Founded in 1829, a wooden building was contructed on the site of the present
United Church. In
1933 the Presbyterian and Baptist congregations merged, and the United
Church of Fayetteville
was formed.
The Presbyterian records are now at the Presbyterian Church depository
in Philadelphia.
The baptismal, marriage and death records which follow were copied from
the microfilm by
Nancy Schiffhauer, 1998.
1830 Samuel Manning Supply - 10 mos.
Died 16 Apr 1843
1831 R. W. Condit Supply - 2 mos.
1831 E. H. Adams Supply - 1 year, 6 mos.
Died 1837 Cayuga, NY
1832 John Lord Supply - 8 mos.
Born Portsmouth, NH 1810
Died Stamford, Conn. 15 Dec 1894
1833 Ethan Smith Supply - 6 mos.
1834 S. S. Smith 2 yrs., 6 mos.
1837 6/28 - Sept 1841 Amos C. Tuttle Died 24 Sept 1862
1841 Oct Richard F. Cleveland Supply
1844 9/19 - 9/3/50 Richard F. Cleveland Died 1 Oct 1853 Holland Patent, NY
1850 12/4 - Oct 1861 Lewis H. Reid Died 8 July 1895
1862 6/26 - Apr 1867 William J. Erdman
1868 9/29 - 5/28/72 Dana M. Bigelow
1872 12/8 - Jan 1874 Edward Stratton Died 9 Aug 1903 Conn.
1874 9/29 - 8/31/80 Robert L. Bachman
1880 Dec - 10/1/82 John Clark Hill
1883 6/5 - 1/3/84 S. J. Rowland
1884 11/10 Cyrus P. Osborne Supply
1885 5/27 - 7/1/88 Cyrus P. Osborne
1899 5/25-4/12/1904 Percy B. Wightman
1905 10/1 - 6/13/09 Francis H. Laird
1910 3/28 - 12/30/17 Henry A. Porter
1917 12/30 - 4/5/21 Henry Clay Poland in cooperation with Baptist Church
1921 4/5 - 1927 C. Frederic Fraser " "
1927 - (1948) John T. Cowan in 1933 merged with the Baptist Church