__ | __| | | | |__ | _Daniel FREEMAN _______| | (1830 - 1877) m 1853 | | | __ | | | | |__| | | | |__ | | |--Melvin Beachor FREEMAN | (1856 - 1952) | __ | | | __| | | | | | |__ | | |_Louisa (Eliza) SMITH _| (1832 - 1918) m 1853 | | __ | | |__| | |__
__ | __| | | | |__ | _Daniel FREEMAN _______| | (1830 - 1877) m 1853 | | | __ | | | | |__| | | | |__ | | |--Rachel Ann FREEMAN | (1865 - 1951) | __ | | | __| | | | | | |__ | | |_Louisa (Eliza) SMITH _| (1832 - 1918) m 1853 | | __ | | |__| | |__
still living - details excluded
_____________________ | ________________________| | | | |_____________________ | _Edward Henry FREEMAN _| | | | | _____________________ | | | | |________________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Shellie Beth FREEMAN | | _John Melvin MCCOY __+ | | (1873 - 1968) m 1897 | _Melvin Aldridge MCCOY _| | | | | | |_Elsie May WILSON ___ | | (1879 - 1937) m 1897 |_Judy May MCCOY _______| | | _____________________ | | |_Zelda Irene GREENE ____| (1910 - 1970) | |_____________________
still living - details excluded
_____________________ | ________________________| | | | |_____________________ | _Edward Henry FREEMAN _| | | | | _____________________ | | | | |________________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Stacy Lynn FREEMAN | | _John Melvin MCCOY __+ | | (1873 - 1968) m 1897 | _Melvin Aldridge MCCOY _| | | | | | |_Elsie May WILSON ___ | | (1879 - 1937) m 1897 |_Judy May MCCOY _______| | | _____________________ | | |_Zelda Irene GREENE ____| (1910 - 1970) | |_____________________
Social Security application gives full name, parentage. He was working for Illinois Bell Telephone Co. at that time (25 nov 1936), and living at 6239 Evans Ave., Apt. 1, in Chicago. Social Security number 319-05-2172.
In the 1940 census, he and his wife were enumerated at the Bay Shore Motel in Santa Monica, California.
There is a court decision, California Court of Appeals, Second District, Division Two, dated 09 feb 1953, in which it is revealed that Victor and Dorothy had a daughter Helen Louise:
[Civ. No. 19357. Second Dist., Div. Two. Feb. 9. 1953.]
Estate of DOROTHY S. FREEMAN, Deceased. BANK OF AMERICA, as Guardian, etc., Respondent, v. VICTOR L. FREEMAN, Appellant.
COUNSEL
Austin, Austin & Jones for Appellant.
McLaughlin & Casey for Respondent.
OPINION
McCOMB, J.
This is an appeal by Victor L. Freeman from a decree determining heirship pursuant to section 1080 of the Probate Code in connection with the estate of his deceased wife, Dorothy S. Freeman, wherein the court decreed that certain real property standing in the name of deceased was her sole and separate property. It was thereupon decreed that appellant was entitled to succeed to a one-half interest in such property, and that Helen Louise Freeman, the minor child of the appellant and deceased was entitled to succeed to the remaining one half.
[1] The sole question for our determination is:
Was there substantial evidence to sustain the probate court's finding that the real property in question was the separate property of decedent at the time of her death?
This question must be answered in the affirmative. The [115 Cal. App. 2d 828] evidence disclosed that on May 1, 1944, decedent received a deed to the property from one Henry W. Walker as grantor conveying it to her as her separate property. There was also evidence that the consideration for the property was paid with money which appellant had prior to his marriage to decedent and the earnings of appellant and decedent during their married life.
This rule is controlling, and governs the instant case:
Regardless of the source or character of the consideration, property deeded to a wife by an instrument in writing is presumed to be her separate property, and such presumption will support a finding that the property was the separate property of the wife even though there be evidence that the consideration paid for the conveyance was the separate property of the husband or the community property of the husband and wife. Such testimony merely creates a conflict in the evidence for determination of the trier of fact. (Estate of Durham, 108 Cal. App. 2d 148, 150 [1] et seq. [238 P.2d 1057].)
Affirmed.
Moore, P. J., and Fox, J., concurred.
_____________________ | _Daniel FREEMAN ___________| | (1830 - 1877) m 1853 | | |_____________________ | _William Henry FREEMAN ____| | (1861 - 1926) m 1899 | | | _____________________ | | | | |_Louisa (Eliza) SMITH _____| | (1832 - 1918) m 1853 | | |_____________________ | | |--Victor Lorenz FREEMAN | (1903 - 1971) | _Victor VICTOR ______+ | | (1798 - 1870) m 1829 | _Solomon VICTOR ___________| | | (1833 - 1900) m 1860 | | | |_Liena MEYER ________ | | (1800 - 1870) m 1829 |_Virginia Rosalind VICTOR _| (1863 - 1935) m 1899 | | _John DANSON ________+ | | (1793 - 1835) m 1818 |_Marion (Mary Ann) DANSON _| (1832 - 1916) m 1860 | |_Catherine POWER ____+ (1797 - 1834) m 1818
Where: 1880 - Dawson Co., NE; (1885 Nebraska State Census, his mother and some of his siblings still in Dawson Co.); 1900 - Gosper Co., NE; 1910 - Marinette, WI; 1920 - back in Gosper Co., NE, living alone. Was there an obituary? Can birth certificates be located for his children? Were there other children?
[4000] Same cemetery has Louisa (Smith) Freeman b. 23 dec 1832 d. 01 dec 1918, presumably William's mother.
__ | __| | | | |__ | _Daniel FREEMAN _______| | (1830 - 1877) m 1853 | | | __ | | | | |__| | | | |__ | | |--William Henry FREEMAN | (1861 - 1926) | __ | | | __| | | | | | |__ | | |_Louisa (Eliza) SMITH _| (1832 - 1918) m 1853 | | __ | | |__| | |__
_____________________ | _____________________| | | | |_____________________ | _William FRENCH _____| | (1603 - 1681) m 1669| | | _____________________ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Abigail FRENCH | (1673 - ....) | _John LOTHROP _______+ | | (.... - 1653) | _Thomas LOTHROP _____| | | (1621 - ....) m 1639| | | |_____________________ | | |_Mary LATHROP _______| (1640 - 1735) m 1669| | _William LARNED _____ | | |_Sarah LARNED _______| (1607 - ....) m 1639| |_____________________
still living - details excluded
1880 Census: appears with Perrin Swan family of Franklin, ME, as mother-in-law.
_____________________ | _____________________| | | | |_____________________ | _Arthur FRENCH ______| | (1804 - 1877) m 1825| | | _____________________ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Amelia FRENCH | (1840 - ....) | _John URAN __________+ | | (.... - 1798) m 1752 | _Thomas URAN ________| | | (.... - 1837) m 1795| | | |_Phebe DAVIS ________ | | m 1752 |_Amelia F. URAN _____| (1809 - 1891) m 1825| | _____________________ | | |_Nancy DAVIS ________| m 1795 | |_____________________
_____________________ | _____________________| | | | |_____________________ | _Arthur FRENCH ______| | (1804 - 1877) m 1825| | | _____________________ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Benjamin B. FRENCH | (1834 - ....) | _John URAN __________+ | | (.... - 1798) m 1752 | _Thomas URAN ________| | | (.... - 1837) m 1795| | | |_Phebe DAVIS ________ | | m 1752 |_Amelia F. URAN _____| (1809 - 1891) m 1825| | _____________________ | | |_Nancy DAVIS ________| m 1795 | |_____________________
1865 census notes she bore 4 children, all accounted for.
_____________________ | _____________________| | | | |_____________________ | _Arthur FRENCH ______| | (1804 - 1877) m 1825| | | _____________________ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Emeline FRENCH | (1832 - ....) | _John URAN __________+ | | (.... - 1798) m 1752 | _Thomas URAN ________| | | (.... - 1837) m 1795| | | |_Phebe DAVIS ________ | | m 1752 |_Amelia F. URAN _____| (1809 - 1891) m 1825| | _____________________ | | |_Nancy DAVIS ________| m 1795 | |_____________________
_____________________ | _____________________| | | | |_____________________ | _Arthur FRENCH ______| | (1804 - 1877) m 1825| | | _____________________ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Georgiana FRENCH | (1848 - ....) | _John URAN __________+ | | (.... - 1798) m 1752 | _Thomas URAN ________| | | (.... - 1837) m 1795| | | |_Phebe DAVIS ________ | | m 1752 |_Amelia F. URAN _____| (1809 - 1891) m 1825| | _____________________ | | |_Nancy DAVIS ________| m 1795 | |_____________________
_____________________ | _____________________| | | | |_____________________ | _William FRENCH _____| | (1603 - 1681) m 1669| | | _____________________ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Hannah FRENCH | (1676 - 1766) | _John LOTHROP _______+ | | (.... - 1653) | _Thomas LOTHROP _____| | | (1621 - ....) m 1639| | | |_____________________ | | |_Mary LATHROP _______| (1640 - 1735) m 1669| | _William LARNED _____ | | |_Sarah LARNED _______| (1607 - ....) m 1639| |_____________________
Listed as "John 2nd" in 1850 census, perhaps indicating there had been another son John who died in infancy?
_____________________ | _____________________| | | | |_____________________ | _Arthur FRENCH ______| | (1804 - 1877) m 1825| | | _____________________ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--John FRENCH | (1843 - ....) | _John URAN __________+ | | (.... - 1798) m 1752 | _Thomas URAN ________| | | (.... - 1837) m 1795| | | |_Phebe DAVIS ________ | | m 1752 |_Amelia F. URAN _____| (1809 - 1891) m 1825| | _____________________ | | |_Nancy DAVIS ________| m 1795 | |_____________________
_____________________ | _____________________| | | | |_____________________ | _Arthur FRENCH ______| | (1804 - 1877) m 1825| | | _____________________ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Lewis FRENCH | (1836 - ....) | _John URAN __________+ | | (.... - 1798) m 1752 | _Thomas URAN ________| | | (.... - 1837) m 1795| | | |_Phebe DAVIS ________ | | m 1752 |_Amelia F. URAN _____| (1809 - 1891) m 1825| | _____________________ | | |_Nancy DAVIS ________| m 1795 | |_____________________
_____________________ | _____________________| | | | |_____________________ | _William FRENCH _____| | (1603 - 1681) m 1669| | | _____________________ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Mary FRENCH | (1670 - ....) | _John LOTHROP _______+ | | (.... - 1653) | _Thomas LOTHROP _____| | | (1621 - ....) m 1639| | | |_____________________ | | |_Mary LATHROP _______| (1640 - 1735) m 1669| | _William LARNED _____ | | |_Sarah LARNED _______| (1607 - ....) m 1639| |_____________________
Isaac Mixers widow, Mary, was still living in 1735, "very aged."
Mary was the daughter of Thomas Lothrop, widow of William French of Billerica and previously widow of John Stearns of Billerica.
_____________________ | _____________________| | | | |_____________________ | _William FRENCH _____| | (1603 - 1681) m 1669| | | _____________________ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Sarah FRENCH | (1671 - ....) | _John LOTHROP _______+ | | (.... - 1653) | _Thomas LOTHROP _____| | | (1621 - ....) m 1639| | | |_____________________ | | |_Mary LATHROP _______| (1640 - 1735) m 1669| | _William LARNED _____ | | |_Sarah LARNED _______| (1607 - ....) m 1639| |_____________________
_____________________ | _____________________| | | | |_____________________ | _Arthur FRENCH ______| | (1804 - 1877) m 1825| | | _____________________ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Willard FRENCH | (1851 - ....) | _John URAN __________+ | | (.... - 1798) m 1752 | _Thomas URAN ________| | | (.... - 1837) m 1795| | | |_Phebe DAVIS ________ | | m 1752 |_Amelia F. URAN _____| (1809 - 1891) m 1825| | _____________________ | | |_Nancy DAVIS ________| m 1795 | |_____________________
Information based mainly on Boston Transcript query 30 jan 1907 #8904, consistent with Savage and other authorities. William French was one of the first settlers of Boston, arriving 1635 on the Defence with Harlakenden & Shephard. He removed to Billerica about 1653.
_____________________ | _____________________| | | | |_____________________ | _Arthur FRENCH ______| | (1804 - 1877) m 1825| | | _____________________ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--William N. (?) FRENCH | (1845 - ....) | _John URAN __________+ | | (.... - 1798) m 1752 | _Thomas URAN ________| | | (.... - 1837) m 1795| | | |_Phebe DAVIS ________ | | m 1752 |_Amelia F. URAN _____| (1809 - 1891) m 1825| | _____________________ | | |_Nancy DAVIS ________| m 1795 | |_____________________