Source: "One Hundredth Anniversary Exercises of The Baptist Church, Flemington, N. J.
June 17th, 18th & 19th, 1898."
"B" signifies received by Baptism; "L" by Letter; "E" by Experience; "R" by Restoration.
| Name | How Received | When Received |
| Abbott, Alice Higgins | B | 1856 |
| Abel, Horace G. | B | 1882 |
| Anderson, Mary Hartpence | B | 1864 |
| Apgar, George | B | 1887 |
| Bacorn, George | B | 1890 |
| Baird, Sallie Barton | B | 1874 |
| Bancroft, Susan Rowe | B | 1891 |
| Barrass, Alice | B | 1890 |
| Barrass, Bessie | B | 1890 |
| Barrass, Howard | B | 1887 |
| Barrass, Josie Dilts | B | 1879 |
| Barrass, Martha Ann Blackwell | B | 1843 |
| Barrass, Mary | B | 1890 |
| Barrass, Mary Gulick | B | 1862 |
| Barrass, Mary Smith | B | 1873 |
| Barrass, Richard | B | 1856 |
| Barrass, Richard, Jr. | B | 1892 |
| Barrass, Rose | B | 1892 |
| Barrass, Stella Rice | B | 1890 |
| Barrass, William, Jr. | B | 1882 |
| Bartles, Nettie Hill | B | 1887 |
| Barton, Bertha Britton | B | 1886 |
| Barton, Susan Merrell | L | 1897 |
| Barton, William S. | B | 1890 |
| Bellis, Emma Higgins | B | 1871 |
| Bennett, Benjamin | L | 1897 |
| Bennett, Harriet C. Howe | B | 1896 |
| Biggs, David | B | 1890 |
| Bloomer, Ada M. Green | B | 1894 |
| Bond, Mary Hampton | L | 1889 |
| Boyd, Martha Britton | B | 1871 |
| Brewer, Elizabeth Carkhuff | B | 1844 |
| Brewer, Hannah | B | 1885 |
| Brewer, Jane | L | 1892 |
| Brewer, Margaret Brewer | B | 1868 |
| Britton, Ann Jeroloman | B | 1860 |
| Britton, Annie | B | 1897 |
| Britton, Cornelia C. | B | 1895 |
| Britton, Ellen | B | 1864 |
| Britton, Ellen Ewing | B | 1860 |
| Britton, George E. | B | 1887 |
| Britton, Georgiana | B | 1864 |
| Britton, Harry | B | 1895 |
| Britton, Harry W. | B | 1891 |
| Britton, Henry | B | 1864 |
| Britton, J. Arthur | B | 1887 |
| Britton, John Wesley | B | 1856 |
| Britton, Josiah C. | B | 1864 |
| Britton, Julia Salter | L | 1890 |
| Britton, Martha Higgins | B | 1835 |
| Britton, Raymond | B | 1891 |
| Britton, Sarah Drake | B | 1868 |
| Britton, Sarah P. | B | 1870 |
| Britton, William J. | B | 1887 |
| Brokaw, Bergen H. | B | 1890 |
| Brokaw, Bessie Abel | B | 1876 |
| Brown, Mary Cronce | B | 1856 |
| Buchanan, Anna Ellen Hughes | B | 1854 |
| Buchanan, Charles | B | 1890 |
| Buchanan, Elizabeth | B | 1858 |
| Buchanan, Ella | B | 1897 |
| Buchanan, John H. | B | 1896 |
| Buchanan, Kate Deats | B | 1874 |
| Buchanan, William S. | B | 1874 |
| Buchanan, Willis | B | 1890 |
| Burd, Elizabeth Potts | B | 1864 |
| Burd, Harriet Schlapfer | B | 1894 |
| Burd, Joseph P. | B | 1882 |
| Burd, Kate Fulper | B | 1868 |
| Burd, Leonard G. | B | 1864 |
| Burd, Mary G. | B | 1887 |
| Burd, Sadie | B | 1890 |
| Burd, T. B. J. | L | 1872 |
| Burket, Corinda Walker | B | 1887 |
| Burket, Lemuel | B | 1890 |
| Campbell, Louisa Hoagland | B | 1870 |
| Carkhuff, Henrietta Yard | B | 1876 |
| Carkhuff, Margaret Case | B | 1841 |
| Carkhuff, Mattie Hoff | L | 1894 |
| Carkhuff, Peter J. | L | 1894 |
| Carkhuff, Sarah E. | B | 1868 |
| Carkhuff, Theodore S. | B | 1860 |
| Case, Daniel P. | L | 1895 |
| Case, Hannah Bateman | B | 1876 |
| Case, Jonathan | L | 1898 |
| Case, Minnie Sterms | L | 1895 |
| Castner, Abbie | L | 1889 |
| Castner, Millard P. | L | 1889 |
| Chamberlin, Mary | L | 1891 |
| Choyce, Rebecca | B | 1876 |
| Clawson, Abel S. | L | 1872 |
| Clawson, Ethel | B | 1890 |
| Clawson, Granville | B | 1892 |
| Clayton, Charity Hummer | B | 1864 |
| Cole, Ella Ewing | B | 1871 |
| Coleman, Frank | B | 1894 |
| Coleman, Levina Baird | B | 1891 |
| Conover, Harriet | B | 1892 |
| Conover, Mary E. | B | 1882 |
| Conover, Naomi | B | 1894 |
| Conover, Nellie | B | 1892 |
| Conover, Sadie | B | 1892 |
| Coyle, Ella Gordon | B | 1887 |
| Cronce, Henry | B | 1882 |
| Cronce, Mary | B | 1877 |
| Cronce, Mary | B | 1892 |
| Cronce, Rachel Gulick | B | 1862 |
| Cronce, Richard | B | 1877 |
| Crum, Gussie | B | 1893 |
| Dalrymple, Clara Hoff | B | 1887 |
| Davis, Minnie V. Miller | B | 1892 |
| Dean, George W. | B | 1894 |
| Dean, Tillie Barrass | B | 1887 |
| Dean, Walter R. | B | 1894 |
| Demott, Sallie Higgins | B | 1864 |
| Dilts, Anna Dean | L | 1871 |
| Dilts, Frank | B | 1897 |
| Dilts, Hannah F. | L | 1895 |
| Dilts, Laura | L | 1894 |
| Dilts, Lizzie | L | 1894 |
| Dilts, Oliver C. | L | 1876 |
| Dilts, Rachael A. Merrell | L | 1897 |
| Dilts, Theodore | B | 1892 |
| Downs, Susan Cole | B | 1856 |
| Emerson, Kittie Rockafellow | B | 1887 |
| Ent, Getta Maria Carkhuff | B | 1864 |
| Ent, Laura | B | 1895 |
| Ent, Margaretta Biggs | B | 1864 |
| Everitt, Annie | B | 1897 |
| Everitt, Elnora Higgins | B | 1864 |
| Everitt, Ezekiel L. | L | 1858 |
| Everitt, Mary Wilson | B | 1876 |
| Everitt, William L. | L | 1891 |
| Ewing, Ann Higgins | B | 1842 |
| Ewing, Eliza Brewer | B | 1874 |
| Ewing, Georgia Emma | B | 1876 |
| Ewing, James G. | B | 1849 |
| Ewing, Julia A. Clawson | B | 1882 |
| Ewing, Martha | B | 1851 |
| Fackenthall, Clarissa Smith | B | 1856 |
| Fackenthall, William | B | 1870 |
| Fink, Chrissie Cook | B | 1873 |
| Fink, Henry | B | 1880 |
| Fink, Ida | B | 1893 |
| Fisher, Charles T. | B | 1887 |
| Fisher, Ellen Hope | E | 1870 |
| Fisher, George E. | B | 1882 |
| Fisher, Luella Stout | B | 1874 |
| Fisher, Mary Leigh | B | 1887 |
| Fisher, Mary R. | B | 1888 |
| Fisher, William | B | 1870 |
| Fleming, Amanda Dilley | B | 1865 |
| Fluck, Anna Parker | B | 1869 |
| Fluck, Henry A. | B | 1871 |
| Fluck, Linton | B | 1897 |
| Forker, Elmira | B | 1854 |
| Forker, Rebecca Housel | B | 1838 |
| Freeman, Anna M. Higgins | B | 1883 |
| Fulper, Catharine Van Fleet | B | 1869 |
| Fulper, Charles | B | 1864 |
| Fulper, Eva | B | 1897 |
| Fulper, George W. | B | 1887 |
| Fulper, Harry D. | B | 1894 |
| Fulper, Jane Forker | B | 1843 |
| Fulper, Julia | B | 1890 |
| Fulper, Martha R. | B | 1894 |
| Fulper, Mary C. Reading | B | 1887 |
| Fulper, Mary Higgins | B | 1856 |
| Fulper, William H., Jr. | B | 1887 |
| Gaddis, Annie E. Hoffman | B | 1860 |
| Gano, John | B | 1869 |
| Gary, Mahlon G. | L | 1894 |
| Gary, Margaret L. | L | 1894 |
| Golden, Carrie Rockafellow | B | 1874 |
| Goodfellow, James | B | 1890 |
| Grabow, Christina Disbrow | B | 1874 |
| Grabow, John H. | B | 1874 |
| Gray, Elizabeth | B | 1868 |
| Gray, Mary R. | B | 1877 |
| Gray, Matilda Case | B | 1838 |
| Green, Harry | B | 1887 |
| Green, Julia Dean | B | 1887 |
| Gulick, Henry | B | 1856 |
| Hall, Evangeline Rockafellow | L | 1869 |
| Hall, Margaret | B | 1897 |
| Hall, Mary A. Losey | B | 1856 |
| Hall, Nettie | B | 1887 |
| Hall, William H. | L | 1869 |
| Hampton, Joseph | L | 1889 |
| Hampton, Susan Swallow | L | 1889 |
| Hann, Albert | B | 1892 |
| Hann, Isaac | B | 1887 |
| Hann, Lewis | B | 1887 |
| Hann, Mary | E | 1876 |
| Hann, Stacy | E | 1876 |
| Hanson, Davis | B | 1874 |
| Hanson, Fanny Holcomb | B | 1882 |
| Hanson, George F. | B | 1877 |
| Hanson, Mary J. | B | 1894 |
| Hardin, Mary C. | B | 1894 |
| Henry, Ann | L | 1891 |
| Henry, Francis E. | B | 1892 |
| Higgins, Alexander | B | 1895 |
| Higgins, Anna | B | 1864 |
| Higgins, Bessie | B | 1887 |
| Higgins, Bessie Thompson | B | 1880 |
| Higgins, D. Walter | B | 1892 |
| Higgins, David E. | B | 1860 |
| Higgins, Edward R. | B | 1887 |
| Higgins, Eliza Rockafellow | L | 1854 |
| Higgins, Ella C. | B | 1874 |
| Higgins, Ezekiel L. | B | 1868 |
| Higgins, G. Barton | B | 1874 |
| Higgins, George C. | B | 1863 |
| Higgins, Gussie Snedeker | L | 1887 |
| Higgins, Harry V. | B | 1896 |
| Higgins, Helen R. | B | 1896 |
| Higgins, Issachar | B | 1876 |
| Higgins, J. Schenck | B | 1890 |
| Higgins, Jacob V. | B | 1869 |
| Higgins, James J. | B | 1877 |
| Higgins, Johanna | B | 1851 |
| Higgins, Jonathan | B | 1864 |
| Higgins, Judiah | B | 1887 |
| Higgins, Leila M. | B | 1878 |
| Higgins, Lizzie B. | B | 1887 |
| Higgins, Lizzie Jeroloman | L | 1858 |
| Higgins, Lucinda Larue | E | 1878 |
| Higgins, Lucretia | B | 1887 |
| Higgins, Lucretia Rockafellow | B | 1851 |
| Higgins, Lydia Jeroloman | L | 1858 |
| Higgins, Mabel | B | 1890 |
| Higgins, Martha K. | L | 1892 |
| Higgins, Mary | B | 1863 |
| Higgins, Mary Marsh | B | 1876 |
| Higgins, Mary R. | B | 1854 |
| Higgins, Sarah B. | B | 1851 |
| Higgins, Sarah Gaddis | B | 1882 |
| Higgins, Vandavier | B | 1854 |
| Higgins, William A. | B | 1890 |
| Higgins, William F. | B | 1894 |
| Hill, Carrie | B | 1883 |
| Hill, George W. | B | 1877 |
| Hill, John | B | 1882 |
| Hill, John B. | L | 1875 |
| Hill, Kate Yard | B | 1890 |
| Hill, Mary Bloom | B | 1886 |
| Hilyer, Fanny Snyder | B | 1887 |
| Hilyer, Pierson W. | B | 1887 |
| Hoagland, Gardner | B | 1897 |
| Hoagland, Lena | B | 1871 |
| Hoagland, Lizzie | B | 1887 |
| Hopewell, Ida Harsell | B | 1887 |
| Hughes, Arthur | B | 1851 |
| Hughes, Bertha | B | 1887 |
| Hughes, Ella Rittenhouse | B | 1876 |
| Hughes, George C. | B | 1882 |
| Hughes, Susan Stires | B | 1867 |
| Hughes, William, Jr. | B | 1882 |
| Hyde, Clifford | B | 1882 |
| Hyde, Ella G. | B | 1887 |
| Hyde, Emily F. | L | 1892 |
| Hyde, Hulda Rittenhouse | L | 1878 |
| Jefferson, Christopher K. | B | 1843 |
| Jefferson, Thomas | E | 1874 |
| Johnson, Addie S. | B | 1887 |
| Johnson, Ann | L | 1864 |
| Johnson, Anna Gethard | B | 1894 |
| Johnson, Anna Hill | B | 1882 |
| Johnson, John | L | 1890 |
| Johnson, Kate | L | 1890 |
| Johnson, Maggie | B | 1890 |
| Johnson, Mamie | B | 1885 |
| Johnson, Robert | L | 1890 |
| Johnson, Theodore W. | B | 1890 |
| Kerr, Mary Miller | B | 1891 |
| Kilgore, Alice | B | 1864 |
| Kilgore, Ella Dunham | B | 1877 |
| Kilgore, Jennie | B | 1890 |
| Kilgore, Mary V. | B | 1864 |
| Knower, Edward D. | B | 1870 |
| Knower, Ella Riley | B | 1870 |
| Knower, John | B | 1892 |
| Knower, Mary B. | B | 1890 |
| Lair, George | B | 1874 |
| Lake, Hannah Danbury | B | 1848 |
| Larue, Minnie | B | 1893 |
| Larue, Rachel | B | 1890 |
| Lederer, Charles | B | 1890 |
| Leigh, Jennie | B | 1890 |
| Leigh, Samuel | B | 1829 |
| Losey, Catharine | R | 1890 |
| Losey, Maggie | B | 1890 |
| Lott, Edna | B | 1897 |
| Lott, Lizzie H. | B | 1894 |
| Lott, Mabel | B | 1897 |
| Lovell, Annie E. Fisher | B | 1882 |
| Mahoney, Mary Rittenhouse | L | 1892 |
| Marsh, Edith B. | B | 1896 |
| Marsh, Mary Higgins | B | 1870 |
| Mathews, Edwin | B | 1892 |
| Mattison, Lizzie Deats | B | 1892 |
| Mattison, Mary Britton | B | 1873 |
| McCann, Jane Hoff | B | 1842 |
| McCann, Louie C. | B | 1882 |
| McPherson, Charity Hill | L | 1887 |
| McPherson, Willard F. | B | 1894 |
| Merrell, Anna M. Suydam | B | 1864 |
| Merrell, Catharine S. | B | 1894 |
| Merrell, Jane Hixon Bullock | B | 1848 |
| Merrell, Jesse | B | 1860 |
| Merrell, Lucinda D. | B | 1886 |
| Miller, Aletta Cronce | B | 1871 |
| Miller, George | B | 1893 |
| Miller, James | B | 1890 |
| Miller, John M. | B | 1892 |
| Miller, Julia Griggs | B | 1890 |
| Miller, Mrs. John | L | 1892 |
| Miller, Raymond | B | 1892 |
| Miller, William | B | 1871 |
| Moore, Charlotte Swallow | B | 1838 |
| Moore, Lizzie Servis | L | 1887 |
| Moore, Mary | B | 1894 |
| Murray, Anna Case | B | 1877 |
| Murray, Kate | B | 1877 |
| Opcdyke, Jemima Hartpence | B | 1894 |
| Opcdyke, Lewis A. | B | 1874 |
| Opcdyke, Lizzie A. | B | 1894 |
| Parker, Ellen Higgins | L | 1852 |
| Paul, Harry H. | B | 1896 |
| Paul, Tillie | B | 1896 |
| Peterson, Lizzie M. Reading | B | 1894 |
| Pilger, Ella Yard | B | 1890 |
| Pilger, Jacob G. | E | 1890 |
| Pilger, John G. | B | 1894 |
| Pilger, Mary Everitt | L | 1890 |
| Pimm, Hattie Madara | B | 1887 |
| Pimm, Wm. B. | R | 1887 |
| Poulson, Emma Hudnit | B | 1877 |
| Price, Lillian Warman | B | 1876 |
| Ramsey, May Sutphin | B | 1883 |
| Reading, Bessie | L | 1896 |
| Reading, Cesar | B | 1851 |
| Reading, Hannah Boeman | B | 1854 |
| Reading, Oscar | B | 1848 |
| Rice, Albert A. | B | 1894 |
| Rice, Eva | B | 1896 |
| Rice, Forest A. | B | 1876 |
| Rice, Josephine Opcdyke | B | 1880 |
| Riley, Maria Sked | E | 1878 |
| Riley, William S. | E | 1878 |
| Risinger, Anna Yard | B | 1890 |
| Rittenhouse, Albertus K. | L | 1892 |
| Rittenhouse, Bertha | B | 1892 |
| Rittenhouse, Elnora Olmstead | B | 1877 |
| Rittenhouse, Hawley O. | B | 1873 |
| Rittenhouse, Jane Shepherd | B | 1876 |
| Rittenhouse, Kate Stryker | B | 1892 |
| Rittenhouse, Will Fisher | L | 1892 |
| Robbins, Bertha | B | 1887 |
| Robbins, Elizabeth Roberson | L | 1874 |
| Robbins, Susan Rittenhouse | B | 1878 |
| Roberson, Amzi | L | 1883 |
| Robinson, Betty | B | 1882 |
| Rockafellow, Ann E. Leigh | B | 1854 |
| Rockafellow, Ella V. | B | 1887 |
| Rockafellow, Emily | B | 1851 |
| Rockafellow, Georgia C. | B | 1887 |
| Rockafellow, John M. | B | 1874 |
| Rockafellow, Joseph | R | 1887 |
| Rockafellow, Lizzie R. | B | 1887 |
| Rockafellow, Martha B. | B | 1851 |
| Rockafellow, Mary | B | 1882 |
| Rockafellow, Mary L. | B | 1886 |
| Rockafellow, Peter S. | B | 1874 |
| Rockafellow, Tillie | B | 1874 |
| Rowe, Jacob R. | B | 1892 |
| Rowe, Lizzie | B | 1892 |
| Rowe, Mary | B | 1892 |
| Salter, Esther Dalrymple | E | 1869 |
| Salter, Joseph | B | 1876 |
| Schenck, Anna M. | B | 1894 |
| Schenck, Ella Johnson | B | 1868 |
| Schenck, Laura Barton | B | 1874 |
| Schenck, Peter C. | B | 1882 |
| Schenck, Susan P. | B | 1894 |
| Schlapfer, Albert | B | 1887 |
| Schlapfer, Mary Swallow | B | 1887 |
| Scudder, Laura Higgins | B | 1887 |
| Sebring, Anna Rockafellow | B | 1874 |
| Servis, Theodore | L | 1887 |
| Sheats, Catharine Ewing | L | 1871 |
| Sheppard, Howard | B | 1890 |
| Sheppard, Jennie Nevius | B | 1874 |
| Sheppard, Mary Bateman | B | 1876 |
| Sheppard, William E. | L | 1859 |
| Shrope, Rebecca | L | 1890 |
| Shurts, Anna G. Croce | B | 1882 |
| Simmons, Walter Edward | B | 1894 |
| Sloff, John A. | B | 1893 |
| Sloff, Mary Williamson | B | 1883 |
| Smith, Adelbert | B | 1892 |
| Smith, Catharine Leigh | B | 1843 |
| Smith, Charles | B | 1882 |
| Smith, James | B | 1892 |
| Smith, Jane Stewart | L | 1882 |
| Smith, Laura | B | 1895 |
| Smith, Lewis K. | L | 1877 |
| Smith, Lewis K. | L | 1891 |
| Smith, Lillie | B | 1892 |
| Smith, Lincoln G. | B | 1882 |
| Smith, Lizzie McCann | B | 1882 |
| Smith, Oliver | B | 1882 |
| Smith, Olivia C. | L | 1895 |
| Smith, Walter | B | 1887 |
| Smith, William B. | L | 1877 |
| Snedeker, Helen | L | 1897 |
| Snyder, Charles | L | 1892 |
| Snyder, Henry | L | 1892 |
| Snyder, Jennie | L | 1892 |
| Snyder, Laura Dean | B | 1887 |
| Snyder, Lida Griggs | B | 1887 |
| Snyder, Maggie M. | B | 1897 |
| Snyder, Rebecca Dean | B | 1887 |
| Sproul, Eleanor | B | 1897 |
| Sproul, Florence Hyde | B | 1895 |
| Stenabaugh, Tillie Pimm | B | 1879 |
| Stone, Josiah A. | B | 1882 |
| Stothoff, Emma Hill | L | 1875 |
| Stothoff, Samuel | B | 1890 |
| Stout, Ann | B | 1842 |
| Stout, William | B | 1851 |
| Stryker, Asher | B | 1892 |
| Stryker, Hannah | L | 1895 |
| Stryker, Mary Rowe | B | 1875 |
| Sutphin, Annie | B | 1897 |
| Sutphin, Bessie | B | 1897 |
| Sutphin, Elizabeth Groff | B | 1868 |
| Sutphin, Howard | B | 1880 |
| Sutphin, Nedwell | B | 1894 |
| Sutton, James | B | 1897 |
| Sutton, Jonathan P. | L | 1894 |
| Sutton, Mary E. Gary | L | 1894 |
| Suydam, Asa | B | 1848 |
| Suydam, Corinda Higgins | B | 1883 |
| Suydam, Daniel | B | 1838 |
| Suydam, Ella R. | B | 1874 |
| Suydam, Emily Parker | B | 1864 |
| Suydam, Hannah | B | 1864 |
| Suydam, Henry | B | 1869 |
| Suydam, Katie | B | 1876 |
| Suydam, Lizzie Trimmer | B | 1869 |
| Suydam, Mary | B | 1897 |
| Suydam, Robert R. | L | 1868 |
| Suydam, William J. | B | 1874 |
| Swallow, Emma | B | 1864 |
| Swallow, Hannah E. Higgins | L | 1872 |
| Swallow, William B. | B | 1839 |
| Tennent, Ann E. Van Syckel | B | 1883 |
| Thatcher, Barton H. | B | 1892 |
| Thatcher, William H. | B | 1883 |
| Trewin, Alice Brewer | B | 1874 |
| Trewin, Charlotte Harrison | B | 1883 |
| Trewin, Peter E. | B | 1883 |
| Trewin, Robert | B | 1882 |
| Trewin, William E. | B | 1870 |
| Trimmer, Elizabeth Robbins | L | 1869 |
| Van Syckel, Chester | L | 1859 |
| Van Syckel, Emmet | B | 1887 |
| Van Syckel, Jennie | B | 1890 |
| Van Syckel, Mary | B | 1877 |
| Van Syckel, Mary J. Mount | L | 1871 |
| Wagoner, Ella Merrell | B | 1868 |
| Wagoner, George | B | 1866 |
| Wagoner, Rachel | B | 1868 |
| Wagoner, Rhoda | B | 1868 |
| Walker, John | B | 1864 |
| Wallace, Martha Sutphin | B | 1878 |
| Webb, Ida Opcdyke | B | 1892 |
| Webb, William | B | 1894 |
| Williamson, Barton H. | B | 1893 |
| Williamson, Jane Hummer | B | 1861 |
| Woodruff, Addie W. | B | 1887 |
| Woodruff, Edward | B | 1887 |
| Woodruff, Gideon | E | 1887 |
| Woodruff, Nancy Case | L | 1887 |
| Yard, Mary Mason | B | 1856 |
| Young, Augustus | B | 1890 |
| Young, Elizabeth Dailey | B | 1890 |
| Young, Julia Higgins | B | 1864 |
| Zwicky, George | B | 1897 |
