| 1840 | Mr. D. Rockwell & family | Removed |
| Major Simms & family | Major withdrew | |
| Mr. Charles Ogle & family | Mr. Ogle deceased, family removed to Indiana | |
| Mr. E. T. Miller & family | ||
| Mrs. C. Heslep & family | Removed | |
| Dr. B. Gillett & family | ||
| Mr. Inc. Galbraith & family | Absented | |
| Mr. I. Gledhill & family | Mr. Gledhill deceased, and family removed from town | |
| Dr. Samuel Prosser & family | Dr. Prosser withdrawn | |
| Mr. I.M. Lucas & family | Removed 1849 to Washington City | |
| Mr. H. B. McClure, Esq. & family | Removed | |
| Mr. I. T. Sigler & family | Mr. Sigler left the parish | |
| Mr. G. A. Dunlap & family | Withdrawn | |
| Mr. Samuel R. Smith & family | Removed to Galena | |
| Mrs. M. McConnell & family | ||
| Mr. B. B. Chamberlain & family | Removed to St. Louis | |
| Mr. Adolphus Cherrill & family | Removed to Augusta, IL | |
| Mr. Inc. E. Tolpree & family | Removed to State of New York | |
| Mr. Jona. Tucker & family | Mr. Tucker deceased, merged in I.L. Morrison's | |
| Dr. Augustus M. Heslep & family | Removed to St. Louis | |
| Mr. E.M.M. Clarke & family | Removed to Rushville, IL | |
| Mr. A. Brother & family | Removed to St. Louis | |
| Mr. Edward Lambert & family | Absented | |
| Mr. Craven & family | Absented | |
| 1842 | Dr. C. B. Zabriskie & family | Removed to New York 1848 |
| Mr. Wm. Braidwood & family | Died and removed | |
| Mr. Joseph Heslep & family | Removed | |
| Mr. Samuel W. Lucas | Removed to Peoria 1846 | |
| Mr. David Robb & family | ||
| 1848 | Mrs. Sarah E. Hardin & family | Removed |
| Mr. Henry Stryker & family | ||
| Mr. Samuel Markoe & family | Removed | |
| Mrs. Sprowetts family | Absented | |
| Mr. Dresser & family | Removed to Naples | |
| Mr. Newell & family | Go to Springfield | |
| Mr. Inc. Iabina & Family | Revmoed to Waverly 1848 | |
| Mr. Samuel Bacon & family | Went to St. Louis | |
| Mr. James Berdan & wife | ||
| Mr. H. T. Collins & wife | Removed | |
| Mr. Thos. A. Colt | Returned to New York | |
| 1849 | Mr. A. Rockwell & family | Mistake |
| Mr. John Lindsey & family | ||
| Mr. Hannant & family | Absented, returned, removed | |
| Miss Eliza Conn | Removed | |
| Sept 1850 | Mathew Blackburn, wife & daughters & sons | Removed in the country |
| Mrs. Swearengen & family | Removed | |
| Mrs. Marill McDougal (Miss McConnell) | To California | |
| Mr. Stewart | Absented | |
| Mr. & Mrs. Willis | Removed | |
| 1851 | Mr. John Bashfortts & wife | Removed |
| Mr. Joseph Sheppard & family | Removed | |
| Miss Egbert | ||
| Miss Vanderhoeff (Mrs. Wash. Hook) | ||
| Mr. James Simpson - Sept. 1852 | Removed | |
| Mr. J. W. Hook & family | ||
| Mr. John Booth & wife | Aug. 1852 - Moved to Pittsfield, IL | |
| Mrs. Warren & family | ||
| Mr. Wm. K. Ducy & family | ||
| Mr. Warfield & family | Removed | |
| Jun 1, 1853 | Mr. McEvers & family | Withdrawn |
| Mr. Robert Roe & famil | Removed | |
| Mrs. Tunney & family | Removed | |
| Mr. Edward Lax & wife & family | Wife deceased | |
| Mr. Daniel Robb | Removed | |
| Dr. Rhodes & family | ||
| Mr. Charles Smith & family | Removed | |
| Mr. Higgins & family | ||
| Mrs. Dr. Cassell & family | ||
| Mr. Epler, wife & family | ||
| Mr. Jas. English & wife | Removed | |
| Mr. Wilson & wife | Removed | |
| 1855 | Mr. Cane & family | Removed |
| Dr. Wakely & family | ||
| Dr. Long & family | Removed | |
| Mrs. Lightfoot & family | Withdrawn | |
| Mr. Clement | Removed | |
| Mr. Hubbel | Removed | |
| 1856 | Mr. H. Talmage Collins & family | |
| Mr. Clarke & wife | Removed | |
| Mr. Mapes & family | ||
| Mr. J. L. McConnel (died) | Family merged in Murray McConnel's | |
| 1857 | Mr. Peck & family | |
| Mr. Marsh & family | Removed | |
| Mr. John Flack & family | ||
| Mrs. Sherwood & family | Removed | |
| Mrs. Philpot & family | Removed | |
| Mr. George M. McConnel & family | ||
| 1860 | Mr. Edmund Fox & family | Removed |
| Mr. Neuruch & family | Removed | |
| Mr. G. W. Richard & family | Removed | |
| Mrs. Elisha Brown & family (1 daughter here) | Removed | |
| Mr. Charles Birnham & family | Removed | |
| Mr. Lynn & wife | Ceased to attend | |
| Mrs. Roberts | ||
| Mrs. Hargrave & family | Removed | |
| 1861 | Mr. Rudolph | Removed |
| Mr. Baher & wife | Removed | |
| Charles Gillett & family | Removed | |
| 1862-1863 | Peter Tilton & family | |
| William Masby & family | Removed | |
| Mr. Strong & family | Removed | |
| 1864-1865 | Mr. Parker & family | |
| Mr. Palmer & family | ||
| Mr. Essminger & family | ||
| Mr. Caldwell & family | ||
| Mrs. Gore | Removed | |
| Mr. Wilson & wife | Removed | |
| Col. Morton & family | Removed | |
| Mrs. Bennett | Removed | |
| Mr. Phillips & family | ||
| Mr. Warfield, wife & family | Removed | |
| Mr. C. Miller & family | ||
| 1853 ? | Mr. I. L. Morrison & family | |
| Mrs. Matingly | Dead | |
| Mrs. Mary McCracken | Removed | |
| 1865-1866 | Mrs. Tomlin & family | |
| Mrs. Kelley | ||
| Mr. William B. Mosbey & family | ||
| Mr. Waller & family | ||
| Mr. Wm. Brown & family | ||
| Joseph Grassey & family | ||
| Henry Stryker, Jr. & family | ||
| William Rockwell & family | ||
| Moreen & family | ||
| 1865-1866 | Dr. Wakely & family | |
| Mrs. Webster | ||
| Mrs. Henry | ||
| Mrs. Donaldson & family | ||
| Dr. Milligan & family | ||
| Mrs. McElhinney & family | ||
| Mrs. Wm. H. Corcoran & family | ||
| Mrs. Stella Poe | ||
| Mrs. Matthew Blackburn | ||
| Mrs. Daniel Howe | ||
| Mrs. Harwood | ||
| No regular list of Communicants was kept until | ||
| Aug. 16, 1840; the following names & dates are, | ||
| however, to be found in the records made by | ||
| Mr. Batchelder, viz: | ||
| Aug. 1834 | The number of communicants has never | |
| exceeded five; that is the present number. | ||
| During the first year of the present Rector's | ||
| labours, the sacrament was administered but | ||
| once: July 3, 1836. Miss Margaretta & Miss | ||
| Della Saunders, together with Miss Mary Mauro | ||
| were admitted to the communion. | ||
| Feb. 4, 1838 | Mr. Henry Robb was received to the communion |