Schoharie County NYGenWeb Site
latitude 42� 37' 11" N; longitude 74� 15' 32" W
Google location map
Listings on this page are not necessarily complete and may not represent all of the stones in this cemetery. Please send additional submissions and corrections to Doug Boyer
Directions: State route 145 about 1 mile from village of Middleburgh (south). Left on Cotton Hill Rd. Approximately 4 miles on right.
Submitted by Steve & Anne LaMont
photos by Jeff Schadl, Richard A. Sherman, and Cathy Guilz Fisher (note: Camera icon (
) links to a picture of that person's gravestone.)
If anyone would like more information on these people, we may have it. I read the old Middleburgh News and copy any information about the people of Huntersland and have it in notebooks by family. Steve and I would be happy to help anyone out. Anne
Name | Birth | Death | Age | Spouse 1 | Child 1 | Child 2 | Child 3 | Father | Mother | Notes |
Alger, Chester | 12-1-1864 | 21y5m12d | d/Annapolis, MD | |||||||
Alger, Jared | 10-2-1792 | 2-5-1867 | Olmstead, Deborah | |||||||
Alger, Jesse H | 4-22-1818 | 12-12-1889 | Lawton, Mariah | |||||||
Babcock, Daniel | 12-23-1827 | 9-29-1903 | Williams, Elmina | |||||||
Babcock, Elmira | 10-17-1851 | 1y2m23d | Babcock, Walter | Zimmer, Elizabeth | ||||||
Babcock, Jekel (?) | 3-25-1860 | 25y6m9d | ||||||||
Babcock, John L | 9-8-1845 | Lawton, Mary M | Willie | Spouse 2 - Barber, Alma | ||||||
Babcock, Tryphena | 7-11-1839 | 4-11-1807 | Lamb, A.D. | |||||||
Babcock, Walter | 8-20-1803 | 3-19-1881 | Zimmer, Elizabeth | Elmira | ||||||
Babcock, Willie | 5-3-1872 | 4y6m28d | Babcock, John L | Lawton, Mary M | ||||||
Barber, Alma | 1-4-1855 | Babcock, Joh F | ||||||||
Barber, George | 3-22-1838 | 9-28-1908 | Weedman, Anna | Orlin | Manford | Rozella | ||||
Barber, Manford | 3-1-1888 | 9d4m | Barber, George | Weedman, Anna | ||||||
Barber, Orlin | 11-7-1890 | 4-11-1909 | Barber, George | Weedman, Anna | ||||||
Barber, Rozella | 4-3-1873 | 2y9m25d | Barber, George | Weedman, Anna | ||||||
Barrett, Wilia | 11-16-1892 | 5m | Barrett, William | Barrettt, Mattie | ||||||
Bartholomew, Polly | 9-12-1885 | 80y4m17d | Posson, Peter W | |||||||
Batsholts, George | 1796 |
First settlers in settlement; Erected by their grandson John Jacob Hilsley 1867 |
||||||||
Bellar, Mary W | 4-1-1877 | 23y5m | ||||||||
Bellar, Nancy Maria | 8-15-1844 | 1y5m | Bellar, William | Bellar, Sophia | ||||||
Bellar, Sophia | 11-14-1871 | Bellar, William | Nancy Maria | |||||||
Bellar, William | 4-4-1848 | 50y4m1d | Bellar, Sophia | Nancy Maria | ||||||
Bellar, Andrew | 8-7-1853 | |||||||||
Bergh, Dora | 9/14/1921 | 55y | ||||||||
Boomhower, Emily | 1828 | 1895 | Lawton, Peter | |||||||
Boomhower, Sophia | 11-14-1871 | Boomtower, John | ||||||||
Borst, Delina | 10-16-1873 | 20y7m7d | ||||||||
Borst, infant dau. | 3-28-1872 | 8d | Borst, John Jr. | Borst, Eliza | ||||||
Borst, infant son | 6-30-1869 | 14d | Borst, John Jr. | Borst, Eliza | ||||||
Borst, Nellie | 1831 | 1915 | Durfee, Wilbur | Edwin | ||||||
Borst, Seymour | 8-4-1877 | 15y11m24d | Borst, John Jr. | Borst, Eliza | ||||||
Cannady, Catharine | 11-8-1865 | 44y | Plank, William | Cannady, David | ||||||
Cannady, David | 12-12-1868 | 65y | Catharine | |||||||
Cass, Elma | 1-7-1858 | 2-20-1858 | Cass, Paul | Cass, Maranda | ||||||
Cass, Elmina | 6-13-1855 | 1-7-1860 | Cass, Paul | Cass, Maranda | ||||||
Cass, Maranda | 12-13-1830 | 3-7-1908 | 78y | Cass, Paul | Elmina | Elma | ||||
Cass, Paul | 11-2-1827 | 4-5-1911 | Cass, Maranda | Elmina | Elma | |||||
Cass, Wesley | 1870 | 1902 | ||||||||
Chaddon, Hannah | 2-28-1888 | 78y11m | Shufelt, Philip | Peter | ||||||
Clemon, Susanna | 1819 | 1890 | Dobbs, John | |||||||
Coddington, Anna | 3-8-1832 | Hilsley, John Jacob | ||||||||
Daring, Catharine | 3-10-1789 | 7-23-1858 | Daring, Frederick | |||||||
Daring, Frederick | 3-7-1784 | 2-7-1870 | Daring, Catharine | |||||||
Daring, John | 12-8-1814 | 1-16-1890 | Daring, Senamaria | Martha | ||||||
Daring, Martha | 10-5-1853 | 3m | Daring, John | Daring, Senamaria | ||||||
Daring, Senamaria | 4-19-1827 | 11-21-1890 | Daring, John | Martha | ||||||
Decker, Jennie | 1885 | 1936 | Harris, Gilbert | |||||||
Dobbs, Henrietta | 1846 | ? | Lawton, Peleg | |||||||
Dobbs, John | 1820 | 1895 | Clemon, Susannah | |||||||
Durfee, Edwin | 1853 | 1935 | Wood, Elizabeth | Floyd | Durfee, Wilbur | Borst, Nellie | ||||
Durfee, Floyd | 1891 | 1891 | Durfee, Edwin | Wood, Elizabeth | ||||||
Durfee, George | 1870 | Rose, Maggie | ||||||||
Durfee, Wilbur | 1822 | 1905 | Borst, Nellie | Edwin | ||||||
Gallup, Sarah | 8-18-1799 | 47y7m7d | ||||||||
Goodington, Anna | 3-8-1832 | Hilsley, John Jacob | ||||||||
Harp, Betsey | 4-11-1882 | 72y | Schell, Joannas | |||||||
Hauven, Cornelia E | 2-16-1824 | Weidman, Abraham J | Lodema E | John J | Almira | child - Eri | ||||
Henness, May | 10-28-1890 | 1y2m24d | Henness, William | Henness, June | ||||||
Hilcous, Jacob A | 4-10-1840 | 2/21/1903 | Weidman, Lousa | |||||||
Hill, Deanna | 1839 | 3/8/1866 | Posson, Lewis | Evaretta | Charles | |||||
Hilsley, David | infant | |||||||||
Hilsley, Hannah | 3-9-1865 | 72y | Hilsley, Jacob | |||||||
Hilsley, Henry | 3-21-1837 | 17y | ||||||||
Hilsley, Jacob | 2-16-1865 | 73y | Hilsley, Hannah | |||||||
Hilsley, John Jacob | 8-1-1817 | 8-13-1889 | Wright, Margaret | Levi | spouse 2 - Coddington, Anna | |||||
Hilsley, Joseph H | 4-22-1879 | 36y | ||||||||
Hilsley, Levi | 1-4-1866 | 18y9m17d | Hilsley, John J | Wright, Margaret | ||||||
Hilsley, Pater | infant | |||||||||
Hilsley, Rosannah | 9y | |||||||||
Hiltley, Catharine | 9-12-1887 | 76y | Hiltsley, George | |||||||
Hiltsley, George | 3-4-1889 | 76y | Hiltsley, Catharine | |||||||
Hoaltzel, Anna Marriah | 1796 | Hoaltzel, Johann |
First settlers in settlement; Erected by their grandson John Jacob Hilsley 1867 |
|||||||
Hoaltzel, Johann | 1796 | Hoaltzel, Anna Marriah |
First settlers in settlement; Erected by their grandson John Jacob Hilsley 1867 |
|||||||
Hulbut, Minton | ? | |||||||||
Lamb, A. D. | ? | ? | ||||||||
Lawton, Danforth | 1856 | 1882 | ||||||||
Lawton, Huldah | 1852 | 1864 | ||||||||
Lawton, John | 12-15-1815 | ? | ||||||||
Lawton, Levi | 1866 | 1908 | ||||||||
Lawton, Mariah | 4-8-1822 | 4/30/1908 | Alger, Jesse H | (obituary) | ||||||
Lawton, Mary M | 12-18-1840 | 12-13-1888 | Babcock, John F | Willie | ||||||
Lawton, Peleg | 1847 | ? | Dobbs. Henrietta | |||||||
Lawton, Peleg | 12-28-1879 | 93y | Shultis, Eva | |||||||
Lawton, Peter | 1826 | 1909 | Boomhower, Emily | |||||||
McKinley, Elizabeth | 1842 | 78y | Hilsley, Johannes | |||||||
Masholts, Jeremiah | 11-3-1890 | 50y | Co. G, 177 Regt. N.Y.V. | |||||||
Olmstead, Deborah | 10-25-1797 | 5-17-1851 | Alger, Jared | |||||||
Patrovits, Ruddy | 1908 | 1910 | ||||||||
Picket, Catharine | 8-6-1890 | 82y6m4d | ||||||||
Plank, Agness | 10-18-1865 | 15y10m24d | ||||||||
Posson, Asenith | 2-19-1814 | |||||||||
Posson, Carrie | 1873 | 1893 | Posson, Lewis | Weidman, Elizabeth | ||||||
Posson, Charles | 1865 | 2/6/1866 | 15m27d | Posson, Lewis | Hill, Deanna | |||||
Posson, Charles | infant | Posson, Henry | Posson, Rossanna | |||||||
Posson, Evaretta | 1861 | 5/6/1863 | 1y9m22d | Posson, Lewis | Hill, Deanna | |||||
Posson, Florence | 9-7-1884 | 3y21d | Posson, Charles | Posson, Margaret | ||||||
Posson, Henry | 10-11-1812 | 2-24-1891 | Posson, Rossannah | Mary | Charles | |||||
Posson, Lewis W | 1834 | 1821 | Hill, Deanna | Evaretta | Charles | Carrie | Spouse 2 - Weidman, Elizabeth | |||
Posson, Maggie | 2-4-1896 | 27y | Posson, Charles | Posson, Margaret | ||||||
Posson, Martha | 9-21-1896 | 18y | Posson, Charles | Posson, Margaret | ||||||
Posson, Mary | 7-30-1860 | 9y3m | Posson, Henry | Posson, Rossanna | ||||||
Posson, Peter W | 9-25-1884 | 85y11m24d | Bartholomew, Polly | |||||||
Posson, Rossannah | 3-7-1865 | 45y5m | Posson, Henry | Mary | Charles | |||||
Rasue, Catharine | 3-16-1819 | 12-8-1887 | Rasue, John | |||||||
Rasue, David | 9-12-1840 | 3-18-1890 | ||||||||
Rasue, George | 10-14-1873 | 22y7m7d | ||||||||
Rasue, John | 3-12-1818 | 9-12-1889 | Rasue, Catharine | |||||||
Rose, Maggie | 1875 | 1897 | Durfee, George | |||||||
Sarin, Dora | 9-26-1928 | 99y | ||||||||
Schell, Joannas | 6-29-1884 | 77y10m18d | Harp, Betsey | |||||||
Shufelt, Peter | 9-29-1862 | 21y4m8d | Shufelt, Philip | Chaddon, Hannah | ||||||
Shufelt, Philip | 7-6-1806 | 57y5m28d | Chaddon, Hannah | Peter | ||||||
Shultes, Eva | 4-22-1877 | 86y | Lawton, Peleg | |||||||
Simkins, Catharine | 2-24-1858 | 65y10m28d | Simkins, Nelson | Catharine | ||||||
Simkins, Catharine | 5-7-1844 | 19y3m16d | Simkins, Nelson | Simkins, Catharine | ||||||
Simkins, Nelson | 6-7-1878 | 87y7m19d | Simkins, Nelson | Catharine | son | |||||
Simkins, son | 5-27-1866 | 25d | Simkins, Nelson | |||||||
Simpkins, Jane | 10-15-1872 | 37y9m4d | Borst, John | |||||||
Stalker, William E | 2-26-1885 | 33y5m6d | Stalker, Susie | |||||||
Stevens, Eugene A | 12-24-1888 | 54y | ||||||||
Tompkins, James H | 1865 | 1925 | ||||||||
Tousan, Jacob | 10-25-1868 | 68y8m21d | Picket, Catharine | |||||||
Warner, Catharine | 2-7-1867 | 76y | Hawver, John | |||||||
Weedman, Anna | 1-1-1851 | Barber, George | Orlin | Manford | Rozella | |||||
Weidman, Abraham J | 8-3-1819 | 5-24-1894 | Hauven, Cornelia E | Lodema E | John J | Almira | child - Eri | |||
Weidman, Amanda | 2-22-1836 | 12/25/1904 | Weidman, Paul | Dora | ||||||
Weidman, Augusta | 9-11-1864 | 9-16-1879 | Weidman, Jacob | Weidman, Ann | ||||||
Weidman, David | b/d? 5-26-1856 | |||||||||
Weidman, Dora | 10-8-1866 | 3-17-1892 | Fox, Herrick | Weidman, Paul | Weidman, Amanda | |||||
Weidman, Elizabeth | 1842 | 1925 | Posson, Lewis | Carrie | ||||||
Weidman, Eunice | 4/25/1908 | 47y | Decker, Byron | |||||||
Weidman, Leusion | b/d? 10-3-1861 | |||||||||
Weidman, Lousa | 10-11-1847 | 7-18-1881 | Hilcous, Jacob A | |||||||
Weidman, Mary Ann | b/d? 7-19-1833 | |||||||||
Weidman, Paul | 8-16-1835 | Weidman, Amanda | Dora | |||||||
Whitcomb, Submit | 11-28-1848 | 46y10m2d | Boomhower, John | |||||||
Williams, Elmina | 7-5-1835 | 7-24-1886 | Babcock, Daniel | |||||||
Wood, Elizabeth | 1853 | 1895 | Durfee, Edwin | Floyd | ||||||
Wright, Abraham L | 10-20-1876 | 5m21d | ||||||||
Wright, Caroline | 4-28-1865 | 30y5m4d | Wright, Rich J | |||||||
Wright, Dr. Samuel J | 1-10-1847 | 37y3m21d | ||||||||
Wright, James | 10-15-1857 | 70y | ||||||||
Wright, Margaret | 8-5-1813 | 9-25-1870 | Hilsley, John Jacob | Levi | ||||||
Young, Alice | 1904 | 1919 | Young, Theodore M | Young, Mattie | ||||||
Young, Raymond | 1900 | 1901 | Young, Theodore M | Young, Mattie | ||||||
Zimmer, Elizabeth | 12-28-1808 | Babcock, Walter | Elmira |
Notes
June 2009, Richard Sherman
I have several photos of the Resue (Rasue) section of the Dutch Settlement
Cemetery if you want to post them.
Also according to everything I have been told my brother Everett Sherman was
buried in there.
He died hours after birth and his grave was between the two pine trees on the
end of the area. Fieldstone marker.
My mother pointed out the location but she was not at the burial as she was
extremely ill when he was born.
I never heard her say she ever went to the grave.
My Grandmother Laura (Resue) Treadlemire shared the same information with me.
March 2014 - Roney burials
I received the attached items from my aunt's children. She passed this Dec. (2013) and they found these papers among her other items. - Cathy Fisher
Names listed: Charles E Roney, Catherine (Daring) Roney, Eve E Roney, Peter A
Roney, Mary A Roney, Lambert S Roney, James H Roney, William C Roney,
Catherine M Roney, Charity M Roney, Bernard G Roney, Nancy (Weidman) Roney,
Michael Roney
hand-written sketch of burial locations
typed sketch of burial locations
April 2015 - Tompkins burials
I have attached pictures I took last summer of headstones I located in Dutch Settlement/Cotton Hill Cemetery. - Cathy Fisher
Margaret "Madge" Tompkins, Nov. 17, 1921 - June 19, 1993
Edgar F Tompkins, Apr 25, 1920 - Dec. 13, 1998
A Note to Researchers using this Web-site: As you use this site, please keep in mind the difference between primary and secondary sources and the importance of building a preponderance of evidence. Accept nothing without further checking. It is our hope that through this collection of data from many sources, you will find a piece of the puzzle that you are working on and that may lead you to further discoveries.
Links to external web sites are being provided as a convenience and for informational purposes only; they do not constitute an endorsement or approval of any of the products, services or opinions contained in any external web site.
Welcome Page of the Schoharie County NYGenWeb Site