The Church Record dated March 9, 1843 that is filed in the Onondaga
County Courthouse includes the names of:
| MEMBERS | DISMISSED | DIED |
| Vliet Carpenter | Aug. 1897 | |
| Deacon Delanie | d. | |
| George Terwillegar | d. | |
| Samuel C. Walker | d. | |
| Thomas H. Wands | Dec. 2, 1894 | |
| Robert Seargent | Mar. 27, 1889 | |
| Benjamin P. Baker | June 23, 1882 | |
| Orlando P. Spencer | d. | |
| David Maxwell | Jan. 8, 1897 | |
| Christopher Maxwell | Sept. 27, 1896 | |
| Andrew Fuller | d. | |
| John Gipson | Collamer M.E. 1880 | |
| Thomas Jones | Collamer Meth. 1880 | |
| Dwight Baker | May 1882 | |
| William Hayward | Collamer Methodist | |
| John P. Hales | d. | |
| Dennis Darling | Oct. 25, 1897 | |
| Edwin Schuyler | Sept. 29, 1926 | |
| William Temple | d. | |
| John Powlesland | Jan. 28, 1893 | |
| George Powlesland, Jr. | Jan. 9, 1915 | |
| Adam Smith | Apr. 25, 1903 | |
| Adam Drum | d. | |
| Joseph Warner | d. | |
| Frederick Warner | Mar. 21, 1934 | |
| George Warner | Mar. 24, 1921 | |
| Henry Fuller | Apr. 1927 | |
| George D. Baker | Apr. 28, 1924 | |
| John Henry Blessing | Letter to Collamer Meth. | |
| John H. Blessing, Jr. | Letter to Collamer Meth. | |
| William Tumball | Letter Collamer M.E. 5/30/1880 | |
| Thomas Wilson | Letter Collamer M.E. 5/30/1881 | |
| Mrs. Margaret Wands | d. | |
| Mrs. Edwin Schuyler | Dec. 17, 1898 | |
| Sarah Baker | Sept. 31, 1878 | |
| Nancy Smith | Jan. 10, 1880 | |
| Louis Walker | Nov. 18, 1895 | |
| Ann B. Baker | Oct. 31, 1900 | |
| Maryann Goodfellow | Oct. 1880 | |
| Sophia Anible | Oct. 1878 | |
| Mary Fuller | Apr. 4, 1906 | |
| Jane Baker | To Collamer Meth. | |
| Nancy Maxwell (now Mrs. Lee's) | gave letter | |
| Mrs. Chris Maxwell | d. | |
| Sarah Maxwell | ||
| Deborah Furbeck | Jan. 15, 1878 | |
| Mrs. D. Maxwell | Mar. 29, 1901 | |
| Nancy Hale | ||
| Mrs. Richarts (Riceharts) | Mar. 9, 1909 | |
| Mary Darling | ||
| Mrs. William Murray | 1887 |
Submitted 6 June 1998