The original land transfer for this isolated rural cemetery located between Meredosia
and Arenzville is found on page 521 in Deed Book KK, in the Morgan County Courthouse. Dated 1 March 1856,
the document shows that Benjamin Newman, Jaral Wilday and his wife Catharine Wilday, sold to Simon P.
Newman, Lorenzo D. Graham, James A. Post, Charles Wilday, David Giger, John F. Skinner and
William Burrus, for $1.00, 2 1/2 acres of land located in Section 3. Those receiving the land
had been appointed a body of trustees for the purchase of "George Newman Burying Ground." As
found on page 136 of Deed Book 40 in the Morgan County Clerk's office, more land was added to the
cemetery on April 4, 1891. On that date, Alexander Wilday & Tabitha, his wife, sold to
Thomas Naylor, Starrett Coy and John D. McLain, as trustees of the Newman Cemetery, for $1.00, a part of the
northwest quarter of the southeast quarter of Section 3 in Township 16N, Range 12W. The said land
is conveyed in trust for the sole purpose of a burial ground, and no other.
When visiting the cemetery on September 6, 1976, Robert W. Dalton and his youngest daughter, Brenda Lee
Dalton, found the cemtery to be a difficult place to find. Entrance was made by driving
about 100 yards along a trail covered with weeds as tall as the car, and then driving along a very
winding and dusty dirt road for perhaps 1/4 mile, then driving across a pasture to the cemetery fence.
A previous attempt to find the cemetery had failed. The cemetery was practically free of
brush but apparently had not been mowed that growing season. The compilers felt that they probably
missed some tombstones because of the tall and dense vegetataion. Several tombstones were so badly weathered
that they could not be read.
Name | Born | Died | Age | Additional Inscription/Info. |
BENNETT, Betsy C. | 12 Oct 1835 | 4 Feb 1908 | ||
BENNETT, James | Co. I, 11th Missouri Inf. | |||
BLANDFORD, Ann | 3 Nov 1844 | 1y9m15d | Dau of L. & E. Blandford | |
BOLES, Josephine | 1853 | 1917 | Wife of Wm. Boles | |
BOLES, Lione | 1897 | 1918 | ||
BOLES, William | 1848 | |||
BURRUS, Elizabeth E. | 27 Feb 1886 | 40y21d | Wife of John Burrus | |
BURRUS, Leonard | 26 Aug 1853 | 25y3m1d | ||
BURRUS, Lovina | 25 Aug 1860 | 3y5m3d | Dau of G. & M. Burrus | |
BURRUS, Lovina | 24 Nov 1876 | 45y10m5d | Wife of Matthew Burrus | |
BURRUS, M. Agolda | 8 Feb 1898 | 18 Oct 1900 | Dau of Alex & Mary L. Burrus | |
BURRUS, Martha C. | 14 Mar 1883 | 24y6m3d | Wife of John Burrus | |
BURRUS, Martha M. | 13 Aug 1859 | 18y21d | Wife of G.W. Burrus | |
BURRUS, Mary Alex | 5 Jan 1912 | 47y | (No stone found); Dau Frederick & Mary Cockran | |
BURRUS, Nancy Rebecca | 17 Sep 1854 | 19y1m | Wife of G.W. Burrus | |
BURRUS, Susan Catharine | 15 Oct 1868 | Dau of Matthew & Lovina Burrus | ||
BURRUS, William D. | 2 Oct 1859 | 1m20d | Son of G.W. & M.M. Burrus | |
BUTCHER, Sarah | 9 Aug 1862 | 6y10m | ||
CIRE, Nancy | 8 Feb 1879 | 57y | Marr. (1) Masterson (2) J. L. Cire | |
CLARK, Chriscilda | 28 Feb 1841 | 17y3m28d | ||
CORCORAN, P. H. | 13 Sep 1900 | 67y28d | ||
COY, Addie E. | 11 Jan 1898 | 28 Dec 1898 | Dau of U.S. G. Coy & Sarah Elizabeth (Kuhlman) Coy | |
COY, Mary E. (Lamb) | 14 Oct 1897 | 53y | Wife of S.P. Coy | |
COY, Starret Preston | 23 Oct 1838 | 25 Mar 1922 | Co. I, 115th Ill. Inf. | |
COY, Ulysses Simpson | 8 Feb 1865 | 1 Dec 1910 | ||
DANIELS, Pearl N. | 26 Aug 1902 | 11y22d | (From death cert. - no stone found) | |
DRINKWATER, Addie Marie | 24 Mar 1862 | 4y8m21d | Dau of Rev. Jacob & Catherine Drinkwater | |
DRINKWATER, Catherine | 14 May 1859 | 26y | Wife of Rev. Jacob Drinkwater | |
DRINKWATER, Charles | 20 Feb 1866 | 30y1m22d | ||
DRINKWATER, Isaac | 17 Feb 1817 | 12 Mar 1873 | ||
DRINKWATER, Jacob, Rev. | 13 Aug 1820 | 10 Aug 1905 | 84y11m21d | |
DRINKWATER, Rebecca | 12 Jan 1847 | 18y3m16d | ||
DRINKWATER, Sarah | 17 Jun 1845 | 50y | ||
DUNN, Mahala J. | Wife of (Broken off) | |||
EMORY, Clark/Carl | Oct 1883 | No stone - coroner's jury said kicked to death by mule | ||
ERVIN, Ange (Illegible) | ||||
FRY, Charles | 29 Oct 18?? | 60y11m9d | ||
FRY, Matilda | (Illegible - stone matches Charles Fry's) | |||
GABLE, Joseph | 28 Feb 1884 | 28y | (No stone - death cert. - died of exposure & drunk) | |
GIDEON, E. S. | 11 Oct 1863 | 1 Jan 1889 | 25y2m20d | |
GIGER, Charles Wesley | 1872 | 1956 | ||
GIGER, David | 31 Jul 1817 | 24 Sep 1891 | ||
GIGER, Elizabeth Houdyshell | 25 Aug 1815 | 6 Nov 1873 | Wife of David Giger | |
GIGER, Tillie McLain | 1874 | 1933 | ||
GIGER, William H. | 9 Jan 1845 | 18 Dec 1895 | Co. I, 115th Ill. Inf. | |
GIGER, Willie | 12 May 1873 | 12m7d | Son of W.H. & S.E. Giger | |
GILLILAND, Emma | 20 Oct 1907 | 46y | (No stone - fm death cert.) | |
GILLILAND, John E. | 2 Dec 1853 | 17 Jul 1923 | (No stone - fm death cert.); Son John & Rebecca G. | |
HAYES, Lizzie | 17 Dec 1882 | 41y | (No stone found - fm death cert) | |
HENDERSON, William | 22 Sep 1856 | 23 Jan 1913 | ||
HESS, Melvina | 10 Apr 1882 | 37y11m | (No stone found - fm death cert) | |
HOGAN, William | 2 Dec 1902 | 32y4m6d | (No stone found - fm death cert.) | |
JAMES, Adam | 5 Jul 1854 | 8m11d | Son of John & Fannie James | |
JAMES, Charles | 23 Feb 1865 | 11y27d | Son of John & Fannie James | |
JAMES, John | 31 Dec 1857 | 67y6m21d | ||
JAMES, Mary | 21 Sep 1861 | 2y25d | Dau of John & Fannie James | |
JAMES, Nancy | 1 Jul 1861 | 71y9d | Wife of John James | |
JAMES, Tenna | 16 Sep 1862 | 52y9m21d | ||
JOHNSON, George H. | Nov 1880 | (coroner's jury -hanged himself) | ||
MATHEW, Elizabeth | 25 Dec 1859 | 20y6m25d | Dau of J. & A.M. Mathew | |
MATTHEWS, Annie | 16 Nov 1863 | 76y3m25d | Wife of L. Matthews | |
MATTHEWS, Elizabeth Jane | 3 Sep 1847 | 26y?7m | ||
MAYES, Catherine | 1839 | 1927 | Wife of James H. Mayes | |
MAYES, James G. T. | 16 Apr 1869 | 1y1m | ||
MAYES, James H. | 1828 | 1918 | ||
MAYES, James R. | 15 Sep 1860 | 1y4m25d | Son of J. & M. Mayes | |
MAYES, Mary L. | 7 Aug 1855 | 9m27d | Dau of R. & S. Mayes | |
MAYES, Susannah | 11 Jul 1861 | 31y10m26d | Wife of Robert Mayes | |
MCALLISTER, Mattie E. | 1861 | 1931 | ||
MCLAIN, Infant | 8 Apr 1882 | Child of J.D. & M.A.McLain | ||
MCLAIN, Maudie | 18 Oct 1881 | 1y11m5d | Dau of J.D. & M.A. McLain | |
MCLAIN, Ruth | 1899 | 1900 | Dau of C.W. & T.E. McLain | |
MCLAIN, Wilmer E. | 15 Jul 1888 | 5y3m19d | Son of J.D. & M.A. Mclain | |
MILLER, Glena | 19 May 1898 | 10 Apr 1899 | Dau of J.A. & M. Miller | |
MILLER, James Allen - (Obit) | 1862 | 1929 | ||
MILLER, Martha Ellen | 1864 | 1956 | Wife of James Allen Miller | |
MILLER, Randol C. | 27 Feb 1852 | 33y11m | ||
MUSH, Emma | 21 Jan 1883 | 14y6m | ||
NAYLOR, Mary C. | 7 Aug 1865 | 5y8m4d | Dau of P.H. & E. Naylor | |
NAYLOR, Mary R. | 11 Nov 1873 | 18 May 1899 | 25y5m9d | (Born Lancashire, Eng.) |
NAYLOR, Mother | ||||
NAYLOR, Philip H. | 27 Jun 1890 | 73y1m15d | (Born Rutland, Eng. - came to Morgan Co. 1852) | |
NAYLOR, Sarah E. | 18 Oct 1906 | 81y9m5d | ||
NAYLOR, Thomas | 15 Sep 1849 | 18 Sep 1902 | Father | |
NAYLOR, William Henry | 8 Apr 1880 | 36y3m7d | (Born Rutland, Eng.) | |
PANKEY, William, Lieut. | Ill. Mtd. Vol., Black Hawk War | |||
POST, Mary E. | 28 Mar 1873 | 26y2m15d | Wife of John M. Post | |
POST, Nancy R. | 11 May 1849 | 25y11m29d | Wife of J.A. Post | |
POST, Phebe | 30 Sep 1853 | 49y11m7d | Wife of Wm. Post | |
POST, Stephen | 12 Oct 1851 | 33y6m16d | ||
REILY, J. W. | 25 Aug 1885 | 50y | (No stone - death cert says he was a peddler) | |
RHEA, Ellen | 3 Feb 1817 | 1 Dec 1875 | Wife of Samuel Rhea | |
RHEA, Howard | 14 Feb 1874 | 6 Jun 1874 | Son of Wm. & L.J. Rhea | |
RHEA, Linda | 1852 | 1874 | Wife of Wm. Rhea | |
RHEA, Margaret Jane | 6 Aug 1862 | 3y5m | Dau of Robert & Mary Rhea | |
RHEA, Mary | 20 Jun 1882 | 14 Nov 1882 | Dau of Wm. & M.J. Rhea | |
RHEA, S. Esteline | 1850 | 1878 | Wife of Wm. Rhea | |
RHEA, Samuel | 18 Apr 1820 | 3 Feb 1880 | 59y9m16d | |
RUMMEL, Infant | 17 Apr 1871 | Son of G. & M. Rummel | ||
RUMMEL, Mary E. | 3 Oct 1865 | 7m11d | Dau of G. & M. Rummel | |
RUMMEL, Peter | 10 Oct? 1879 | 12y7m18d | Son of G. & M. Rummel | |
SCOTT, Bennie | 22 Jan 1883 | 1m5d | (No stone found - fm death cert) | |
SLEETER, David H. | 12 Jun 1875 | 8m21d | Son of Wm. & W. Sleeter | |
SLEETER, Josephine H. | 7 Sep 1874 | Dau of Wm. & M.M. Sleeter | ||
SLEETER, Lillie May | 13 Aug 1875 | 6 Nov 1917 | ||
SLEETER, William | 1848 | 19 Feb 1880 | ||
SLEETER, William | 19 Feb 1884 | |||
SKINNER, Harriett | 31 Dec 1862 | Wife of Hazen Skinner | ||
SKINNER, Hazen | 3 Nov 1866 | 32y6m | ||
STRICKLIN, Caroline Henson | 24 Dec 1839 | 23 Jun 1920 | Wife of W.R. Stricklin (Born OH, Died OK) | |
STRICKLIN, Ophelia | 24 Feb 1880 | 18y2m22d | Wife of W.J. Stricklin | |
STRICKLIN, Ophelia | 18 Jul 1880 | 5m25d | Dau of W.J. & O. Stricklin | |
STRICKLIN, William R. | 1 Jan 1829 | 31 Mar 1870 | ||
SUMPTER, Eva May Coy | 15 Aug 1885 | 12 Nov 1918 | (No stone - fm death cert) | |
SUMPTER, Margaret | ca 1908 | ca 1913 | ||
THOMPSON, Surrwin ? | 10 Oct 1908 | 78y8m15d | (No stone found - fm death cert.) | |
TRUITT, Archel | 20 Aug 1893 | Son of W.S. & R.J. Truitt | ||
TRUITT, Clinton | 22 Jun 1890 | 7m17d | Son of W.S. & R.J. Truitt | |
WAGNER, Aaron Smith | 22 Mar 1825 | 6 Feb 1904 | ||
WAGNER, Mary | 17 Nov 1889 | 58y4m7d | Wife of A.S. Wagner | |
WILDAY, Alexander | 11 Jul 1825 | 28 May 1914 | (Son of Ale & Elendor Wilday) | |
WILDAY, Arthusa J. | 15 Nov 1848 | 16 Oct 1909 | ||
WILDAY, Benjamin | 12 Jan 1815 | 25 Feb 1894 | ||
WILDAY, C. A. | 1841 | 1913 | ||
WILDAY, Charles | 11 Jul 1825 | 27 Jul 1901 | ||
WILDAY, Diana | 1818 | 1904 | Mother | |
WILDAY, Eleanor | 3/5 Nov 1866 | 83y4m11d | Wife of Thomas Wilday | |
WILDAY, Elizabeth | 26 May 1841 | 30 Aug 1908 | ||
WILDAY, Infant | 3 Feb 1851 | Son of A. & T. Wilday | ||
WILDAY, Jerial E. | 25 May 1859 | 25 Aug 1861 | ||
WILDAY, John | 31 Jan 1855 | 41y11m27d | ||
WILDAY, Katharine | 13 Oct 1824 | 29 Jun 1897 | Wife of Charles Wilday | |
WILDAY, Luella M. | 2 Dec 1865 | 20 Mar 1890 | Wife of Wm. Wilday | |
WILDAY, Sarah | 10 Apr 1820 | 16 Dec 1861 | Wife of Benjamin Wilday | |
WILDAY, Sedonia | 1849 | 1922 | ||
WILDAY, Thomas J. | 22 Jan 1884 | 30y8m5d | (No stone - fm death cert) | |
WILDAY, Tilitha Drinkwater | 28 Feb 1827 | 23 Apr 1912 | Wife of Alexander Wilday | |
The following paragraph is copied from an undated and unsigned history of Grace Chapel Methodist Church: "We have on record an account of a Rev. William Drinkwater, a Methodist minister who served the churches in this vicinity, devoting his life to preaching the gospel and doing good. His examples and good life were long remembers by older settlers. He had for his residence a hole in the ground on the bank of the Indian Creek about a mile and a half above the old Babb and Horns mill which I am told by the older settlers that the mill was located on the farm now owned by Mr. Fritz Hammer, formerly known as the Ogle farm. Remnants of the old mill were still in existence. This farm is close to Grace Chapel and not far from the old camp meeting ground which served the entire community in an early day.