Brantley County is located within the Waycross Judicial Circuit (Bacon, Brantley, Charlton, Coffee, Pierce, Ware) and has had the following individuals to serve as Judges
| Term | Name | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 01 Jan 1915 - 30 Nov 1924 | James Isaiah Summerall | Died 30 Nov 1924 |
| 15 Dec 1924 - 01 Feb 1928 | Harry Day Reed | Resigned 01 Feb 1928 |
| 01 Feb 1928 - 1929 | James Dorsey Blalock | |
| 01 Jan 1929 - 1942 | Marcus David Dickerson | |
| 01 Jan 1943 - 1955 | Walter Thomas | Died 25 Oct 1955 |
| 03 Nov 1955 - 1962 | Cecil M. Roddenberry | Died 29 Jan 1962 |
| David M. Parker | ||
| John W. Bennett, Jr. | ||
| John R. Walker | ||
| Dewey Hayes | ||
| 05 Feb 1962- 1982 | Ben A. Hodges | Died May 1983 |
| 01 May 1974- 1990 | Elie Lee Holton | 08 Aug 1999 |
| 01 Jul 1981 - 1998 | Clarence D. Blount | |
| 1989 - | Joseph Benjamin Newton | |
| 1997 - 2008 | Steve Jackson | |
| 1999 - | Joseph Benjamin Newton | |
| 2005 - 2012 | Michael P.Boggs | |
| 2003 - Present | Dwayne H. Gillis | |
| 2012 - Present | Jeffrey H. Kight | |
| 2009 - Present | Michael D. DeVane |