CARROLL, NY
Fentonville, is situated in the South west corner of the town of Carroll. On
the D.A.V. and P.R.R. and contains 1 hotel, 1 store, a blacksmith and cooper
shop, a saw and lath mill, (in which 3-4 million feet of lumber are annually
sawed) and about 20 houses; The population in 1870 was 82. The Fentonville
Cemetery was established in 1869 by W.H.H. FENTON, who donated and fitted up
the grounds, which consist of 2 acres, situated at Fentonville near a fine pine
grove. (1873-4 Gazetteer and Business Directory of Chautauqua Co NY by Hamilton
CHILD)
This cemetery and town lies at the very edge of Chautauqua Co and Warren Co PA
on CR 53 there is another small cemetery just 2.3 miles past the Fentonville
named HALE cemetery it is just inside the Warren Co PA line, on CR 53 also,
many of the names are the same as Fentonville; Contact number for the HALE
Cemetery is 814-757-4361.
Records created from reading done by Dolores Davidson in 2001.
Name Born Died Note
ADAMS
Big monument reads only Adams
nearby is
a small child's stone for Bertha, cannot read dates
a stone for E. Euretta (NEWBURY)ADAMS 1846-1921 wife of JOseph
a stone for Joseph H ADAMS 1844-1918
ADAMS FORBUSH
These are in individual markers and all have a long epitaph, although I
could not read any of them, others may be able to
ADAMS, Jacob Died Jan 1, 1872 age 69-9-10 lot 99
ADAMS Nancy (FORBUSH) wife of Jacob Adams, b Nov. 15, 1801 d May 4, 1879
age 78-0-16 lot 99
ADAMS Rev. Ira Son of Jacob and Nancy, died 12/29/1869 age 28-8-16 lot 99
ADAMS Cyrus, son of Jacob and Nancy, fell at the Battle of Williamsburg VA
May 5, 1852 age 25-?-? (*Cyrus Adams Enlist Date 28 May 1861 at Jamestown,
NY rank Private, age 24 lot 99
Served New York Enlisted B Co. 72nd Inf Reg. NY Killed at Williamsburg, VA
on 05 May 1862 Cyrus ADAMS was born at Fentonville,19 Aug 1836 Son of
Jacob and Nancy (FORBUSH) Adams brother of Rev Ira above)
FORBUSH, Ruth, Died Feb 26, 1858 age 86 years LOT 99
(* Ruth is Ruth FORBUSH wife of Daniel Forbush and she is the mother of
NANCY, wife of Jacob ADAMS and also the mother of the following FORBUSH
Children;
* ARE BURIED HERE
*Luther Forbush is here bp. Apr. 1, 1798
Aseneth Forbush bp. Apr. 6, 1800
*Nancy Forbush is here bp. Nov. 15, 1801
Daniel Forbush bp. July 24, 1803
Aseneth Forbush
Lucy Forbush 29 May 1809
Sephrona Forbush
Simeon Forbush 15 Feb 1815
Daniel Forbush
David Hayward Forbush bp. July 26, 1807
Sarah Forbush , bp. July 26, 1807
Lucy Forbush 17 Oct 1819
ADAMS
A massive monument to
Hiram Adams b 1838 d 1895 (*Son of Jacob and Nancy (Forbush) Adams)
Wife Lydia M. 1845-1903
ADAMS
double marker
John G. Adams 1851-1931 (Son of Leonard ADAMS b 22 Mar 1808 who probably is
bro to Jacob and here also in 1880 census)
Ellen A. Adams 1853-1883
beside is another marker probably the 2nd wife of John
Sarah G. Adams 1858-1943
ADAMS
Ira Adams died 1/7/1926 age 55-4-19
Wife Mary HASKINS b 1877 died 5/20/1950 dau of George W Haskins
Son, Lee A. Adams b 1898 died 11/17/1939 age 41
ADAMS DAVIS
lot 167
side by side single markers
Francis Adams 1856-1915
Ella (DAVIS) Adams 1857-1933
ADAMS
double marker with planted urn
Frank Adams 1879-1958 (Son of Francis and Ella )
Flora D 1880-1954
ADAMS
lot 117
Joseph H ADAMS 1844-5/16/1918 age 74
Wife, H. Euretta (Harriet NEWBURY) 1846 - 6/11/1921
Dau Bertha d 5/30/1870 age 1-1-23
(*In the 1880 census Carroll Twp, Abigail Newbury age 73 b VT the mother
of Harriet is in house of Joseph, with wife and son H. Ira Adams 9 and H.
Willis Adams, age 2)
AMES SHELDON
Rosanna AMES, wife of John Sheldon b Steuben CO NY 1809-1877
ANDERSON
lot 14
C. Thure Anderson, 4/28/1877 d 6/22/1951 Suicide
APTHORPE MORGAN
lot 28
Fred APTHORPE 1/24/1945 age 66
Wife Jennie MORGAN, 4/12/1947
Charles MORGAN, d 5/1/1930 age 75
son of Ellis and Eunice (NORTHRUP) Morgan
Wife Mary HOXIE d 3/1/1935
ARNOLD
Large Monument, with a big A encircled
1 side, John Arnold 1790-1854
Wife Electa 1788-1841
Back of monument is
John I. Arnold, 1823-1915
Wife Phebe M 1836-1912
around this are smaller initial stones for each
ARNOLD
Double marker
Delevan Arnold 1850-1917
Wife Sarah D. LITTLEFIELD 1853-1918
ATKINS
Lot 1
William P(*Prentice) Atkins 11/30/1828 died 10/3/1900 Civil ar Soldier, Co
A 188th NY Reg.( *Son of Wm and Rebecca McNall Atkins)
Wife Susan (BURCH) b Gerry Ny 1/19/1838 died 3/3/1906 age 68
ATKINS LEWIS
lot 20
William F. Atkins 1857-1938
Wife Minnie LEWIS b 1859 d 2/16/1930
ATKINS
lot 32
Reverend Hugh Atkins 1/29/1884 died Aug 1954 age 70-6-22
Wife Flora PHILLIPS 2887-??
Son Paul Emory Atkins 9/9/2932 d 9/28/2962 in VA hospital Erie PS
ATKINS
lot 38
Pearl A Atkins d 4/20/1909
also here 4-5 infant children
BENNETT HASKINS
Lot 129 and lot 111
Lou, wife of Henry W Bennett (Son of Martha and Ezra)died May 7, 1909 b
1867
Ada Belle BENNETT dau of Henry and Lou, d 1880 age 2
Ezra BENNETT 1825 died 1898 age 74
Wife Martha J. HASKINS 1833 died 7/10/1905
*Martha HASKINS was born at Fentonville, MArch 9, 1833 dau of Freedom
HASKINS and Catherine LESHER, her sister,Maria HASKINS, b 1838 Married to
brother of Ezra Bennett, Milton Bennett and they are here also
BENNETT
lot 158
Marvin M. Bennett died 2/10/1934 age 75 son of Milton BENNETT or Ezra
Wife Nellie 1863 d 1/29/1921 age 47 WHO is she?
Son Clyde 11/25/1917 age 22
Cora, Infant dau 2/28/1915
(* who is the father of Marvin, Marvin is also the father of Leland and
Lloyd Bennett
who also are buried here 1982 and 1984 )
BENNETT
lot 63
Freedom BENNETT b *July 22, 1857 son of Milton BENNETT and Maria HASKINS
died May 9 1940 age 83
Wife Helen L. (*Lucille HAMMOND) b 1858 d 4/28/1930
BENNETT
Lot 41
Wesley J. BENNETT b 1866 d 1904 age 38
Wife Jessie M. b 1868 died 10/10/1920 may also be a Bennett,
Wesley J Bennett was the son of Ezra BENNETT and Martha J HASKINS
BENNETT
Orlo E. Bennett, 74 died Sept. 27, 1990 in Jamestown NY,
He was born May 30, 1925, in Fentonville, N.Y., the son of Clifford and Reba
Griffith Bennett. A World War II Navy Veteran, he later joined the Army
during the Korean conflict. He was a member of the Disabled American
Veterans and Brothers of the Brush
He was preceded in death by his parents; four brothers: Leo, Emory, Lester
and Harold Bennett Sr Burial will be in Fentonville (no children)
BILLEB
(spelling is very clear)
Robert H. Billeb 1927-1952
BLACKMER or BLACKNER WILTSIE
Clara Blackmer or Blackner first wife of John Dexter WILTSIE married
2/28/1868 died 3/20/1869
BLACKMON
triple marker
Seldon Blackmon 1856-1932
M. Addie, 1857-19? d/d not etched
Roy L 1882-1902
BLAUSER
lot 187
Samuel Wendell Blauser 1895-1976 data from SS death index; Birth Date: 15
Nov 1895 Death Date: 18 Sep 1976 SS Number from Railroad board PA
Matching stone,
BLAUSER
Mary BOYD, wife of Samuel lot 187 b 1856 died 9/9/1939 age 84
BLY GOODFORD
lot 90
Double marker
David 1864-1942
Wife Addie, 1866-1945
Matching Loretta GOODFORD 1914-1993
BLY
lot 193
Charles E Bly 1/13/1894 d 9/1/1969 age 69
Wife Wilda Lillian 1896 d 4/19/1949 age 53
BOYD
2 markers for David Boyd, 1 is a monument 1 a marker;
the monument
David M BOYD 12/15/1817 d 11/27/1901 Co d 111 PA 1 Vol, has a flag on the
smaller marker
on the monument this same data and other side is Mary J. MARTIN b 5/3/1823
died 11/13/1894
another stone beside is badly eroded
dau Estella Boyd d 5/27/1874 age 20-1-24
in the 1880 census David is listed with wife Mary
Town of Carroll ;David BOYD Self M M W 62 NY
Occ: Blacksmith Fa: NY Mo: NY
Mary BOYD Wife F M W ae57 b PA Keeping House Fa b: DE Mo: PA
BOYD BLAUSER
2 matching stones
Mary (BOYD) Blauser 1856-1939
Samuel Wendell Blauser 1895-1976
BRALEY
double marker
Hubert L. 1928-1992
Wife Ruth 1929-xx
BROGAN SWAGER WARD
lot 182
Emory Berton BROGAN
Wife Blanche Mae (SWAGER) WARD died age 83-7-23 dau of Martin Swager
Blanche married 1st to Emory BROGAN had 1 son, 2 dau, married 2nd to ? WARD
also Hazel Mae Ward or Brogan? b 10/10/1905 d 10/10/1953
BROKAW VanARSDALE
lot 178
The BROKAW family came from Somerset New Jersey they were mostly found in
the Russell area of Warren Co PA
John BROKAW b 22 Aug 1791 Somerset, Nj
died here May 1, 1874 age 83-8-11
Wife Judy Ann * Judith VanARSDALE, b 3/12/1793 died here 10/17/1881 age 88-7-5
Son Ruloff BROKAW 3/1/1810 died 3/22/1891 age 72-0-21
Dau Phebe Ann, b 1821 died 10/11/1906 age 85
Jessie, probable dau of Ruloff
[Notes: It seems to me that Ruloff, Phebe Ann and Jesse (male) Brokaw are all children of John and Judith VanArsdale. In one census it looks like they might be married because there is a 6 year old boy Cleveland listed with them. Cleveland is the son of their brother Peter who was widowed at the time of the Census 1860. In other census' Phebe and Ruloff are listed as single. - Ryley Winter Meagher, 2007.
In reading the Fentonville cemetery listing, I noted that Ruluf and Phoebe are listed as husband and wife. This is incorrect. They were brother and sister. Both had lost their hearing due to illness when Ruluf was a baby and Phoebe was about 2. My mother's family lived with the Brokaw family in the "Bootjack" around early 1900's. Mom could remember, "Aunt Phoebe taking care of her and that she spoke only at a 2 year old level. I hope this error can be corrected, as I am one of the few left who are aware of the actual relationship. - Judith R. Faustine, 2010]
BROWN
lot 123
Unknown
Phebe (May be COWAN)
John b PA died 1/14/1883 age 70
BUCK
Nellie M. Buck 1901-1974 (She is buried beside Alfred E Robbins,1919-1927
(Child)
BUCK
Fred d 8 /2/ 1927 no age
BURGART
lot 190
Double marker
Donald K 1900-1946
Florence H. 1901-1982
CAMPBELL
double marker
Charles E Campbell 1882-1951
Martha J EDMONDS 1886-1962
CARROLL
lot 151see COVELL
COBB ATKINS
Orson P Atkins 1878 d 11/3/1950
Wife Agnes M b 1883 died 10/8/1908 age 25
Son Roy P Atkins
Dau Ruth (Atkins) COBB 1906-1960
COMSTOCK
Lot 10
Miner Comstock died 10/24/1946 age 76
Wife was Eleanor Amy COY married 2nd to Ed TOWNS
Child 1917
Another Child 4/13/1922
(*Miner shows in the 1880 census as the son of Lyman COMSTOCK and Esther
Ann HAIGHT )
Lyman COMSTOCK Self 46 NYOcc: Farmer Fa: NY Mo: NY
Esther COMSTOCK Wife 43 NYOcc: Keeping House Fa: NY Mo: NY
Alice COMSTOCK Dau F S W 13 NY
Minnie COMSTOCK Dau F S W 11 NY
*Miner COMSTOCK Son M S W 9 NY
Ida COMSTOCK Dau F S W 7 NY
Eric COMSTOCK Son M S W 5 NY
Nora COMSTOCK Dau F S W 2 NY
COVELL COWAN CARROLL
the stones for this family are of a limestone sort and most are badly eroded
or broken;
I found the names there but gathered the dates for the ** ones from other
sources;
Simeon M. COVELL son of Simon and Sally(*Maria THOMPSON) COVELL
Simeon jr died age 15,-6- ? (*b 19 Mar 1816 Frewsburg, Chautauqua, New York)
he died 12/12/1832 or 1830
there are near also 3 small child's markers for COVELL children;
Sophia, or Sophronia d 3/22/1831 age 1-10-7 of Simeon and Sally
child 11 days 4/11/1824 of Simeon and Sally
Child Sally d 6/4/1832 of Simeon and Sally
and 2 others that are totally eroded
Susan W. COVELL d/o *Simon and Sally Maria THOMPSON b c 1825 she was the
wife of David CARROLL as stated on her stone, died may, 1869 (* She was
Susannah West Covell
beside
Sally Maria Covell d/o Simon and Sally Thompson Covell wife of George W
COWAN as stated on her stone, which is broken in half and no dates remain,
** She was born 7 Jul 1812 Frewsburg, Chautauqua, New York died 11/17/1832
age 20-1-10
S. Merrill Covell son, d 10/12/1830 age 15-6-24 Son of Simeon and Sally
COVELL RICE
lot 35
Serena (RICE) born Wendell MA August 12, 1807 died Fentonville Feb, 16, 1861
wife of John COVELL (John does not seem to be buried here Serena was sister
of the Wheeler Rice also buried here, they have matching stones) Serena died
in South Valley NY
Son COVELL
Edmund Covell 1835-1919 Civil War Soldier NY Vol Co A 188th regt
(*Son of John COVELL and Serena RICE)
Lewis Covell Son of John and Serena no dates (In the 1880 census of
Cattaraugus Co NY in the house of Edmond COVELL is brother LEWIS Covell b
1845 Sister Augusta, b c 1858 and Emma Covell b ca 1849) the rest of this
family is in Catt Co also
[NOTE: The inscription list
at the Fenton History Center has an asterisk in front of the name Lewis Covell.
I discussed that with Ernest Wiltsie who had the cemetery records at the time I
called. Mr. Wiltsie said that the asterisk meant that he was the person who put
lot 35 in perpetual care, and who was billed for it every year. He said that
Lewis was not buried there, as evidenced by the fact that there are no dates
for his name. Please include a note to this effect at this point on your web
page. Perhaps, Lewis Covell paid for perpetual care for this lot, but
he is not buried here. - Jim Barton, 2008]
COWAN FENTON
15-20 ft monument with a C encircled
Smaller stones
J. Marvin COWAN 4/19/1836 d 8/26/1876
Wife Elsie FENTON 11/7/1833 d 11/15/1891(* Elsie (Fenton) COWAN is age 49
widow, in the 1880 census ,same house with Brother REUBEN FENTON age 42 and
another person named Abram Talbott age 52)
Same lot
FENTON, Reuben died 3/24/1904 Age 66 Civil War Soldier
COWAN FENTON
Tombstone is a carved granite tree cut off at the top and so are the
branches, names etched on a scroll hanging from a cut off branch all in
stone
Elisha M. Cowan 4/13/1827 died 12/25/1890
Wife Mary Jane FENTON 6/27/1831 died 10/29/1876 (* Mary Jane and Elsie
FENTON must be the daughters of William H H Fenton and Catherine, there were
4 and these married to brothers Cowan, and there is also the brother Reuben
Fenton, there is very little data published on this Fenton family)
COWAN
lot 123
Roswell Cowan 1852-1917
Wife Lena B.(*FURGESON) 1860-1/12/1940
COWAN
lot 123
George Henry cannot read the records
Jenny d 1904
4 Brothers Cowan
Herbert, 8/28/1922
James M 1/7/1928
Fred 3/13/1930
Charles 4/1/1931 age 77
COX
lot 120
this is the lot dedicated to the Unknown Soldiers, and has a flag there now,
but also may be there or not;
Julie Nichols COX and Susan,
CLARK WILTSIE LINEBORG BROKAW
side by side markers
Morgan CLARK b June 8, 1841 No death date etched;
beside is wife;
Hannah E (Hannah Eliza WILTSIE,) b Feb 28, 1850 died Aug 31, 1891
Beside is stone for
James C. CLARK 1868-1949 (Son of Hannah and Morgan,)
His wife Hannah (LINEBORG) 1874-1964
His son J Morgan Clark d 12/25/1907 age 4 mos
His son Leroy no date child
Beside these is the parents of Hannah E WILTSIE CLARK
WILTSIE; these are very eroded *data added;
James died 1894 * he was born July 29, 1819 or 1821 son of William Wiltsie
and Mary Hull and brother of John H and William)
Wife of James Wiltsie ;
Catherine *BROKAW died 10/9/ 1905 b 11/1/1823 New Jersey dau of John And
Judith(VanArsdale) BROKAW also here
CROCKER
lot 14
David U Crocker 1868 6/22/1951 age 60
CURTISS is spelled wrongly as BURTISS on stones lot 130
(clearly spelled BURTISS on stone and is in error )
John L. Burtiss 8/18/1841 d 5/3/1907 Civil War Vet, has flag stone gives
same military data as Curtiss below
beside him is Aseneth D Burtiss (*Asenath Emma HEMMENGER, dau. of Oramel
Hemmenger) .7/30/1846 d 7/27?/1930 stone is eroded
JOHN LELAND CURTISS, son of John G. and Minerva Montague Curtiss, b. Aug.
18, 1841, in Frewsburg, town of Carroll, N. Y. Married, Nov. 22, 1865,
Asenath Emma HEMMENGER, dau. of Oramel Hemmenger. Served three and one-half
years in the late civil war, participated in eighteen battles, was three
times wounded, and taken prisoner for a few hours, and honorably discharged
at the close of the war, and now receives a pension. Resides in the town of
Frewsburg, but the post-office is Jamestown, Chautauqua county, N. Y. Has
held town offices of constable, collector and pathmaster. Occupation, a
farmer.
Children;
Bertie Laverne, b. April 17, 1868.
Ephraim Gleason, b. Jan. 13, 1870.
Lizzie Minerva, b. Feb. 10, 1871.
Nellie Lovina, b. Feb. 29, 1873
Enlist date 24 August 1862 at Carroll, Ny rank Priv age 21
Served New York Enlisted 7th Co. 1st SS Reg. NY Mustered Out at Rochester,
NY on 23 June 1865
beside lot 130
CURTISS Ephron, C Curtiss died 2/3/1891 age 22-0-21
(In the 1880 census EPHRON Curtiss ae 11 is shown in the house of father
John and Asenath Curtiss with brother, Bertie, 13 sisters Lizzie ae 9 and
Nellie Curtiss ae 7
CURTISS
Monument lot 113
Bert L Curtiss 1867-1947 or 1943 (son of John and Asenath)
Wife Asha 1870-1902
Raymond W 1894-1898
Ivan L 1895-1896
CURTIS(S)
lot 40
Jason Eugene b 1856 d June 1926 age 70 (Son of Aaron and Harriet CURTISS
Shows as E. Jason in census)
Wife Margery S. b 1868 d 10/12/1957 age 88-11-5
Dau Dora 2/24/1889 d 8/15/1889
CURTISS
lot 176
Aaron CURTISS b ca 1818 died after 1880
Wife Harriet b c 1830 died after 1880
Son E. Jason is in the census 1880 age 25
DINSMORE BROKAW
Addie (BROKAW) Dinsmore d 8/25/1889 age 33-2-28 wife of a C J Dinsmore
Dau of John and Rhoda (BROWN) BROKAW
the family moved away
DOTY
lot 138
Charles DOTY d 4/11/1912 age 78
DOTY
Her name alone is on this monument
Wife Anna FENTON, dau of W H H Fenton and Catherine Edmonds 11/25/1842 died
7/17/1888 Anna FENTON was the wife of Charles DOTY
DOTY
lot 139
Emmett Doty, son of Charles and Anna Fenton Doty b 1866 d 4/7/1941
Wife Minnie L LUNDBERG of Titusville PA d 9/24/1961 age 89
Son John L Doty b/d/ 3/21/1913
DRAYTON MARTIN
Lot 8
William J. Drayton Born England 4/7/1791 died 7/10/1874 age 83 Soldier in
the War of 1812
Wife Mrs Maria b 3/4/1800 d ?
Mrs. Jane stone gone no data
Lot 11
Earl DRAYTON b 6/4/1872 died 3/12/1953 age 89-8-16
John Rupert MARTIN 2/23/1883 d 9/27/1955 age 72-7-1
Wife Ruth H b 1901 d ??
lot 17
DRAYTON, Joseph d 3/8/1941 age 62
EDMONDS
Lot 163
Flag
Henry EDMONDS 10/13/1824 died 11/12/1867 Civil War
Served PA 145th Pa Vol
Wife Harriet HASKINS b 4/13/1831 d 6/14/1858 Dau of Freedom HASKINS,
Catherine LESHER
EDMONDS
lot 165
double marker, lots of blooming iris planted around
Norman S. Edmonds 1851-1944 (Bro of Charles )
Rose E. 1859-1921
EDMONDS
lot 166
triple marker
Charles H Edmonds 1855-1940 (brother of Norman)
Phebe J. 1860-1932
Minnie M. 1880-1897
EDMONDS
lot 173
John 1849-1917 age 68
Robert Edmond PETERSON Infant 1939 grandson of Thomas
Double marker;
Thomas, 1880 d 8/18/1957 age 76-10-26
Emma, wife of Thomas, 1885-1964
EDMONDS
John b. Apr 17 1793, d. Mar 29 1881, War of 1812
EHRHART
Lot 197
Leonard T. d 7/19/1961 age 73-4-26
ENDS
(as spelled) Double marker
Ephraim Ends 1864- no d/d
Clara M. 1869-1926
ENOS
lot 121
Charles H. L. ENOS 1889-8/13/1922 age 33 WWI
Son of Ephraim ENOS, his wife remarried and went to Calif with their
daughter;
FENTON OWEN EDMONDS
Very large monument
1 side is George W. FENTON, born Hanover NH 12/20/1783 died at Carroll NY
3/3/1860
1 side is Elsey (*OWEN),(Dau of John OWEN (Rev War) and w/ Lydia GILSON)
wife of George W. Fenton, born *8 Jul 1790 died Feb 26, 1875 aged 84-7-18
1 side is their son, W. H. H. FENTON ( William) 4/24/1814 died 7/4/1887
1 side Wife of William H H Fenton is Catherine EDMONDS b 10/6/1812 died
2/3/1894
Smaller markers near monument are;
W.H.H.F
C.F. (Catherine)
Malvina, dau of W.H.H.F (infant)
E.F.(Elsey)
G W FENTON
(*more about George W Fenton in 1804 left Broadalbin NY where his father had
settled, traveled to Pittsburgh, then a small village, and commenced trading
in goods and provisions, in a canoe, came up the Allegany River and French
Creek, which business he followed 2 or 3 years. In the winter of 1805-06, he
taught school at Warren PA, the first ever taught there, Here he married to
Elsey OWEN, who was born in Lunenburg, NY July 8, 1790. He is said to have
moved to his new log cabin on the south side of the outlet on Chautauqua
Lake, in the spring of 1807, where the only settlers were William WILSON,
and James CULBERTSON, who were on the north side. in 1809, he sold his farm
and moved to lot 52 on the East side of the Conewango (the date of this
purchase was March 1810)
Mr. FENTON died march 3, 1860, His widow died Feb. 26, 1875
Their children were;
Roswell O. FENTON, who married Lenora AKIN and had 4 sons 4 dau.
George W. FENTON Jr. Married Mitta HOWARD, has 2 sons 4 dau.
William H. H. FENTON, married Catherine EDMONDS, has a son William H.H.
Junior, and 4 dau, of whom 1 died in infancy.
John F. FENTON, married to Maria WOODWARD and is deceased, he had 3 sons 5
dau. one of the sons died an infant.
Reuben E. FENTON (see Jamestown History and bio )
(*)added data Andrew W. Young 1875 History of Chautauqua )
FENTON
Roswell O. FENTON, d. Mar 5 1880, age 42-5-19
Lenora (AKIN) FENTON, wife of Roswell O. Fenton, d. Jul 1 1888
FENTON THAYER
Monument
W.H.H.F. 1845-1905 (* William Henry Harrison Fenton JR Son of WHHF SR and
Catherine Edmonds))(* He went by the name of HARRISON and was married to
Sybil)
Wife, S.B.F.L. 1843-1923 Sybil THAYER B 7 Sep 1843 Frewsburg Ny dau of Hiram
THAYER and Mariette EAMES, Sybil married 2nd to LANDON died at age 80
10/11/1923
FENTON
lot 67
Hiram Fenton born 6 July 1828 died 5 July 1862 age 33-11-30 of
consumption and is buried in the Fentonville Cemetery. He married Martha
Feeney She is buried in the Clendening Cemetery on Quaker Hill in Warren
Co., PA. She m. (2) Charles Rote. After her death Charles Rote married Jane
?
Caroline Fenton, nodata
G. Hiram Fenton, no data
FORBUSH
2 matching markers,
Luther FORBUSH 10/25/1797 died 11/8/1862 there is a flag at his marker , but
he DID NOT SERVE
His son LUTHER Jr is the soldier, no flag
Wife Eliza (JONES) Forbush, 7/27/1801 died 12/19/1876 Luther SR and Eliza
had several Children
Beside them is buried son
FORBUSH, William H.H. died Nov 11, 1862 age 21-11-11
He was a son of Luther Sr and Eliza Jones Forbush
FORBUSH
Monument
1 side;
Francis M (*MARION) Forbush 4/28/1832 d Probably 1908 as Marion
1 side He was the son of Luther Sr and Eliza Jones Forbush
Mary O. ACKLEY 1st wife 8/13/1843 d 1/7/1881
son Charlie M 11/25/1872 d 12/30/1872
Marion, 1832-1908 probably Francis M
2nd wife of F M Forbush, m 27 Nov 1881
Nancy MOORE , 10/16/1844 d 7/24/1883
(* in the 1880 town of Frewsburg, Carroll NY census, is Marion, with still
living wife Mary and children;,
Marian FORBUSH Self M M W 47 NY
Occ: Carpenter Fa: NY Mo: NY
Mary FORBUSH Wife F M W 36 MI
Occ: Keeping House Fa: NY Mo: NY
Ada FORBUSH Dau F S W 11 PA
Florence FORBUSH Dau F S W 5 PA)
FORBUSH
Beautiful granite monument with a polished granite ball on top
5 smaller stones have the names
Joel S Forbush, 1844-1908
Wife Kate Howard, 1847-1908
Luther A Forbush JUNIOR, 1838-1909 Civil War Soldier, No flag
he and Joel are sons of Luther SR and Eliza JONES Forbush as is Francis
Marion Forbush above
Wife Martha MARSH, 2/12/1847 -1909 (* Many of the MARSH family are down the
rd at the HALE Cemetery just inside PA line)
Alice C Forbush 1875-1876 infant dau of one above family
FORBUSH STODDARD NEWBURY or NEWBERRY
lot 80
Corydon J. FORBUSH b 5/16/1830 died 11/11/1892 age 62-5-26 Son of Luther
and Eliza Jones Forbush
Wife 1, Priscilla STODDARD 1/12/1829 died 11/5/1862 age 33-9-23
"Mother"
Wife 2 Fanny M. NEWBURY b 11/24/ 1842 died 10/14/1889
Her Mother Abigail Newbury died 3/12/1890 age 82-3-19 "Our Mother"
Son of Priscilla nd Corydon Forbush, Luther Forbush, 1/17/1855 died
11/20/1862 age 7-10-3
Daniel Forbush either a child or Grandchild, no dates
FORBUSH MONG
large monument with both names
James FORBUSH 29 Sep 1868 d 8/4/1916 (Son of Luther JR Forbush and Martha C
MARSH, )
Wife Cora MONG 1870-1939
E. Benton MONG 1868 1943
James B ?? 1916
GALBRATH
lot 4
Orson Galbrath 9/7/1910 age 78
Frank 6/1/1915
GANEY BROCKWAY
lot 168
Leo Ganey 1883-1914
space beside may be burial no marker
Stone matching Leo Ganey, Lilian (as spelled) Ganey BROCKWAY 1861-1947
Matthew Ganey, 1879-1949 (Matthew and Leo are the sons of Lilian, neither
ever married)
GANEY RHODES
lot 169
Elroy R. Ganey 1881-1950 Son of Lilian,
RHODES GANEY
double marker
Alex Rhodes 1881-1959 son in law
Wife Katherine GANEY 1887-1970 Dau of Lilian
(data from SS Death index Katherine RHODES Birth Date: 25 Sep 1887 Death
Date: Oct 1970 Social Security Number: 058-38-4354 State or Territory Where
Number Was Issued: New York Death Residence Localities ZIP Code: 14757
Localities: Mayville, Chautauqua, New York )
GOLDING
Effie Golding lot 165 d 4/30/1911 age 29-9-2
GRAHAM
double marker
Halcy Graham, 1874-1956
Julia A. 1885-1953
GRAHAM
lot 71
Robert d 2/20/1941 age 1-6-0
Infants 1937 and another in 1938
GRIFFIN SILVIS
Clayton E. Griffin, "Pop" 1889-1971
Beside Laura E. SILVIS 1906-1952
GRIFFIN BRADY RHODES
Winnie Brady no data
Harriet RHODES no data
Mattie GRIFFIN 1872 d 12/12/1942
Husband Alvin Delay Griffin 1871 d 9/1/1952 age 81-5-3
GRIFFIN
lot 196
Lucy Arlena wife of Lester Griffin, d 2/14/1953 age 46-5-17
Beside
Albert L Griffin, 8/19/1927 d 8/26/1974 U S Army Air, Flag,
Kevin Clark YOUNG b 7/26/1954 d 1/13/1957 Grandson
"Now I lay me down to sleep"
Another infant grandchild, child of Gaylord STEVENS 3/22/1959
HALE
lot 33
Clark J HALE 1871 d 5/31/1947 age 77
HARRISON MILLER
2 small matching stones, with only this info but they are beside a monument
for 3 Miller Children may or not be related
C. HARRISON. (not sure if that is the last name) 1840-1923
Emma L. 1843-1924
on Monument name is MILLER
Isaac 3/6/1873 d 11/1/1875
Wiltsie 7/27/2868 d 11/11/1875
Kizzie 9/25/1871 d 11/15/1875
It is obvious some awful tragedy took these 3 children in a 2 week period
HASKINS
Large Monument for G.W. Haskins
individual stones in a row;
Ezra Haskins 1884-1946
beside Myrtle M. 1892-7/3/1935
George W. Haskins 1853-1940 (*Who is his father?)
Sarah 1856-3/20/ 1930
HASKINS
small childs marker of G W and Sarah Haskins
1892-1895
(George and Sarah also had a son JOHN b 1875 PA in the 1880 census GW
Haskins is Born PA so is Sarah his wife;)
HASKINS
Ira Haskins died 1/19/1863 age 35-5-5 (*son of Freedom Haskins and Catherine
LESHER)
Wife Lydia EDMONDS (OWEN) died 4/19/1862 age 32-10-2
HASKINS
large monument with flag
E.A. HASKINS Co A. 112th NY Inf
Ethan A Haskins
Enlist Date 28 July 1862 Jamestown, NY rank Private age 18
Served New York Enlisted A Co. 112th Inf Reg. NY Mustered Out at Raleigh, NC
on 13 June 1865 Ethan A. Haskins, Carroll, wounded in battle, October 27;
rejoined Company May, '65; on guard at Corps Headquarters from May 20
Beside this large monument on each side is 1 stone for;
Ethan A. Haskins 1846- 1933
Pheba A. (as spelled) HOLT 4/21/1846 died 4/26/1908
(*they had several children b in Chautauqua Co)
HASKINS
John 1843-1864 no flag
beside is plot, no marker has flag
HASKINS
Lucinda (EDMONDS) (dau of John Edmonds) wife of Henry W. Haskins (son of
Freedom and Catherine Lesher) died May 18, 1864 age 23-8-3 stone is quite
eroded
(* research shows that Lucinda was b Fentonville and after her death, Henry
remarried to Mary HOLT, sister of Pheba wife of Ethan Haskins ; Lucinda is
buried next to Henry's Grand mother Isabel LESHER)
HASKINS
Double marker lot 24
Clayton C. Haskins 1880-1936 (*son of W.H.H. Haskins)
Wife Ruth (HALE) Haskins 1878-1947 (*dau of James Hale and Julia Wetmore of
Warren Co PA)
Son, separate marker;
Ralph Hale HASKINS 1902-1928
Matching stone for Dau Marjorie Haskins HECTOR 1905-1964
HASKINS
Lot 164
George W. Haskins b PA 1853 died 11/5/1940 age 89
Wife Sarah, 1856 d 3/20/1930 age 73
Son Ezra HASKINS 1884-1/22/1946
Myrtie his wife, 1895 d 7/3/1935 age 40
(Also had a son John b PA 1875)
HAYWARD
Double marker
DeWitt C. Hayward, 1850-1926
Alice B. 1849-1931
22 markers for their children
Dau Jessie Hayward 1876-1894
beside totally eroded childs marker no data readable
is Only Son Glenn d 12/1/1875 age 1-8-1
HASKINS
Elmer E. Haskins 1864-1926
HEADLEY
Double,
Lafayette, 1865 - 1902
Minnie I 1871-1964
HERRICH
Henry and Esther supposedly buried here lot 21
JACKSON DUNHAM DAVIS
Lot 47
Thomas JACKSON, 1847-6/2/1913 age 66
Wife Alice DUNHAM 1849 d 3/12/1927 age 78
Melvin, (ashes) died 1947
Wife Mamie (Mary) 1872 died 6/3/1916 age 44
Also lot 47 is Samuel DAVIS 1848-1919
and wife
Hannah G. 1849-1917
JOHNSON
Lot 74
Dorastus Johnson b June 11,1800 died April 3, 1881 Flag Probably should not
be on his grave,
Wife Bathsheba (*CUMMINS) died August 3, 1874
(*Marriage: 11 Jan 1821 Oneida, New York )
(added from Chautauqua History notes Dorastus JOHNSON, from Cattaraugus Co
NY, about 1845 settled at Fentonville, lot 33,(*his wife was Bathsheba
CUMMINS) he had 6 sons and one daughter.
Ira JOHNSON (*born Sept 4, 1834), Catt Co NY one of the sons, died in the
late (*Civil) War,the Battle of Fredricksburg VA.He died Dec 13, 1863 age
29-3-10
Calvin JOHNSON,(*Born July 14, 1842 CATT Co. NY Died Nov 20, 1864 age )
another son, also served in the war and died of disease contracted in the
army.
Salina B. Johnson, 4/24/1829 died in the Civil War
Andrew W. Young, 1875
A son, not known if he is buried here or not, was Doras Johnson, also served
Civil War, and was married to Delphene Unknown
History of Chautauqua Co NY )
Doras Johnson (Short for DORASTUS?)
Enlist Date 20 September 1861 Jamestown, NY Priv 25
Served New York First Name: Doras or Lewis Enlisted C Co. 9th Cav Reg. NY
disch disability at Convalescent Camp, VA on 24 December 1862
His widow, Delphene had pension granted as a widow, Nov 21, 1912
Salina Johnson, son of Dorastus, b 4/24/1829 died Civil War
Wife? Basha Johnson remarried to Briggs? no dates
Calvin Johnson son of Dorastus, 7/14/1842 d 11/20/1864 age 22-4-9
Abel or Able Johnson, son of Dorastus, 4/10/1826 died 1867 age 41
Lydia, dau of Abel 1866-1872
JOHNSON
lot 12
Leroy H 6 or 7/12/1892 died 6/5/1939 age 60 (Son of John and Florence)
Wife Eva (WILLSON) b 1896-
JOHNSON
Florence Johnson 3/31/1867 d 11/27/1911 (wife of John Johnson)
JOHNSON
Earl W. Johnson 1896-1960
Wife LaRue G 1903-1967
JOHNSON
Double Delton E. Johnson 1928-1977 Flag, Served Korea
Constance 1934-1982
JOHNSON
Gust A Johnson 1860 d 5/3/1950 age 89
Anna B 1863 d 9/25/1932 age 69
Elmer G 1890 d 8/11/1960
KELLY or KELLEY DAVIS RICKERSON
Frank B DAVIS 1881 d 3/22/1951
Wife Rena M RICKERSON b13 Mar 1889
Infant dau Gwendolyn 3/15/1919
Infant no date
*Rena remarried to a KELL(*E)Y and may not be here she was the dau of John
RICKERSON and Viola Jane BENNETT
KELLEY
Double marker
Arthur W. Kelley 1882-1959
Wife Grace R. 1878-1967
KELLEY
lot 4
Frederick D, 11/25/1939
KINESTON or KINISTON
Josiah Kiniston, 1847-4/26/1908 age 62 Soldier in the Civil War
Enlist Date 17 February 1864 Carroll, NY Priv age 18
Served New York Enlisted U Co. 112th Inf Reg. NY Mustered Out at Elmira, NY
on 27 December 1865
Louisa no data
Phillips no data
Soldier of the Revolution, Daniel WHEELER said also to be buried this lot
See Wheeler
no data found
LESHER
Isabel (Nee unknown) LESHER ( mother of Catherine LESHER HASKINS)
b ca 1783 NY, died March 1873 age about 89-9-29 stone is eroded
beside her is what seems to be a females stone unreadable, age about 24 may
be LESHER
LEWIS
Lot 2
George Lewis 12/10/1937
Mrs George 12/16/1942
Arthur
Ernest, age 81
LYONS JACKSON
lot 47
Dora JACKSON wife of Frank LYONS 1898 died 10/27/1918 age 27
LINDSEY
Double
children
Timothy Alan, 1946-1950
Thomas Harold July 2-7 1946
LINDSEY
Double
Harold 1909 -1964
Lavina V 1909-1992
LOWREY
lot 184
double marker
William Lowery 1874-1950
Clara 1875-1956
MALIN
lot 171
Monument with 4 small matching stones in front
John D Malin 1871-1951
Evaline L. 1841-1914 Mother
Cora A. 1867-1924
Clara D. 1863-1952
MALIN
lot 172
Fred W Malin 1880 d 6/29/1945 son of Evaline above
Wife Henrietta 1884-1963
No children
McCOY
Herbert B McCoy 1874 died 7/17/1957
Wife Eva ASH b 1885 d 7/20/1928 age 41
Son Myrl Herbert 6/7/1913 died 5/4/195? age 40-10-24
MILLER
Monument, with names
Isaac 3/6/1873 d 11/1/1875
Wiltsie 7/27/1868 d 11/11/1875
Kizzie, 9/25/1871 d 11/15/1875
Harrison Children
Beside this monument are 2 stones that read
C. Harrison Miller 1840-1923 Born PA
beside Emma L (WILTSIE) . 1843-1924
Dau of David WILTSIE and Jane HADLEY
(*the 1880 census shows in house are also 2 daughters, Bertha Miller, 13 b
PA and Lulu age 1 b NY)
MOORE
unusual and beautiful round tall column type rose granite monument is in
perfect condition;
front is page scroll type says Mother and Father
George MOORE 9/3/1830 died 5/24/1886
Wife Deborah, F. 2/26/1836 died 7/27/1887
MOORE BULL DAVISON
lot 92
5 small stones in a row, matching
Charles D Moore 1888-1965
Katie Moore BULL 1879-1907
Bessie (Moore) DAVISON 1884-1965
"Father" W.F. MOORE 1858-1891
"Mother" Mary Moore 1858-1896
MOORE
lot 92
William F Moore 1858-1891 age 33
Mary Moore 1858-1896 age 38
NEWBURY
Monument
Roswell Newbury, 1828-10/28/ 1902
Wife Mary Ann 1827-4/3/1910
Fayette 1848-1897
Beside this monument are 2 quite eroded stones for
NEWBURY
H. Fayette 4/6/1848 d 9/1897 age 49
Newbury, Jennie A. 10/8/ 1843- 1/21/1916 age 72
NILES
Leslie Niles, 1884-1951
NORBERG ROBBINS
triple marker
Stanley M. 1909-1981
Stanley NORBERG Birth Date: 29 Jun 1909 Death Date: Nov 1981 State or
Territory Where Number Was Issued: New York Death Residence Localities ZIP
Code: 14214 Localities: Buffalo, Erie, New York
Beula S 1911-??
Ferol A. 1892-1988
(*SS Death index, Ferol ROBBINS Birth Date: 25 May 1892 Death Date: 8 Jul
1988 Social Security Number: 134-40-4264 State or Territory Where Number Was
Issued: New York)
NOURSE
James David Nourse b 1830-? may not be there
Malvena 1836-1885
(*In the 1880 census one James Nourse born PA age 24 is in the Martin home
in Pomfret the only one of this name in the County 1880)
OLSON
lot 20
Harry E. Olson 5/13/1880 d 4/17/1957
Wife Nellie May 5/8/1881 d 2/9/`957
PERRY WAID OTANDER
lot 19
Grant I PERRY 1865-11/30/1931
Wife Gertrude WAID d 4/12/1935 age 66
Dau Clara P 9/18/1890 d 4/21/1962 resided at BEmus PT
Husband, Carl Elmer OTANDER 2/17/1895 d 5/28/1958 WWI Veteran
PETERSON
2 matching stones side by side
Victor Peterson 1871-1944
Hettie F. Peterson 1892-1974
PETTIT
3 stones side by side all matching
Fred 1860-1916
Lizzie, 1870-1936
Bertha, b/d/1902
PRICE BROWN
Joseph A PRICE 5/11/1813 DIED 1/9/1893 AGE 80
Wife, Mary Ann WILTSIE, dau of William and Mary Ann 3/29/1819 D 9/17/1892
age 73
Dau Olive married to Isaac BROWN of Randolph, Catt Co Ny her infant son,
Brown buried here with his grandparents,
Lucien Price b 1848 died 2/10/1922 age 74 never married
PRICE MANN
triple marker
Edward C.Price 1873-1944
May H. 1880-19-??
Lewis MANN 1870-1937
RAWSON BENNETT
Monument, with 4 smaller matching stones;
Lewellyn L RAWSON 1820-1866
Wife Nancy E. 1833-1895
Marcia L ( Rawson) Bennett (DAU) 1866-1949
Herbert R. BENNETT 1861-1943 (Son of Maria HASKINS and Milton BENNETT)
(*the name Bennett does not show on the marker, but Marcia is shown in the
1880 census as dau of Nancy widow RAWSON and Herbert Bennett shows in the
1880 census as son of the Bennett)
RICE
Wheeler RICE born Wendall MA March 19, 1810 died Nov 16, 1873 (Brother to
Serena RICE Covell also here )
Wife Betsey L. b ELLERY NY 1818 died 9/17/1892
Mrs. Jemie RICE died 5/19/1910 age 62-11-12 Who is SHE wife of?
RICKERSON
double marker
Arthur H. 1907-?
Lillian A. 1906 1981
RICKERSON BROKAW
;ot 127
double marker beside Arthur Rickerson's
James Ezra Rickerson, 1883-1957 (*son of Arthur I. Rickerson and Ella
(BENNETT)Wyman)
wife Luella B. 1886 1955 (Minnie Luella BROKAW)
RICKERSON
Son Everett William Rickerson 1905 d 11/8/1927 age 22
RICKERSON JOHNSON BENNETT
John L RICKERSON 1862-1919 Woodsmen of the world
Wife Viola BENNETT , 1871- 1940 she married 2nd to Archie JOHNSON she was
the dau of Milton BENNETT and Maria HASKINS she was born August 8, 1871 died
August 15, 1940
ROBBINS
lot 5
Frank P. Robbins b 1849 11/1/1928
Mary A died 1849 died 1/15/1945 age 94
They had 2 sons, 5 daughters, 27 Grand children and 30 Great and 60 GG
Grandchildren
ROBBINS
Lot 6 Bessie (Elizabeth L.) (ENOS) Robbins b 1874 d 1/15/1931
ROBBINS
Alfred E. Robbins 1919-1927
SCHOTT
lot 126
Gerald 6/15/1949
SCOTT FREDERICKSON
lot 3
Johanna Scott burial 1/2/1919
F. Frederickson 7/21/1891 age 67
SHELTERS
lot 13
Edward SHELTERS 3/29/1879 d 6/5/1939
Wife Maude WAID 11/18/1888 d 11/9/1945
SHURES
double marker
Eugene B 1935-1964 no name engraved
SHURES
Triple Marker
Mildred C 1913-??
Lou A. 1909-2000
Ida M "Mother" 1868-1950
SMITH
lot 185
Double marker
William Smith 1870-1952
Martha, 1871 - 1943
SOULE
Double marker
Robert Soule 1896-1976 Flag,
Wife Harriet 1905-1999
STOCKER
Ella J Stocker 1851-1925
SWAGER
2 matching stones
Martin Swager 1844-1928
Katherine Swager 1852-1925
SWAGER
double marker
Bert J. 1879-1961
E. Lulu 1879-1974
SWAGER KEHE JOHNSON
Double marker
Guy Swager 1877-1954 Son of Martin Swager
Florence M. JOHNSON 1883-1958 dau of Frank Johnson beside this marker is
Gertrude KEHE "Mother" 1907-1976 Gone but not forgotten
(Dau?)
SWANSON
lot 26
Roland D, d 3/23/1929
Richard Willis 6/11/1933
Donna Jean 6/11/1933
SWEET
lot 65 lot 66 is vacant
Infant and family left the area
TEMPLE
Robert A. 1911-1938
THORMAN HALE
both men lot 33
Charles F THORMAN 1869 d 11/22/1950
Clark J HALE 1871 d 5/31/1947
TODD ADAMS DAVIS
Major Martillus TODD died 5/30/1948 age 78-10-0 Served WWI and WWII
Wife Mary DAVIS d 10/6/1952 age 84-5-29
Katherine M Todd Adams d 7/24/1955 age 46-1-24
she was the 1st wife of Harry Davis ADAMS
TREADWAY LANE
lot 29
Charles R Treadway 1881- 9/5/1935
Wife Maude COLE 1887- 1983
Charles LANE 1943-1973
Arvilla A (TREADWAY) Lane, In Loving Memory, 1912-1995
WARD BROGUN
triple marker
Hazel M. 1905-1943
Blanche M. 1879-1962
E. Burton BROGUN 1897-1984
UNKNOWNS
Lot 18
4 burials, unknown persons
WAID SHELTERS
Lot 22
Ira L WAID 1846 d 1903 brother of Gertrude in lot 19
Laura SHELTERS d 10/5/1923 no age
Claude SHELTERS d 5/6/1941 age 60
Floyd SHELTERS d 12/18/1937 age 17
WAID GREGORY
Waid, Violet M., 82, died Feb. 12, 2000 in her residence. She was born Sept.
25, 1917, a daughter of the late Ralph and Ellen (Johnson) Gregory. She was
preceded in death by her parents; and by a brother, Leroy Gregory. Burial
was in Fentonville Cemetery. (pj obit)
WARNER
James H. Warner 1862 d 6 28/1941 age 79
Clara Warner WAID (remarried) d 3/5/1943 age 76
WARNER
lot 39
Lodasea 1839-2/18/1928 age 88
Robert 1834-1896 Civil War Veteran
George no data
John died 8/15/1924 age 64
WATKINS
Richard E Watkins 1871-1928
WETMORE
Seaman Wetmore died 8/13/1874 age 76-9-21
(Amelia Hubbard was his wife)
WETMORE LONKTO
in a row are individual markers;
2 old blue metal monuments/markers are in beautiful condition;
1 is Amelia (Millie) HUBBARD Wetmore b Litchfield CT 1800 died 3/15/1885 ae
85
(Amelia is still in the 1880 census as the mother of Marcus Howard age 27
town of Carroll)
next to her is a monument states only WETMORE
next is another blue metal matching Amelia for
Horace Wetmore, 12/24/1836 d 6/5/1879
beside him is a gray stone,name spelled Lourinda 1837-1910
(* Wife of LUCIUS WETMORE who was born c 1827 and in the 1880 census with
wife Lucinda, b 1837
Lucius is here also died 2/8/1917 )
individual markers for
Ebenezer WETMORE 4/14/1808 d 4/16/1851
beside Ann Eliza LONKTO 1876-1912
WETMORE
Double marker
Fred E. 1875-1947
M. Belle 1885-1966
WHEELER
Daniel WHEELER Soldier of the Revolution, ?
Originally buried on the W H Fenton farm, removed when street cars were
installed, bones buried on the KINESTON Lot, some relationship to Louisa
KINESTON, ) Heresay, notes of Evelynn Stone Crandall
(* Daniel was the son of Josiah Wheeler b 1764 and Mary Miles who came to
the town of Carroll, and I cannot find any records for either man in the Rev
War dd),
WIDRIG COWAN STOCKER
lot 122 Double marker
Birney G WIDRIG d 11/14/1941 Masonic Emblem
Wife Flora COWAN d 3/13/1933
WIDRIG
Sister Ella COWAN STOCKER d 8/7 1925 age 74
her son Frank L STOCKER b 7/22/1880 died (Interred )2/27/1954 age 73 his dau
Mrs Lawrence CHAPMAN brought his body here from Pittsburg PA
WILTSIE FORBUSH
a massive WILTSIE monument
John H. Wiltsie 2/12/1807 died 1/14/1885
Wife Eliza A. 11/26/1820 died 10/17/ 1904 smaller matching stones EAW and
JHW
(* Eliza is Eliza Ann FORBUSH b Sudbury, Worcester, Massachusetts Dau of
Luther and Eliza JONES Forbush also buried here)
John and Eliza married at Fentonville in 1839 John is John Hull Wiltsie son
of William Wiltsie and Mary HULL he was born Bethlehem, Dutchess, New York
(* notes for the Wiltsie family from the Wiltsie Cemetery online records
>From Century Farms No. 63 in the Jamestown Journal of 3 May 1952 one reads
that John Hull Wiltsie came from Otsego County about 1830 with six brothers
and sisters. According to family records John Hull Wiltsie was born 12
February 1807 in Cooperstown, NY, son of William and Mary (Hull) Wiltsie.
Though there are no records of the coming of their parents, the stone in the
cemetery is mute evidence that they did.
(*WILTSIE, William, died 15 Oct. 1846, age 65-1-23 father of John and
William)
There is no stone for Mary HULL though she died 22 years after her husband.
We wish the children had erected one. Mary was born 9 May 1789 and died 30
Oct. 1868, aged 82.
John Hull Wiltsie and wife Eliza Ann Forbush are buried in the Fentonville
Cemetery. After his death his grandson John Clarke Wiltsie bought up all the
land owned by the brothers and sisters. John Clark Wiltsie married Flora
Bradley and had four sons: William Luther, Harris B., John Clark Jr. and
Carver. Also, three daughters: Mrs. Grace Jacobson, Mrs. Esther Burkland,
and Mrs. Elizabeth Cowan
https://sites.rootsweb.com/~nychauta/CEMETERY/Wilt_cem.htm )
WILTSIE LOUCKS
2 matching markers, side by side
Isabelle LOUCKS / ADOPTED dau of John H Wiltsie and Eliza died Feb 26. 1866
aged 17-7-0
Addison Wiltsie, son of John and Eliza, died March 16, 1863 age 15-10-6
WILTSIE BUEL
Another BIG monument
one side reads
William Wiltsie, b 2/12/1812 died 2/12/1881 (*Brother to above John and son
of William Wiltsie and Mary Hull)
Wife No 1, Susan M. BUEL b 8/9/1813 died 9/16/1850
Wife 2 Susan JONES 8/28/1814 died 1/8/1893
Mary E. Wiltsie 11/4/1844 d 1/20/1921
another side reads
Charles H Wiltsie, 12/9/1838 died 11/8/1906
Wife Martha C. b 6/20/1844 died 3/29/1916
6 smaller initial stones surround this monument
WILTSIE CLARK
William L. (*Luther) Wiltsie 1843-1914
Wife Roxey A. (*CLARK) 1847-1896
(*Marriage: 4 Sep 1867 <Fentonville>, Chautauqua, New York)
WILTSIE CLARK
Small monument
side 1
Morgan CLARK 6/8/1841 no dd
Wife Hannah 2/28/1850 d 7/31/1891 (Hannah Eliza WILTSIE)
side 2
James C CLARK 1868 d 1949
Wife Hanna 1874-1964
WILTSIE
double marker
Harris Wiltsie 1902-1985
Mildred, 1899-1980
(*SS death index Harris WILTSIE Birth Date: 24 Apr 1902 Death Date: Jan 1985
died in Florida)
WILTSIE PETERS
lot 210
Mrs. Leland PETERS d 12/28/1956 age 38
(* She was Pauline WILTSIE, dau of Edward and Nelie Barberres Wiltsie)
WILTSIE BROKAW
James Wiltsie b 7/29/1821 died 6/16/1894 age 73 Son of Wm and Mary Hull
Wiltsie
Wife Catherine BROKAW born 11/1/1823 died 10/9/1905 age 81 dau of John
Brokaw and Judith VanArsdale)
WILTSIE
4 matching stones in a row
Augustus E. WILTSIE, "Father" 2/21/1847- 6/17/1897
(*He is Augustus Edward Wiltsie, b Fentonville, son of James Wiltsie and
Catherine Brokaw)
Ellen J. Wiltsie, "Mother" 1856-1928 (* wife of Augustus is Ellen J
HILLER
or MILLER)
Son, Harry Wiltsie b 1879 *18 Dec 1879
Birth Date: 18 Dec 1879 Death Date: Feb 1973 Wesleyville, Erie, Pennsylvania
Mildred 1890-1967
Mildred WILTSIE Birth Date: 5 Jul 1890 Death Date: Jun 1967 State or
Territory Where Number Was Issued: Pennsylvania Death Residence Localities
ZIP Code: 16345 Localities: Russell, Warren, Pennsylvania
WILTSIE
Edward A. (Augustus) Wiltsie 1876-1979
Wife Nellie F (BARBERRES) 1886-1945
beside matching stone for son
William E. WILTSIE, 4/13/1913 died 12/15/1963
also here is their dau;
Ellen Wiltsie b 29 Sep 1918 Jamestown, NY?Death: 29 Nov 1956
not known if she married , Another son was Ulysses G Wiltsie who was born
Fentonville 1915 d 1974 in Calif,
WILTSIE MOORE BLACKNER or BLACKMER
lot 94
Large Monument
John D. (*Dexter) Wiltsie, 1845-1910
2nd Wife Anna M. (MOORE)1847-1901
beside this monument are 2 smaller stones, John D and Anna
(first wife of John is Clara BLACKNER m 2/28/1868 she died and is buried
here lot 94
3/20/1869
WILTSIE
Double marker
George Wiltsie, 1823-1904
Wife Abby HURD 1824-1914
WILTSIE
Lot 59
David Wiltsie, b Bethlehem Albany,Co NY son of William Wiltsie and Mary Hull
9/7/1816 died 9/8/1884
Wife Priscilla Jane HADLEY or HEADLEY 11/22/1823 died 3/14/1894
Betsey J Wiltsie 9/28/1841 d 3/2/1842
Lora M b 8/18/1848 d 1/20/1849
Son of David, Lawrence, W (*Warren). Wiltsie b 1850-(*30 Mar 1850) d
2/20/1932
Wife Caroline P ABRAMS 1855-d 3/19/1918 age 63
their son David Hadley WILTSIE b 1888-d 7/1/1920 age 32
WINN THAYER
Lana M Thayer WINN 1/3/1856 wife of Adelbert WINN died 1/3/1892 age 36 Dau
of Hiram THAYER Died 4/15/1925 in his 70's listed as buried here, no stone
but there is space by Lana
Adelbert WINN son of Lana 1884-1891
WORDEN
Sylvester S, died 4/12/1908 age 68 Soldier of the Civil War served Co K 139
PA Vol Inf.
Wife Hannah M. (*DRAYTON)
Henry died 2/5/1926 no age found
WYMAN lot 162
William Wallace Wyman, b 1880, may or not be here lived in Warren Co PA
Wife Hannah Elizabeth SANDBERG 1879 died 1/10/1960 age 80
WYMAN STANTON RICKERSON BENNETT HASKINS
Richard Wyman died March 1879 (stone is very eroded and cannot read his age
but IGI lists him as husband of Ella BENNETT 1854-1950 dau of Ezra Bennett
and Martha HASKINS Ella married 2nd to Arthur I. RICKERSON and is buried
here their only WYMAN child was GIFT WYMAN buried Beside him;)
GIFT (WYMAN) w/o Frank STANTON, 1877-1899
stones beside Richard Wyman dau Gift
are 2 matching RICKERSON stones;
Arthur I RICKERSON 1856-1923 (Son of Noble Rickerson and A. Reed)
Ella (BENNETT) Rickerson, 1854-1950 Dau of Ezra BENNETT and Martha HASKINS
on the other side of stone for GIFT is another 2 matching stones;
Ada Bell dau of H.W.B (probably Henry W. BENNETT son of Ezra And Martha
Haskins Bennett ) 1878-1880
Lou, wife of H.W.B. 1867-1909
beside large monument for
BENNETT
smaller monument beside is
Ezra BENNETT 1825-1898
Wife Martha J (HASKINS) b March 9, 1833 died July 10, 1905 dau of Freedom
HASKINS and Catherine LESHER
YOUNG GRIFFIN
lot 192
David Leroy YOUNG 1890 died 4/23/1954 age 63-11-25
Wife Laura GRIFFIN b 1895 died 6/25/1941 age 46
Infant son, Donald, no dates his stone seems home made and no etching seen
SOURCE: Provided by Dolores Davidson, 2001.