Article
Number Thirty Seven - History of the First Presbyterian Church Con't
Written by Joshua G. Borthwick and originally published
on April 5, 1884, in the Catskill "Examiner". Copy provided
by the Durham Center
Museum and retyped by Annette Campbell
The founders of the Church and Society appear to have acted upon the principle
that "whatever is worth doing at all, is worth doing well."
Accordingly they availed themselves of the laws of the State "in such
cases made and provided." They appointed Christopher Lord,
the senior deacon, and Daniel Brown, the clerk of the
society, to certify to the regularity of their proceedings, which they did as
follows:
"We Christopher Lord and Daniel Brown, appointed by the Society or
Congregation of the church at Durham, in the town of Freehold and county of
Albany, do hereby certify that agreeable to the law of this State, entitled
'An act to enable all religious denominations in this State to appoint
trustees, who shall be a body corporate, for the purpose of taking care of the
temporalities of their respective congregations, and for other purposes
therein mentioned,' which act was passed April 6, 1784, after due and regular
notice given, an election was held for the appointment of trustees of the said
Society, when by a plurality of votes Lemuel Hotchkiss, Daniel
Coe, David Cowles, Joseph Hart and Elihu Hart were
duly elected to serve as trustees for the said Society, and that we have
divided by lot the said trustees into three classes, to-wit: Lemuel
Hotchkiss and Elihu Hart, first class; David
Cowles and Daniel Coe, second class, and Joseph
Hart, third class."
Then follows the date, their signatures, seals, etc., all of which was
witnessed by William Cook, James Holcomb, Abner Mather, and
John Canfield. it was sworn to by John Canfield
before Henry Glen, one of the Judges of the Court of Common
Pleas for the county of Albany, and "registered in the Clerk's office of
the City and County of Albany in Book No. 1 of Church Patents, pages 55 and
56, this 22nd day of January, 1793. Signed, "B. Lusk,
Clerk." The correctness of the copy was attested by Daniel
Brown, Society Clerk.
This Daniel Brown was a prominent man in those days. He was a
brigadier-general in the war of 1812, and is referred to on pages 30, 269 and
270 in the "History of Greene County" just published. The late
Robert Hotchkiss told the writer that when a boy, he was
permitted to deliver a horse which his father, George Hotchkiss, had
sold to the general and that the horse was ridden by him into the war.
But to return to the history. I appears that the affairs of the Society did
not move on very harmoniously. They were without a minister, although the
appointed several committees "to treat with Mr. Bird for
to see if he will be persuaded to settle among us in the gospel
ministry," but all their efforts in that direction failed. Moreover,
those who were in favor of building the meeting-house on Canfield hill
persisted in their efforts to bring that project to a successful issue, but
that did not prevail, although much time and no doubt much patience was called
for before the matter was adjusted.
But finally they met at the house of Linus Hopson on the 24th
day of March, 1795, and with Mr. Ambrose Field as moderator
of the meeting they voted "That we build a house of public worship near
the place where the old meeting-house now stands, a little West of Selah
Strong's dwelling house, where the stake was formerly set for that
purpose."
At a subsequent meeting held April 6, 1795, they appointed "Ambrose
Field, Jairus Chittenden, Jonathan Baldwin, Moses Austin, John Palmer and
Silas Hullas a committee to secure the necessary
funds for the building of the house."
April 22, 1795.---According to adjournment they met in the old meeting-house
and appointed Silas S. Fordham, Contractor and Joseph
Hart and Selah Strong Advisory Committee, and they
voted "That we submit the bigness of the aforesaid house to the judgment
of the contractor." It appears that hitherto they had neglected to elect
a treasurer for the Society, hence at this meeting they chose Jonathan
Baldwin to that position. Then the record is as follows:
"This afternoon, received a Billet from the Northern committee
accompanied by the committee and clerk and heard the minds of their
constituents and
"Voted, That we think it not consistent with the interests of this people
to move from the place which we have fixed upon for building a house of public
worship;
"Voted, That we invite and request the Northern people to unite with us
in building the house;
"Voted, That the committee proceed to procure material for building said
house and hold out the papers for subscription."
So this always troublesome question of location was settled for the third time
in three years and each time in favor of meeting-house hill, but probably not
to the satisfaction of all, so that the matter was not passed to a
consummation that year.
The next Society meeting was held Dec. 16, 1795, at the house of "Capt.
Elihu Hart." He was a physician and lived in Broadway where the Derick
Wyncoop house is situated. At this meeting they voted
"First, That we make choice of Mr. Bela Strong
instead of Mr. Selah Strong, to serve as a committee, he
declining to serve as such;
"Second, That the said house shall be fifty-five
feet in length and forty-five in width, and that the committee, if they think
most convenient, may alter five in length and width, and no more;
"Third, That if any would wish to build a Steeple, they have free
toleration;
"Fourth, That the Committee proceed immediately to procure materials, and
carry on said building.
"Fifth, That the meeting be dissolved. Dissolved accordingly."
Their efforts at this time were crowned with success, and the year 1796
witnesses the construction of the house. This consummation, so earnestly
longed for, had been delayed for four years by the want of union among them in
regard to the site. Were these people obstinate? No, we think not; but
they were very decided in their opinions, and were not willing to call any man
"Master." They had assisted in conquering the British Lion,
and were engaged in subduing the forests and the stony fields to the uses of
husbandry, and it took time to learn subjection to each other. And it must be
confessed that except in the central location Meeting-house hill had little to
recommend it as a suitable place for a church.