Town of Coldspring - 1837

History of Coldspring

The Town of Coldspring, formed from Napoli on March 20, 1837. Parts of South Valley were taken off in 1847 and 1848. It takes its name from the creek of the same name which flows through the town. It is an interior town, lying in the southwest corner of Cattaraugus County. It is the second township of the eighth range of the Holland Land Company's survey. It covers an area of 17,787 acres. It is bounded on the south by Elko on the west by Randolph, on the north by Napoli and the east by Salamanca and Red House. Its surface is hilly and broken upland. The highest summits being 400-500 feet above the valley. The Allegany River flows southwest through the northeast corner, receiving the Cold Spring Creek as tributary. A sulphur spring is found in the N.E. part. The main industry was lumbering in the 1800s, but as the lands become deforested, agriculture took on more importance, especially the dairy industry. Important crops were hay, grain and potatoes.

Ed. Note: ¹ The town of Elko was absorbed into Coldspring in 1965 when the Kinzua Dam was built on the Allegheny River.

Pioneers of Cattaraugus County

Early pioneer landowners, taken from the 1819 Holland Land Company Records were Artemas Houghton, Philip Tome, Jesse Hotchkiss, Isaac Dow and Milton Holmes.

Philip Tome came from Susquehanna, Pennsylvania as early as 1818 and is believed to be the first white settler in town. He was a hunter and trapper, taking large numbers of elks, which were plentiful at that time. He was also a great lumberman, claiming to have run the first raft (60,000 feet) of lumber down the Allegany River. Several of his sons still lived in Willow Creek in 1878, and it was there that Philip Tome died.

Shortly after Mr. Tome, came three other pioneers, Mr. Conn, and James and Robert Pease, who only stayed a short while before moving on.

Jesse Hotchkiss came in 1819.

Isaac Merrill came from Oneida County in 1822, locating on lot 54 in the northwest corner of town. He was born in Connecticut ,April, 1779 and died in Randolph, Oct. 17, 1858. His wife, Rebecca Benedict was born in Connecticut , March 1781, and died in Coldspring, Sept 1864. A son, Isaac N, lived on Lot 50 in Napoli in 1878.

Early settlers included: Charles Crook came from Holland, in Erie County , in March 1822. He was born in 1751, and had fought in the army under Washington for several years. He located on Lot 32, in lower Hardscrabble, and built a shanty, a saw mill on Cold Spring Creek with Joshua Basson in 1822. His wife, Polly Chandler, was born in 1759 in New England, and died in Coldspring in 1833. Two of his sons, Stephen and Asa, died in Illinois . A third son, Elijah, was living in Indiana and running a boat on the Mississippi, when he left his home for a trip and was never heard from by his family again. Nathan, another son, was living on Lot 16, in the Bunker Hill Section, in 1878, and at that time was the oldest living settler in Coldspring. The Crooks were responsible for the first orchard, in 1823; the first frame barn in 1825; and the first sawmill. Joshua Basson, who came from Massachusetts in 1820. Other early settlers included: Eastman Prescott and his father, in the south part, and Isaac Merrill, in the north part in 1821.

The first child born was Martha, to Charles Crook, Jr and his wife, Sally Ballard in 1824; the first death was Miss Jones in fall of 1821.

The first school was taught by Miss E. Sanford, in 1831 . Philenus Hall kept the first inn and the first store, in 1822 .

• Seneca Indian Nation Cemetery; South end of Bunker Hill Rd/new cemetery built later/Contact Seneca Indian Nation
• Steamburg Cemetery; Rte 394, West of Steamburgh Contact: Mr. James Arrance, #10232 Arrance Rd., Steamburgh, NY 14783, telno: 716-354-4845
• Cemetery; Bunker Hill Rd, Coldspring/Maintained by the town of Coldspring 
  
• Carnahan Family Cemetery - Elko