The records for the Stillwater Lutheran Church are now kept at the Lutheran Church in Vandalia. Many of these records are in German. The cemetery inscriptions were transcribed by Lois Baker, Mrs. Andrew Mazak and Irene Forrer. The cemetery is in very poor condition.

Achlenker, David Carmellias-died 18 Jan 1844 8 y 8 m 18 d-son of Solomon & Susan

Achlenker, Elisabeth-died 5 Oct 1850 age 69 y 6 m 1 d-wife of George

Achlenker, George-died 2 Jan 1844 age 67 y 6 m

Achlenker, George Henry-died 20 Dec 1839 age 4 y 2 m 26 d-son of Solomon & Susan D

Achlenker, Mary Elizabeth-died 9 Sep 1839 3 y 4 m 27 d dau of Solomon & Susan

Alexander, G-died 19 Feb 1838 age 77

Balmer, Andrew-died 28 Apr 1874 age 72 y 7 m

Balmer, Emma-died 10 Sep 1866 age 13 y 8 m 11 d

Balmer, Infant-son of David & Leah-no date

Balmer, Jacob-5 May 1831-20 Feb 1881 son of Matthew & Mary Balmer

Balmer, Jacob-5 May 1831-20 Feb 1850 son of Andrew & Margaret Balmer

Balmer, John-10 Aug 1829-27 Feb 1850-son of Andrew & Margaret Balmer

Balmer, Margaret-died 10 Oct 1870 age 66 y 2 m wife of Andrew

Bassre, Benjamin-died 22 Apr 1863 age 85

Bassre, Sarah-died 13 Jun 1869 age 58

Boll, John G-died 16 Jun 1854 age 23 y 6 m 20 d son of Simon & Magdelena

Boschor, Maria-12 Oct 1783-5 May 1855

Coble, Anthony-died 8 Nov 1820 age 2

Coble, John-died 10 Aug 1835 age 23 y 10 m

Cress, Elizabeth-died 24 Aug 1841 age 79

Crowell, Elisabeth-died 3 Oct 1853 age 75

Crowell, Henry-died 22 Aug 1846

Crowell, M C-stone missing

Crowell, Mary-died 7 Sep 1853 age 51 y 2 m 12 d

Crowell, N N-stone missing

Crowell, S C-stone missing

Crowell, Sophia-died 3 Aug 1850 age 24 y 14 d

Dickensheets, Samuel A-died 22 Mar 1865 age 3 y 22 d son of Frederick & Sarah

Dooley, Henry-died 20 Oct 1829 age 23 y 8 m 18 d

Ehrhert, Susannah-26 Apr 1823-9 Jun 1855 dau of Jacob Ehrhert

Ehrhert, John-2 Apr 1830-31 Jan 1831 son of Jacob

Erhart, Jacob-18 Apr 1793-6 Aug 1837 husband of Elizabeth

Fissel, Henry-5 Jun 1768-3 Jun 1844

Frybarger, Anna M-died 25 Feb 1865 age 86 y 4 m wife of Jacob

Frybarger, Jacob-died 15 Feb 1842 age 66 y 6 m

Frybarger, Jacob-died 30 Sep 1848 age 30 6 m

Hale, Anna-28 Dec 1808-14 Jan 1862 wife of John

Hale, John-native of England-died 28 Oct 1841 age 43

Hardar, John-died Jun 1871 age 7 y 2 m 17 d

Keller, Jerome-died 16 Oct 1853 age 85

Keller, Lewis-died 11 Sep 1861 age 62 y 6 m 9 d

Keller, Lewis-died 25 Jan 1842 age 37

Kline, Catherine-died 6 Sep 1876 age 76 y 3 m 21 d wife of Mathias

Kline, Louisa-died 22 Apr 1844 age 24 y 7 m wife of Henry

Knopp, George-22 Feb 1851-1 Dec 1875

Kunkle, Infant-child of Henry & Elizabeth Kunkle no date

Mast, Austin-died 23 Apr 1840 age 3 m

Mast, Elizabeth-died 25 Mar 1822 age 13

Maus, Mary-died 7 Jan 1844 age 21 y 11 m 7 d wife of Elias dau of Richard & Mary Sandham

Michael, Anna Mary-native of York Co. Pa-died 10 Dec 1844 age 98 y 3 m

Newman, Naomi-died 5 Oct 1868 age 91 wife of William

Newman, William-died 13 May 1852 age 75 y 5 m

Nishwitz, Catherine A M-died 15 Mar 1854 age 36 y 6 m 19 d-wife of George

Nishwitz, Margaret Jane-died 4 Sep 1839 age 4 m 6 d-dau of George & Catherine

Palmer, David-died 22 Sep 1859 age 55 y 4 m 2 d

Pound, David M-died 8 Jan 1851 age 11 d son of P&D Pound

Pound, L K-stone missing

Pound, S O-stone missing

Pound, S O S-stone missing

Quillin, Absalom-died Jan 1820 age 17 y 9 m son of J&O Quillin

Ranka, John-died 1 Feb 1868 age 64

Ranka, Minnie-died 20 Mar 1871 age 36 wife of John

Roof, Sarah J-died 29 Sep 1842 age 2 y 22 d

Ryder, Michael-died 28 Mar 1871 age 31 y 1 m 4 d

Ryder, Sarah-died 3 Aug 1867 age 23 y 7 m wife of Michael

Sahee, Elisabeth-died 9 Nov 1865 age 62 y 11 m 18 d wife of Michael

Sahee, J W-stone missing

Sahee, L K-stone missing

Sandham, Mary-a native of England-died 3 May 1842 age 56 y 3 m wife of Richard

Sandham, Richard-a native of England-died 13 Feb 1857 age 72 y 6 m 26 d

Scheaffer, Infant-son of John & Susannah died 1846

Scheaffer, Jacob-death date missing age 41 y 11 m 7 d

Scheaffer, Sarah A-died 27 Dec 1849 age 5 m 1 d-dau of J&S Scheaffer

Shaefer, Frederick-died 31 Aug 1880 age 80 y 9 m 24 d

Shafer, A M-stone missing

Shafer, E M-stone missing

Shafer, John-17 Aug 1821-7 Sep 1842

Smith, A M M-stone missing

Smith, Elizabeth-died 10 Oct 1837 age 3 y 4 m 15 d dau of D&E Smith

Smith, Elizabeth-died 13 April 1859 age 38 y 5 m 20 d wife of David

Smith, Lovinan-died 4 Apr 1843 age 7

Warner, David-12 Mar 1796-7 Jun 1830

Warner, David-14 Dec 1828-24 Sep 1840 son of D&E Warner

Warner, Elisabeth-4 Mar 1798-9 Jul 1869 wife of David

Warner, Elizabeth-died 29 May 1835 age 4 y 11 m 6 d dau of G&S Warner

Warner, Joellen-died 5 Oct 1858 age 27 y 3 m 25 d wife of Amos

Warner, Margaret-died 3 May 1855 age 59 y 8 m wife of George

Waymire, Solomon-23 Feb 1791-18 Apr 1837

Weaver, Conrad-died Oct 1851 age 62

Weaver, Richard-16 May 1843-12 Nov 1844 son of Henry & Sarah Weaver

Weaver, Sarah-died 7 Jul 1846 age 1 y dau of Henry & Sarah Weaver

Weissenborn, A M-stone missing

Weissenborn, C W-stone missing

Weissenborn, Catharina Sophia-died 20 Apr 1851 age 21 y 1 mo wife of Christopher dau of F&S Schlotteludever

Weissenborn, M W-stone missing

Wise, Mary-died 10 Apr 1847 age 68 wife of Jacob