The New York Times wrote April 7, 1998: "Today's digitally processed words and images may not be nearly as stable or long-lived [as paper]... From 1976 through 1979, the National Archives worked on recovering certain 1960 census data from tapes designed to run on long-obsolete machines. By the mid-1980's, computerized land-use maps of New York State produced in the 1960's became unavailable; the State Archives found that the software required to analyze the data had not been stored with it and that the hardware and operating system no longer existed... Donald Waters, director of the Digital Library Federation, a consortium of large research libraries and archives, said the issue was not merely a matter of technology. 'It's also legal, organizational and financial,' Waters said. "That is why Bill Gates's privately held image-bank company, Corbis, 'refreshes' its data tapes by copying them every few years onto more advanced ones that typically hold more data in the same space and last longer. Still... of the company's 1.3 million digital images, 50 had been lost because of media failures. The National Archives keeps two copies of its tapes and refreshes them every 10 years."