| Rev. John Thomas | 1704-1724 |
| Rev. Robert Jenney | 1726-1742 |
| Rev. Samuel Seabury | 1742-1764 |
| Rev. Leonard Cutting | 1766-1783 |
| Rev. Thomas Lambert Moore | 1785-1799 |
| Rev. John Henry Hobart | 1799-1800 |
| Rev. Seth Hart | 1800-1829 |
| Rev. Richard Drason Hall | 1829-1834 |
| Rev. William M. Carmichael, D. D. | 1834-1843 |
| Rev. Orlando Harriman, Jr. | 1844-1849 |
| Rev. William H. Moore, D. D. | 1849-1892 |
| Rev. Creighton Spencer | 1892-1901 |
| Rev. Jere K. Cooke | 1901-1907 |
| Rev. Charles H. Snedeker | 1908-1924 |
| Rev. John S. Haight, B. D. | 1924- |
Notes:-"W" = Warden. "V" = Vestryman. *Now in office, Records previous to 1878 were copied from History of St. George's Church, by Rev. William H. Moore, D.D.
| Alburtis, Joseph | 1755-1767 |
| Allen, Leon | 1924-1927V |
| Baldwin, George | 1784-1787 |
| Baldwin, Isaac | 1763-1765 |
| Barroll, W. H. | 1835-1837 |
| Bedell, John | 1840-1863 |
| Belmont, August | 1901-1915W |
| Belmont, August | 1915-1917V |
| Berrian, William | 1860-1861 |
| Brown, John | 1749-1754 |
| Calkins, J. T. P. | 1917-1923V |
| Carlile, Thomas J. | 1917-1923V |
| Carlile, Thomas J. | 1924- *W |
| Carman, Bergen R. | 1885-1916V |
| Carman, Samuel | 1789-1817 |
| Carman, Stephen | 1820-1824 |
| Clark, Clarence | 1893-1894V |
| Cleaver, Thomas C. B. | 1921-1923V |
| Clowes, B. Valentine | 1882-1909V |
| Clowes, Ed. A. | 1825-1831 |
| Clowes, John | 1829-1838 |
| Clowes, Thomas | 1787-1824 |
| Clowes, Thomas H. | 1877-1891V |
| Clowes, Thomas H. | 1891-1905W |
| Clowes, Wm. J. | 1837-1839 |
| Conover, Orville G. | 1923-1924V |
| Cornell, John | 1736-1743 |
| Cornell, William | 1736-1741 |
| Cornwell, Henry E. | 1909-1915V |
| Cornwell, Henry E. | 1915-1918W |
| Dannat, W. H. | 1861-1866 |
| Denton, Augustus | 1882-1890V |
| Denton, Augustus | 1890-1900W |
| Denton, Charles | 1840-1863V |
| Denton, Charles | 1863-1878W |
| Denton, Eugene W. | 1909-1914V |
| Denton, Eugene W. | 1914- *W |
| Dickinson, Asa Don | 1919-1919V |
| Dorland, John | 1745-1749 |
| Earle, George W. | 1890-1909V |
| Gildersleeve, James | 1799-1834 |
| Gildersleeve, John | 1914-1919 |
| Gildersleeve, Jona'n | 1849-1863 |
| Hamlet, Dr. Francis P. | 1892-1893V |
| Hamlet, Dr. Francis P. | 1925- *V |
| Haugewout, Leffert (Lefferts) | 1746-1788 |
| Hentz, John H. | 1867-1882V |
| Hentz, John H. | 1882-1890W |
| Hewlett, Benjamin | 1788-1809 |
| Hewlett, Benj., Jr. | 1818-1825 |
| Hewlett, George | 1786-1818 |
| Hewlett, John J. | 1828-1835 |
| Hewlett, Richard | 1783-1786 |
| Hewlett, Richard Jr. | 1816-1834 |
| Hewlett, Samuel | 1849-1868 |
| Hewlett, Whitehead H. | 1854-1857 |
| Irwin, Louis H. | 1911-1917V |
| Jackson, Roland P. | 1923-1924 |
| Jones, David R. F. | 1825-1826 |
| Kilmer, Dr. Theron W. | 1927-1929V |
| Kissam, Daniel | 1788-1799 |
| Kissam, John | 1814-1819 |
| Kissam, Joseph | 1751-1761 |
| Langdon, Edwin K. | 1921-1922V |
| Langdon, George S. | 1916-1921V |
| Lott, Hermones | 1811-1816 |
| Ludlow, George D. | 1781-1781 |
| Marshall, John W., Jr. | 1924-1928V |
| Martin, Sam'l, M.D. | 1770-1791 |
| Marvin, Harry H. | 1836-1863 |
| Marvin, Robert | 1739-1774 |
| Miller, Henry P. | 1923- *V |
| Mitchell, William | 1809-1819 |
| Monroe, G. G. | 1863-1864 |
| Moore, John | 1797-1816 |
| Mulford, Charles W. | 1873-1877 |
| Neumeyer, William | 1930- *V |
| Norton, Carrol F. | 1900-1911V |
| Onderdonk, Andrew | 1789-1797 |
| Onderdonk, Henry M. | 1877-1885V |
| Peters, John | 1752-1779 |
| Pettit, Lewis | 1830-1857 |
| Pettit, Townsend B. | 1857-1880V |
| Pettit, Townsend B. | 1884-1886W |
| Pine, Daniel | 1750-1762 |
| Pine, Richard | 1823-1829 |
| Post, Birdsall | 1886-1921V |
| Pratt, Jonathan | 1768-1782 |
| Rhodes, William | 1837-1852 |
| Rockwell, James | 1764-1765 |
| Roebuck, Jarvis | 1782-1783 |
| Rushmore, Lewis | 1834-1860 |
| Schiele, W. E. | 1929-1930V |
| Seabury, Adam | 1877-1886V |
| Seabury, Adam | 1886-1891W |
| Seabury, Adam | 1905-1914W |
| Seabury, Frederick C. | 1919- *V |
| Seabury, Robert S. | 1863-1877 |
| Seabury, Robert S. | 1923-1924V |
| Seaman, Samuel L. | 1831-1857V |
| Seaman, Samuel L. | 1857-1884W |
| Searing, John | 1744-1745 |
| Smith, Jacob | 1736-1745 |
| Smith, James | 1763-1765 |
| Smith, John | 1747-1749 |
| Smith, Joseph | 1737-1747 |
| Smith, Micah | 1736-1746 |
| Snedeker, Abraham | 1816-1820 |
| Snedeker, Isaac | 1819-1822 |
| Thomas, Charles D. | 1922-1923V |
| Thomas, Charles D. | 1928- *V |
| Thorne, Richard | 1737-1763 |
| Thorne, Richard | 795-1814 |
| Tredwell, Benjamin | 1739-1744 |
| Tredwell, Benjamin | 1837-1848 |
| Turner, James | 1766-1780 |
| Valentine, Jacob | 1864-1877 |
| Valentine, Samuel | 1826-1849 |
| Vandervoort, R. Nelson | 1924-1925V |
| Van de Water, J. W. B. | 1891-1918V |
| Van de Water, J. W. B. | 1918-1923W |
| Vannostrand, Cornel | 1765-1785 |
| Vannostrand, George | 1834-1849 |
| Vannostrand, John | 1769-1770 |
| Van Nostrand, J. H. | 1893-1900V |
| Vannostrand, Martin | 1780-1789 |
| Walter, Henry | 1863-1873 |
| Watt, George | 1766-1784 |
| Webb, Edwin, M.D. | 1862-1878V |
| Webb, Edwin, M.D. | 1878-1882W |
| Weeks, George | 1786-1795 |
| Weeks, Thos. W. | 1825-1830 |
| Weller, A.N. | 1880-1882V |
| Wetmore, Samuel | 1785-1787 |
| Williams, Claude G. | 1920- *V |
| Willis, John H. | 1878-1892V |
| Willits, David B. | 1852-1854 |
| Wood, James | 1751-1789 |
| Wood, Samuel | 1817-1828 |
| Aubrey Abrams | Warren H. Hawkins |
| Norman Abrams | Sherwood L. Irwin |
| August Belmont | Allan D. Jennings (Rev.) |
| Raymond Belmont | Jeffrey Jennings (Rev.) |
| Dale Bassett | William S. Johnson |
| Dell Bassett | N. Forrest Jones |
| Glenn Bassett | Edwin K. Langdon |
| Dudley G. Bird | Albert L. Miller |
| Oliver W. Bird, Jr. | J. MacDonald Nichols |
| Leslie A. Briggs | Theophilus Parsons |
| Henry J. Campbell | W. Fred Pepper |
| T. James Campbell | Otis S. Powell |
| Avery F. Clowes | Wesley Powell |
| Gerardus Clowes* | Barron P. Reed |
| Meredith S. Clowes | Frank R. Sheridan |
| Arthur P. Collins | Walter H. Sammis |
| George Carman | Joseph Tuthill |
| Bennett H. Ertel | John Van de Water |
| Herman F. Evans | Farnk J. Wettstein |
| John R. Herrick | Harry W. Wettstein |
| Claude G. Williams |
*Died in Service
*Adventures for God; by John S. Haight