| SACCHITELLO | Catholic |
| SACKS | Friendship Park |
| SADLER | Greenlawn, Hilldale |
| SAGE | West White Lick |
| SAILORS | Liberty, South Park |
| SALLUST | Walters |
| SALMON | Easthill |
| SALTCORN | Easthill |
| SALYER | Mount Pleasant/Hall |
| SAMPLE | Friendship Park |
| SAMPSON | West White Lick, Centerton |
| SANBORN | West Union |
| SANDERFIER | Old Baptist |
| SANDERS | Brooklyn, Centerton, Centennial, Union Chapel, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Odd Fellows, Easthill, Nast Chapel, Bethlehem, Greenlawn, Liberty |
| SANDUSKY | Mount Pleasant/Hall |
| SANDY | Olive Christian, Friendship Park, Stierwalt, Greenlawn |
| SANFORD | Mount Pleasant/Hall |
| SARGENT | Centerton, Centennial, Greenlawn, South Park |
| SARRAN | Friendship Park |
| SATER | New Salem Baptist |
| SATTER | Easthill |
| SAUCERMAN | Brooklyn |
| SAUER | Easthill |
| SAVAGE | Centerton, Greenlawn |
| SAWYER | New Salem Baptist, Brooklyn, Odd Fellows, Mount Olive, Old Mount Olive, Centenary, West Union |
| SAWYERS | Centenary, Landers, Mount Olive (Madison Twp) |
| SAXE | Centennial |
| SCAGGS | Easthill, Mount Zion Baptist |
| SCARBROUGH | Mount Nebo |
| SCATES | Mount Nebo |
| SCHAFER | Centennial, Greenlawn |
| SCHAFFER | Centennial |
| SCHAFHAUSER | South Park |
| SCHAUB | Hilldale |
| SCHEERER | Cunningham Hill |
| SCHERER | Greenlawn |
| SCHERLE | Friendship Park |
| SCHIFFER | Centennial |
| SCHNAITER | Easthill, Greenlawn, Hilldale |
| SCHINDLER | Easthill |
| SCHISSELE | Centennial |
| SCHLOSSER | Mount Zion Baptist |
| SCHMALZ | Mount Zion Baptist |
| SCHMIDT | South Park |
| SCHOFIELD | Hilldale |
| SCHOLFIELD | Thompson |
| SCHOLL | Greenlawn |
| SCHOOLCRAFT | Brooklyn, Easthill, Mahalasville, Gose Creek, Greenlawn, Liberty |
| SCHOOLEY | Mount Nebo |
| SCHOVEL | Hilldale |
| SCHUCK | Hilldale |
| SCHULER | Friendship Park |
| SCHULMYER | Hilldale |
| SCHUYLAR | Sand Creek |
| SCHWOMEYER | Mannan, Centennial |
| SCOBEE | Easthill |
| SCOTT | Union Christian, West White Lick, Brooklyn, Centerton, Centennial, Williams/Bradford, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Mount Zion (Gregg Twp), Poplar Grove, Odd Fellows, Shiloh, Whetzel, Easthill, North Branch, West Union, Friendship Park, Gose Creek, Greenlawn, Hilldale, South Park |
| SCOTTEN | Mount Pleasant/Hall, Poplar Grove, Scotten |
| SCROGHAM | Easthill |
| SCROGIN | Scrogin, Mount Nebo |
| SCUDDER | Friendship Park |
| SCULLY | Friendship Park |
| SEAMAN | Hilldale, Nutter |
| SEARCY | Mount Zion Baptist, Mount Gilead, Greenlawn |
| SEARS | Easthill, Mount Olive (Madison Twp) |
| SEATON | Mount Pleasant/Hall |
| SECHREST | Lingle |
| SECHRIST | Lingle |
| SECOY | Mount Gilead |
| SECREST | Lingle, Olive Christian, West White Lick, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Poplar Grove, Friendship Park, Samaria, Greenlawn |
| SEDAM | Odd Fellows, Whetzel, Centenary |
| SEDWICK | West Union, Greenlawn |
| SEELEY | Foster |
| SEGER | Poplar Grove |
| SEIDERS | South Park |
| SEITZ | Nutter |
| SELBURG | Greenlawn |
| SELCH | Union Chapel, Mount Pleasant/Hall, West Union |
| SELF | West White Lick, Greenlawn |
| SELLARS | Monical, West White Lick |
| SELLERS | Monical, Mount Zion Baptist |
| SELWA | Brooklyn |
| SHACKELFORD | Centerton |
| SHACKLEFORD | Brooklyn |
| SHAFER | Mount Pleasant/Hall |
| SHAKE | Mount Tabor, Shumaker, Walters, Mount Pleasant/Hall, West Union |
| SHANE | West White Lick, Brooklyn, Mount Nebo, Nutter, South Park |
| SHANK | Easthill |
| SHANNON | Easthill, West Union |
| SHARP | Mount Olive (Madison Twp) |
| SHAW | Mannan, Centennial, West Union, Greenlawn, South Park |
| SHAWVER | Bethesda |
| SHEAFER | Easthill |
| SHEELY | Brooklyn |
| SHEERER | Liberty |
| SHEETS | West White Lick, Bethesda |
| SHEETZ | Brooklyn, Odd Fellows |
| SHELL | Easthill |
| SHELTMIRE | Union Chapel |
| SHELTON | Mount Pleasant/Hall, Mount Olive, Free Methodist |
| SHEPARD | Old Baptist |
| SHEPHERD | Brooklyn |
| SHEPLOB | Hilldale |
| SHEPLOR | Friendship Park, Greenlawn |
| SHEPP | Greenlawn |
| SHEPPARD | Cunningham Hill, South Park |
| SHERMAN | Easthill, Hilldale |
| SHERRILL | Centerton |
| SHEWMAKER | West Union |
| SHIELDS | Mount Tabor, Walters, Williams/Bradford, Mount Pleasant/Hall, West Union, Friendship Park, Samaria, Hilldale, South Park |
| SHIERMAN | Sand Creek |
| SHINKLE | Greenlawn |
| SHIPLEY | Mount Olive, Old Mount Olive, Greenlawn, Liberty, South Park |
| SHIPPS | Williams/Bradford |
| SHIREMAN | Odd Fellows, Easthill, Friendship Park, Cramer, Greenlawn, Hilldale, Sand Creek, South Park |
| SHIRLEY | Centennial, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Hilldale |
| SHOEMAKER | Shumaker, Mannan, Olive Christian, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Hynds |
| SHOFNER | Mount Pleasant/Hall, Williams(Washington Twp) |
| SHOFFNER | Bethesda, Greenlawn |
| SHOMAKER | Hilldale |
| SHOPPELL | Walters |
| SHORT | Hilldale |
| SHOVER | Bethel (Brown Twp), Easthill, Bethesda |
| SHOWALTER | South Park |
| SHOWECKER | Shumaker |
| SHOWERS | Brooklyn |
| SHRAKE | Brooklyn, Centerton |
| SHUCK | Hilldale |
| SHUEY | Friendship Park |
| SHUFFLEBARGER | Whetzel |
| SHULER | Mount Tabor, Lingle, Mannan, Olive Christian, Ratts, Shuler, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Odd Fellows, Samaria, Greenlawn |
| SHULTZ | Shultz |
| SHUMAKER | Shumaker, Walters, Mannan |
| SHVEY | Hilldale |
| SICHTING | Centennial, Union Chapel, Mount Nebo, Nast Chapel, Greenlawn |
| SIEGEL | Mount Zion Baptist |
| SILCOX | Samaria |
| SILER | Greenlawn |
| SILVEY | Greenlawn, Hilldale |
| SIMES | Centerton |
| SIMMON | South Park |
| SIMMONS | Mahalasville, Mount Olive (Madison Twp), Williams(Washington Twp) |
| SIMMS | Sand Creek |
| SIMON | Nast Chapel |
| SIMONS | Easthill |
| SIMPSON | Shumaker, Centerton, Mount Gilead Chapel, Bethlehem, West Union, Hilldale |
| SIMS | Union Christian, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Friendship Park, Greenlawn, Hilldale |
| SINGLETON | Centennial, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Mount Zion Baptist, Mount Olive, Cramer, Gose Creek, Hilldale, Sand Creek, South Park |
| SINK | Mannan, Olive Christian, Friendship Park, Myers, Liberty |
| SISSON | Easthill, Greenlawn |
| SKAGGS | Centennial, Thompson, Union Chapel, Mount Zion Baptist, Greenlawn |
| SKELTON | Alaska |
| SKILLMAN | Mount Pleasant/Hall |
| SKINNER | Old Baptist, Easthill |
| SLACK | Easthill, Mahalasville, Mount Zion Baptist, Hilldale |
| SLAUGHTER | Brooklyn, Slaughter Grove, Odd Fellows |
| SLAVEN | Greenlawn |
| SLEIGHTER | Easthill |
| SLIGAR | Walters |
| SLOAN | Centennial, Mount Gilead, Shultz, Friendship Park, Greenlawn, Liberty |
| SLOUGH | Centennial |
| SMALL | Greenlawn, Hilldale |
| SMART | Walters |
| SMEDLEY | Walters |
| SMITH | Mount Tabor, Shumaker, Walters, Mannan, New Salem Baptist, Union Christian, West White Lick, Brooklyn, Centerton, Centennial, Highland, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Mount Zion (Gregg Twp), Odd Fellows, Old Baptist, Easthill, Mount Nebo, Mount Zion Baptist, Nast Chapel, Mount Gilead, Mount Olive, Centenary, Friendship Park, Stierwalt, Greenlawn, Hilldale, Liberty, Long, Sand Creek, Williams(Washington Twp) |
| SMOCK | Brooklyn, Mitchell |
| SMYLIE | Easthill |
| SMYSER | Easthill |
| SMYTH | Easthill |
| SNETHEN | Brooklyn |
| SNIDER | Easthill |
| SNOW | Easthill, Mount Gilead |
| SNYDER | New Salem Baptist, Easthill, Greenlawn |
| SOCTT | Easthill |
| SOLAN | Hilldale |
| SOLMON | Mount Nebo |
| SOOTS | Brooklyn |
| SOSBE | Old Baptist, Easthill |
| SOSBEY | Easthill |
| SOUDERS | Friendship Park |
| SOUTHERN | Foster |
| SPAHR | Easthill |
| SPAIN | Walters, Alaska, Mannan, Spain, Centennial |
| SPANGLER | Mannan |
| SPARKS | Easthill, Mount Olive, Cunningham Hill, Hilldale, Nutter |
| SPEARS | Easthill |
| SPENCE | Morgan Family |
| SPENCER | Bethel (Brown Twp), Mount Pleasant/Hall, Friendship Park |
| SPILLMAN | Greenlawn |
| SPOON | West White Lick, Centenary, Bethesda |
| SPRANGLER | Albertson |
| SPRAGUE | Easthill, Mount Nebo, Liberty |
| SPROULS | Greenlawn |
| SPROUSE | Centennial |
| SPURGEON | Easthill |
| SPURLING | Wright |
| SPURLOCK | Centennial |
| SQUIRES | West White Lick, Mount Olive (Madison Twp) |
| STADER | Mount Pleasant/Hall |
| STAFFORD | Brooklyn, Centerton, Williams/Bradford, Highland, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Williams(Washington Twp) |
| STAGG | Liberty |
| STAIRWALT | Walters, Goss |
| STALEY | Walters, Centennial, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Centenary |
| STALLMAN | Greenlawn |
| STALLMANN | Greenlawn |
| STANCOMBE | North Branch |
| STANFIELD | Brooklyn |
| STANGER | Greenlawn |
| STANLEY | West White Lick, Mount Pleasant/Hall, North Branch, Gose Creek, Liberty, South Park |
| STANTON | Walters, Bethel (Brown Twp), Highland, West Union |
| STAREWALT | Goss |
| STARK | Stierwalt |
| STARKEY | Hilldale, Williams(Washington Twp) |
| STARNES | Olive Christian |
| STATZELL | Mount Gilead Chapel, Bethesda |
| STAYTON | Centerton |
| STCLAIR | Old Baptist, Greenlawn |
| STEEL | Free Methodist |
| STEELE | Easthill, Mount Nebo, Mount Zion Baptist, Greenlawn, South Park |
| STEIGER | Centerton |
| STEINWAY | Greenlawn |
| STEMBEL | West White Lick |
| STEPHEN | Friendship Park |
| STEPHENS | Bethel (Brown Twp), West White Lick, Liberty |
| STEPHENSON | Mount Olive (Madison Twp), Greenlawn |
| STEPP | Centerton |
| STEVASON | Union Chapel |
| STEVENS | Mannan, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Easthill, Friendship Park, Samaria, Greenlawn, Hilldale, South Park |
| STEVENSON | West White Lick, Mahalasville |
| STEWARD | Brooklyn, New Butterfield, Williams/Bradford, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Mount Zion (Gregg Twp), Whetzel, Sand Creek |
| STEWART | Mount Tabor, New Salem Baptist, Kenworthy, Odd Fellows, Mahalasville, Mount Zion Baptist, Mount Olive (Madison Twp), Friendship Park, Greenlawn, Liberty, South Park, Williams(Washington Twp) |
| STIERWALT | Walters, Lingle, Mannan, Olive Christian, Centennial, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Shultz, Friendship Park, Goss, Samaria, Stierwalt |
| STILES | West White Lick, Bethlehem, Foster, Hynds, Friendship Park, Greenlawn |
| STIMSON | Mahalasville |
| STINE | Centennial, Friendship Park, Greenlawn, Hilldale, Sand Creek |
| STIPP | Centerton, New Butterfield, Williams(Washington Twp) |
| STIREWALT | Goss, Stierwalt |
| STITT | Stitt/Maxwell |
| STJOHN | Brooklyn, Centennial, Williams/Bradford, Shiloh, Greenlawn |
| STOCKWELL | Patrick/Whitaker, Mannan, Sand Creek |
| STOCKTON | Easthill |
| STOLTY | West Union |
| STOKER | South Park |
| STONE | Whetzel, Greenlawn, South Park |
| STORCH | Friendship Park |
| STORM | Hilldale |
| STORMS | Samaria |
| STORY | Cunningham Hill |
| STOTT | Hilldale |
| STOTTS | Shiloh, Whetzel, Old Baptist, Mount Nebo, Sand Creek |
| STOUT | Shumaker, West White Lick, Centerton, Highland, Mount Pleasant/Hall, Poplar Grove, Stout (Gregg Twp), Mount Gilead, Old Mount Olive, Shultz, North Branch, West Union, Friendship Park, Cramer, Greenlawn, Sand Creek |
| STRADER | New Salem Baptist, Centerton, Mount Gilead Chapel, New Butterfield, Mahalasville, Greenlawn |
| STRAWDER | Williams(Washington Twp) |
| STRATTAN | West White Lick |
| STRAUB | Friendship Park |
| SPREEVAL | Easthill |
| STRETSBURY | Old Baptist |
| STRICKLER | Centennial |
| STRINGER | West Union |
| STRODE | Easthill |
| STROH | Mount Nebo |
| STUART | West Union, Sand Creek |
| STUDER | Mahalasville |
| STULTZ | Mount Tabor |
| STUM | Mount Pleasant/Hall |
| STUMP | Hilldale |
| STURGEON | Samaria |
| STWART | Mount Pleasant/Hall |
| SUDDUTH | Hilldale |
| SULLIVAN | Liberty |
| SUMMERS | Mount Tabor, Patrick/Whitaker, Shumaker, Walters, Baldwin/Patrick, Mannan, Greenlawn, Hilldale, Sand Creek |
| SUMNER | West White Lick, Old Baptist, West Union |
| SUNDERLAND | Centerton |
| SURBER | Walters |
| SUTER | Union Christian, Friendship Park |
| SUTHERLEN | Greenlawn |
| SUTHERLIN | Mannan |
| SUTHERLON | Mannan |
| SUTPHIN | Morgan Family |
| SUTTON | Mount Nebo |
| SWAIN | Old Baptist |
| SWEATT | Centennial |
| SWEET | Cunningham Hill, Greenlawn, Nutter |
| SWEETSER | Mitchell |
| SWIFT | Easthill |
| SWISHER | Centerton, Highland |
| SWOPE | Brooklyn |
| SYKES | Olive Christian, West Union |
| SYMTH | Shultz |
