Article
Number Six -
Hendrickson and Shue Families - Patents
Written by Joshua G. Borthwick and originally published
on April 12, 1879, in the Catskill "Examiner". Copy
provided by the Durham
Center Museum and retyped by Annette Campbell
Our forefathers found, after a few years' residence here in the
wilderness, that there were those who had claims (real or pretended) to their
landed possessions. It appears that it was the custom of the Dutch and English
governments to grant, by letter patent, thousands of acres of virgin soil of
America to their favorites; some of whom had won distinction in war, or had
otherwise leased the fancy of the Sovereign. Hence we find great
Rensselearwyck Patent, in Albany and Rensselaer counties, which was granted to
Killian VanRensselaer by the government of Holland, in 1641. This patent
was 24 miles wide on the river and 42 miles long, with the city of Albany near
its centre. The county of Greene was covered with Patents. The Hardenburg
Patent includes nearly all of the county west of the mountains, while
in the eastern part we have Loveridge Patent, the Catskill
Patent, the Brandow Patent, Johnson's
Patent, VanHoesen's Patent, Pleasant Valley Patent, Lunenburg's Patent,
Verplank's Patent, Salisbury's Patent, Vandenburg's Patent, Houghtaling's
Patent, Coeyman's Patent, and I do not know how many more besides.
The town of Durham, of course, had lots of claimants. In the N. E. we find Sir
Henry Seaton's Patent, while adjoining it on the west was Maitland's
Patent of 5000 acres. This included the village of Oak Hill and
a large territory in every direction, especially south of the village. Richard
Maitland was a Colonel in the British army and received his Patent,
bearing date June 23, 1767, from George III, King of England.Mr. Lucus DeWitt's farm was in this Patent, and his lease was
given in 1774, some time after he took possession. He was to pay a rent
of "One ear of corn and a proportion of the King's rent per year for five
years," and after that the rent was to be five pounds and 12
shillings per year. In the north part of the town, including the village
of Durham, Stewart's Patent was located. In the south east
part of the town and extending into the town of Cairo, was Barker's
Patent, containing over 6000 acres, while in the west part of the
town was a large Patent held by Martin G. VanBergen, and near
the center of the town was Proctor's Patent, Shue's
Patent, and a Patent of 2000 acres granted to Hugh Frazer,
which was surveyed by Eliab Youmans, in 1767. Besides
these Patroons, there was a race of squatters, who troubled the early settlers
with pretended claims. Some of the settlers bought them off, not only
once but twice, and even it is said that Capt. Jairus Chittenden and
others bought their land three times before they got a good title. Others,
like Curtis Baldwin, gave up their improvements for a small
consideration and located elsewhere. Finally they concluded, in the language
of Mark Twain, that "virtue ceases to be a
forbearance," and about thirty of them disguised themselves, somewhat in
Indian style, and drove them out of the country; and it is said one of the
women furnished a gallon of soap to wash the men, after the affair. In
the west part of the town they were troubled by a Mr. Schermerhorn, who
claimed the land and demanded yearly rent, until finally five of them told
him, in the language of Capt. Newell, "If you
don't leave this country, we will put your head under the sod." From that
time they had no further trouble with the squatters. Augustus, or as he
spelled his name, Augustines Shue, came into the town as
early as 1783 (for he sold one and one-half bushels of seed wheat to Selah
Strong in 1784) and settled somewhere near where Mr. H. B. Kirtland
lives. Afterward he left his place to Peter Shue, and
built a house on William Baldwin's farm. The house was on the
south side of the road, about on the site of his wagon house. The road, as it
was laid out in 1793, went over the present site of William
Baldwin's house, and so directly east, along the southside of Wetzel
Brown's woods, to Shubal Finch's on part of Edwin
Elliott's and the Rockerfeller place, to the
turnpike at Smith Bear's barn. This Augustine
Shue was a Dutchman, and claimed quite a large Patent in the
neighborhood, which he offered to sell to the settlers for from twenty-two to
twenty-six shillings per acre. Roswell Post bought his
farm of the said Shue on the 27th day of April 1801, for
twenty-six shillings and five pence per acre. But many of the settlers
resisted his claims, and the result was the commencement of suits in the
Supreme Court of the State, and attempted ejectment of Mr. Shue.
This history of that time is very obscure, but from what I can learn it
appears that his title was defective, on account of its conflict with Frazer's
title, or perhaps for other reasons, so that he was not able to carry his case
successfully through the courts. As a consequence he lost his claims and
his money, and sold his farm to Luke Kiersted,
(Col. "Kit's" Father,) and left the country a poor man---an
impressive warning to those who press their own selfish plans without regard
to the interests of others. Mr. S, had an intimate friend and
neighbor Mr. Henry Hendrickson, who settled on the farm now
owned by Sherwood Johnson. He was a much better man
than Mr. Shue, and lived on the farm until his death. He was
a member of the old Dutch church west of Oak Hill, a history of which I hope
our mutual friend, Mr. Aaron Roggen, will soon write for your
columns, Mr. Examiner. His wife died early in life, and he lived many
long years a widower, one or two of his sisters and others taking care of him.
His brother William settled near by, west of him, and
afterward moved up on the south part of the farm now owned by Mr.
Austin Hull. He had a family of children, one of whom, John,
froze to death on the mountain, within a short distance of his home. Mr.
Hendrickson, when in his prime, was a good hunter; game was abundant,
and he was a good marksman, and with his snow shoes in winter and his rifle
and trusty dog he caused many a deer and wolf, and smaller game to bite the
dust.