We believe that this  is Elijah Stinson Masterson.  That will be my 2nd great-granduncle.  
We have a photocopy of a picture that looks very close. 
1.  Thomas Masterson
               2.  Eljah Stinson Masterson
       2.  Dr. B. O. Masterson
                 3.  Octavia Masterson
                    
  Kathy (Bradley) Alderete
   [email protected]

(Photo property of Charity Goodwin)