balquhidder parish (not in Fiona's transcriptions). (See also John Stewart earlier in Immereoin and note contemporary in Dallanlaggan)
- Margaret STEWART, bap. 17 JUL 1759 in Dallaggan
- Duncan STEWART, bap. 23 FEB 1761 in Dalaggan
- Patrick STEWART, bap. 21 MAR 1763 in Dallaggan
- David STEWART, bap. 20 JUL 1764 in Dallaggan of Glenbucky
- Alexander STEWART, bap. 11 MAR 1766 in Dallaggan
- Betterage STEWART, bap. 17 APR 1768 in Dallaggan of Glenbukie
- Duncan STEWART, bap. 19 NOV 1769 in Dallaggan
- Donald STEWART, bap. 30 APR 1772 in Dallagan of Glenbukie
- Jean STEWART, bap. 16 MAY 1774 in Dallaggan
- Elisabeth STEWART, bap. 22 JAN 1779 in Auchleskine
Other families of interest include:
James STEWART and Marjery STEWART in Duart
James STEWART and Mary MILLAR in Duart
Robert STEWART and Jean MCFARLANE
Alexander STEWART and Mary STEWART in Duart
Alexander STEWART and Margaret STEWART in Duart (may be same couple as previous)
Duncan STEWART and Margaret STEWART in Duart
Alexander STEWART and Janet STEWART in Auchnahard and Duart
Alexander Buchanan Isay STEWART and Catharine BUCHANAN in Duart
Alexander STEWART and Bettrice STEWART in Auchnahard
Robert STEWART and Catharine STEWART in Duart
Walter STEWART and Janet STEWART in Duart
James STEWART and Janet STEWART in Duart
James STEWART and Margaret STEWART in Duart
John STEWART and Janet GRAHAME-alias-MCGRIGOR in Auchnahard
Duncan STEWART and Mary STEWART in Auchnahard
Robert STEWART and Mary STEWART in Duart
Robert STEWART and Christian MCINNIS in Duart
Robert STEWART in "Duart of Glenfinglas" and Janet CAMERON
For more information on
any of the individual persons featured on this page
please click on the INDEX button below to enter Ryk Brown's online database,
then select the first letter of the surname you are
looking for.
The index button will take you to Ryk's searchable GEDCOM database
hosted by RootsWeb's World Connect Project.
= This person has known descendants.
ABT = "about" and is used in three ways:
Where it precedes a precise date of birth, such as "ABT 3 DEC 1855", then it means that the person was baptized on 3 DEC 1795, but his/her exact date of birth is unknown.
Where it precedes a semi-precise date of birth with the month only given, such as "ABT DEC 1855", then that means that the birth is recorded in the civil birth registrations for the quarter ending with that month. Thus the person's birth was registered sometime between the beginning of October 1855 and the end of December 1855, but no baptism record has been found nor any more precise birth record.
Where it precedes a year only, such as "ABT 1855", then it means that there is no information on the person's birth date at all and an educated guess has been made that he/she was probably born sometime around 1855.
Site hosted by: Ryk Brown & Chuck Speed.
To contact the hosts, or any of our researchers, go to the
STEWARTS
OF BALQUHIDDER DISCUSSION FORUM
and leave a message.
This page was last updated on February 05, 2010