The Hannibal Historical Society has an 1867 Topographical Atlas of Oswego County.  Included are maps of the Village of Hannibal and the hamlets of Hannibal Center and South Hannibal, all with residents names. 

A note of interest:"Hannibal Center" was orginally spelled "Hannibal Centre" and "South Hannibal" was originally called "Hulls Corners" after its first settler, Burr Hall.

1867 Map of Hannibal Center

1867 Map of South Hannibal

1867 Map Village of Hannibal

Lowell C. Newvine
  Hannibal Historical Society
  P.O. Box 325 
  Hannibal, NY 13074 
  (315) 564-5650 
  Or email at: [email protected]