CLASSIFICATION: Churchyard.
LOCATION: East of the village of Pleasant Valley, on the north side of the main highway.
CONDITION: Overgrown; surrounded by a stone wall.
INSCRIPTIONS: 175 in number. Copied October 4,1913, by J. W. Poucher, M. D., and Mrs. Poucher.
REMARKS: In 1825 Methodists in Pleasant Valley built a church on this site. The building was removed to the village in 1845.
1. Allen, Lucy, w. of Israel, d. 1864, Feb. 26, a. 53 y.
2. Babcock, Frank, s. of William & Phebe, d. 1887, July 26, in 26th y.
3. Babcock, Laura, dau. of William & Phebe, d. 1866, May 10, a. 6-7-16.
4. Banks, Ann Storms, w. of Daniel W., d. 1858, Mar. 27, a. 64-1-15.
5. Banks, Daniel W., d. 1859, May 30, a. 59-4-17.
6. Banks, Joseph W., s. of Daniel W. & Ann, d. 1839, Mar. 2, a. 1-9-29.
7. Bartlett, Armenia A. Wesley, w. of Charles B., d. 1861, Nov. 11, a. 29-11-18.
8. Beadle, Elisha, d. 1841, June 9, a. 62-11-9.
9. Birch, George, d. 1833, June 8, a. 57 y.
10. Birch, Rachel, w. of George, d. 1865, July 10, a. 81-4-12.
11. Bishop, Bartlett, Co. B, 128th N. Y. S. V., d. 1903, Mar. 26, a. 78 y.
12. Bishop, Charles A., d. 1867, Jan. 15, a. 2 y. 4 m.
13. Bishop, Ellen M., d. 1872, May 6, a. 15 y.
14. Bishop, Frederick A., d. 1864, June 3, a. 9-6-8.
15. Bishop, Uphemia Cole, w. of Bartlett, d. 1890, May 21, a. 66 y.
16. Bishop, William T., s. of Jacob S. & Sarah, d. 1863, July 26, a. 2 m. 16 d.
17. Bodenshatz, Louisa, dau. of John & Mary, d. 1867, Sep. 11, a. 3-8-17.
18. Bullock, Catharine, d. 1849, May 4, in 89th y.
19. Bullock, Mary, w. of Israel, d. 184(0), Feb. 13, a. 65 y. 9 m.
20. Burtis, Marie, dau. of Garret S. & Mary, d. 1849, May 31, in 25th y.
21. Cantine, Lucy, w. of Aaron, d. 1867, Jan. 25, a. 52-9-22.
22. Cheesman, Caroline L., w. of Filkins, d. 1850, Nov. 10, a. 51 y. 12 d.
23. Cheesman, Jacob, d. 1869, Nov. 16, a. 40 y. 11 d.
24. Cheesman, John N., s. of Filkins, d. 1831, Jan. 12, a. 7 y. 13 d.
25. Clark, Christiana T., dau. of Robert & Eliza, d. 1845, Aug. 15, a. 11 m. 15 d.
26. Clark, Eliza, w. of Robert, d. 1883, Mar. 21, a. 78-2-21.
27. Clark, Robert, d. 1862, Jan. 9, a. 69 y.
28. Collins, Oliver D., d. 1833, Feb. 13, a. 55 y. 2 m.
29. Collins, Oliver Davis, b. 1816, June 14, d. 1887, Sep. 16.
30. Collins, Sarah Ward, w. of Oliver D., d. 1860, Oct. 25, a. 76-8-13.
31. Cramer, Abraham, d. 1861, Mar. 3, a. 62 y. 15 d.
32. Cramer, Abraham, s. of Abraham & Permilla, d. 1875, Apr. 29, at Utica, N. Y., a. 39-7-21.
33. Cramer, Elizabeth Dingee, w. of Israel, d. 1866, Dec. 7, a. 74-3-18.
34. Cramer, Permilla, w. of Abraham, d. 1849, Feb. 17, a. 48-2-5.
35. Cramer, Sarah, d. 1886, Oct. 7, a. 64 y.
36. Crume, Lauretta Ann, w. of John P., d. 1851, Nov. 13, a. 49 y. 2 m.
37. Dean, Catherine M., d. 1856, June 16, in 26th y.
38. Dennis, William H., Co. C, 159th N. Y. (no dates).
39. Dise, William, d. 1851, Jan. 23, a. 80 y.
40. Doughty, John H., d. 1879, Aug. 20, a. 26-6-26.
41. DuBois, John R., d. 1872, July 23, a. 61 y.
42. DuBois, Rebecca, w. of John R., d. 1858, Jan. 3, a. 38-4-19.
43. Edmonds, Kerinada, d. 1857, Nov. 23, a. 33 y.
44. Elliott, Joseph H., s. of Rev. Joseph & Harriet M., d. 1856, Sep. 28, a. 6 m. 9 d.
45. Estelle, Helen Bishop, w. of John, b. 1834, July 4, d. 1902, Jan. 12.
46. Estelle, John, b. 1839, Jan. 1, d. 1902, Feb. 11.
47. Flagler, Maria E., dau. of Stephen & Caroline, d. 1845, Mar. 8, a. 6-10-9.
48. Flagler, Mary S., dau. of Stephen & Caroline, d. 1850, Sep. 2, a. 2 y. 9 d.
49. Foster, Elizabeth, d. 1857, Nov. 20, a. 81 y.
50. Foster, Frances A., d. 1873, Mar. 20, a. 30 y.
51. Foster, John I., d. 1852, Feb. 9, in 75th y.
52. Fowler, Ellen S., d. 1877, Sep. 9, a. 69 y.
53. Fowler, Senekey, d. 1856, Aug. 28, in 56th y.
54. (Gentleman), Mary, w. of James, d. 1849, May 19, a. 40 y. 8 m.
55. Giraud, Ann E.. dau. of Frederick & Margaret, d. 1861, June 3, a. 15 m. 3 d.
56. Graham, Angeline, w. of Richard, b. 1835, Feb. 18, d. 1871, Jan. 21.
57. Harris, Elizabeth, w. of William, d. 1829, Sep. 12, a, 54-11-7.
58. Harris, George C., d. 1837, May 5, a. 26 y. 24 d.
59. Harris, William, d. 1828, Feb. 18, a. 51-10-10.
60. Hart, Sarah, w. of William, d. 1858, Mar. 11, a. 66-11-20.
61. Hill, Gabriel, d. 1855, July 16, a. 67-2-11.
62. Hill, Owen S., d. 1892, Mar. 16, a. 53 y.
63. Hill, Sarah A., w. of Gabriel, b. 1810, Mar. 20, d. 1880, June 3.
64. Horton, Benjamin, b. 1836, Feb. 14, d. 1855, June 11.
65. Horton, Mamie, dau. of Benjamin & Jane, d. 1880, Dec. 21, a. 5-3-20.
66. Horton, Mary Jane Robertson, w. of Benjamin, b. 1838, Mar. 19, d. 1911, Oct. 6.
67. Howard, Hezekiah, d. 1849, May 13, in 44th y.
68. Howard, John W., s. of William & Pauline, d. 1848, Dec. 3, a. 1-4-20.
69. Howard, Maria, w. of Hezekiah, d. 1870, Dec. 4, in 59th y.
70. Howard, Paulina Storms, w. of William, d. 1867, Apr. 6, a. 62 y. 6 m.
71. Husted, Phebe J., w. of James D., d. 1860, Oct. 3, a. 37-4-27.
72. Ingraham, Anna Thorn, w. of John L., d. 1859, Sep. 19, a. 74-7-27.
73. Ingraham, Gilbert, s. of Gilbert H. & Mary P., d. 1852, June 27, a. 5 m.
74. Ingraham, Gilbert H., d. 1852, May 27, a. 31-7-20.
75. Ingraham, Irene Amelia, only child of William & Mary C., d. 1848, Dec. 29, a. 3 y. 3 m..
76. Ingraham, John L., d. 1846, Feb. 2, a. 67-9-6.
77. Ingraham, Mary Ann Drew, dau. of John L. & Anna, d. 1839, Dec. 5, a. 26-5-23.
78. Ingraham, Sarah Ann, dau. of Elizabeth, d. 1841, Sep. 14, a. 24 y. 15 d.
79. Ingraham, William, d. 1853, Dec. 29, in 35th y.
80. Johnston, Francis M., s. of Aleander & Phebe, d. 1862, Feb. 20, a. 10 m. 13 d.
81. Johnston, Ida C., dau. of Alexander & Phebe, d. 1858, Nov. 28, a. 3-7-25.
82. Johnston, William M., s. of Alexander & Phebe, d. 1863, Sep. 2, a. 2-5-25.
83. Jones, Nathan M., d. (1850?), (broken), a. 77-4-12.
84. Jones, Susan, w. of Nathan, d. 1869, Dec. 28, a. 79-4-8.
85. Koonz, Elizabeth, w. of Peter, d. 1866, May 3, a. 69 y.
86. Koonz, Peter, d. 1873, Apr. 18, in 79th y.
87. Lake, Hellin, w. of Stephen, d. 1845, Nov, 1, a. 32 y.
88. Lake, Maria, w. of John, d. 1842, June 28, in 42d y.
89. (Law) Mary Rice, w. of William, d. 1851, Feb. 23, a. 56-4-22.
90. Lester, George N., d. 1843, Feb. 11, a. 9-9-20.
91. Lewis, Maria L., dau. of Thomas & Mary J., d. 1861, May 13, a. 4-3-28.
92. Lewis, William T., Co. I, 128th N. Y. Vols., d. 1891, Mar. 18, a. 54 y.
93. Lucas, Arabella, only dau. of George & Sarah A., d. 1864, Aug. 16, a. 16 y.
94. McFarlin, Alfred, s. of Stephen & Phebe, d. 1859, Oct. 28, a. 33 y. 5 m.
95. McFarland, Elizabeth Cornwell, w. of Levi, b. 1803, May 8, d. 1885, Mar. 13.
96. McFarlin, Isaac C., s, of Levi & Elizabeth, d. 1839, Apr. 4, a. 11 m. 8 d.
97. McFarland, Levi, d. 1872, Mar. 18, in 65th y.
98. McIntosh, Johnnie, d. 1871, Jan. 24, in 24th y.
99. Marshall, Eli, d. 1866, Feb. 11, a. 63-4-22.
100. Marshall, Harriet, dau. of Eli & Catharine, d. 1858, Oct. 13, a. 16-2-24.
101. Marshall, Sarah, dau. of Eli & Catharine, d. 1858, Feb. 9, a. 26-3-28.
102. Mastin, Clara A. T.. dau. of David & Mary E., d. 1875, Jan. 11, a. 3 y.
103. Masten, Hezekiah G., Co. D, 128th N. Y. Vols., d. 1865, July 28, a. 25 y.
104. Masten, James E., d. 1879, May 5, in 39th y.
105. Moore, Maria, d. 1873, Jan. 27, a. 90 y.
106. Morris, Martha E., dau. of John & Mary L., d. 1850, May 24, a. 3 wks.
107. (Morris?), Rodah E., d. 1841, Apr. 22, a. 2 y.
108. Mo(wies), William P., d. 1892, July 12, a. 45 y. 14 d.
109. Newcomb, John, d. 1827, Feb. 6, a. 56-11-13.
110. Newcomb, Ruth, w. of John, d. 1834, Dec. 17, a. 62 y. 5 m.
111. Oakley, Eliza, w. of William M., d. 1866, Apr. 2, in 66th y.
112. Oakley, William M., d. 1875, Jan. 20, in 74th y.
113. Odell, Almira A. Baker, w. of Samuel D., d, 1858, Nov. 27, a. 36 y. 7 m.
114. Odell, Cornelia, dau. of Samuel D. & Almira, d. 1866, Aug. 18, a. 8-4-19.
115. Odell, Frances D., dau, of Milton & Harriett, d. 1855, Feb. 25, a. 5 m. 5 d.
116. Overocker, Sarah Lake, w. of Abraham L., d. 1865, Apr. 13, in 83d y.
117. Palmatier, Charles H., d. 1882, Feb. 3, a. 50 y.
118. Patten, Mary F., dau. of William T. & Sarah A., d. 1858, Mar. 27, a. 9-11-4.
119. Place, Louisa Matilda, dau. of Welcome & Louisa, d. 1853, Nov. 26, (age not decipherable).
120. Race, Maria Jane, d. 1866, Aug. 3, a. 2 y. 2 m.
121. Race, Phebe J. Stormes, w of Philo, 1831-1909.
122. Race, Philo, d. 1888, Nov. 1, a. 64 y. 5 m.
123. Rice, Alida, dau. of Jacob & Delia M., d. 1880, Mar. 25, a. 21 y. 6 m.
124. Rice, Egbert N., s. of Jacob & Delia, d. 1876, Mar. 16, a. 21-1-22.
125. Rice, Garrison, s. of Solomon & Sarah, d. 1843, Jan. 8, a. 5-10-5.
126. Rice, Mary Ann, w. of Jacob, d. 1849, Nov. 11, a. 44-6-10.
127. Robertson, Mary, b. 1813, June 12, d. 1884, Nov. 14.
128. Robertson, Richard T., d. 1863, May 26, a. 70-9-19.
129. Rogers, Alexander, Co. I, 150th N. Y. Vols., d. 1873, June 10, a. 42 y.
130. Rogers, Catherine, w. of Alexander, d. 1864, Sep. 21, a. 29 y. 5 m.
131. Rozell, Hannah, w. of William J., d. 1877, Apr. 18, in 73d y.
132. Shaw, Rachel, w. of Elymus, d. 1858, Apr. 9, a. 59-5-13.
133. Silvernail, John Henry, only s. of George & Sarah, d. 1844, June 18, a. 11-10-27.
134. Sleight, Martha, w. of Solomon, d. 1839, Mar. 29, a. 47 y.
135. Sleight, Solomon, d. 1843, Mar. 1, a. 70-3-10.
136. Smith, Aaron H., s. of William S. & Loretta, d. 1864, May 22, a. 1-5-22.
137. Spencer, Jane, w. of J. C., d. 1872, Sep. 13, in 71st y.
138. Stevens, Mary, dau, of Elijah & Mary, d. 1841, Feb. 16, a. 32 y.
139. Stewert, Anna, dau. of Thomas & Sarah, d. 1849, Jan. 13, in 73d y.
140. Stewart, Phebe, wid. of Josiah, d. 1843, Feb. 2, a. 51 y.
141. Stiwell, Daniel, d. 1844, Dec. 21, a. 55-3-27.
142. Stiwell, James Edward, d. 1852, Dec.12, a. 26-10-6.
143. Stilwell, John, d. 1837, Apr. 22, a. 77 y. 2 m.
144. Stilwell, Lydia, w. of Daniel, d. 1855, Oct. 27, a. 64-11-27.
145. Stillwell, Rebecca, d. 1843, Apr. 24, a. 75 y.
146. Storm, Catharine, w. of Jacob, d. 1875, Oct. 11, a. 66-6-18.
147. Storm, Jacob, d. 1867, Sep. 11, a. 64-5-28.
148. Storm, Joseph F., s. of Jacob & Catharine, d. 1862, Dec. 1, a. 9-2-5.
149. Storm, Luman, s. of Jacob & Catharine, d. 1855, Mar. 3, a. 4-5-15.
150. Storm, Rebecca, dau. of Jacob & Catharine, d. 1870, Sep.17, a. 31-8-21.
151. Storm, Susan Ann, dau. of Jacob & Catharine. d. 1855, Dec. 6, a. 23 y. 2 m.
152. Stormes, Abram, d. 1882, Nov. 15, in 76th y.
153. Stormes, Elizabeth Tripp, w. of Abram, d. 1879, Aug. 22, in 72d y.
154. Stormes, Kesiah Lake, w. of Jacob, d. 1871, July 16, a. 92-5-6.
155. Stormes, Matilda, dau. of Jacob & Kesiab, 1822-1891.
156. Storms, Catharine H., w. of John I., d. 184(0), Oct. 27. a. 40-3-27.
157. Storms, Catharine M., dau. of John I. & Catharine H., d. 186(2). Dec. 22, a. (21)-6-13.
158. Storms, John I., d. 1866, July 13, a. 69-7-26.
159. Storms, Phebe Jane, w. of Isaac, d. 1856, Apr. 5, a. 36 y. 1 m.
160. Taylor, Edward C., d. 1825, Nov. 15, a. 40 y.
161. Taylor, Maria C., w. of Edward C., d. 1831, July 10, a. 43 y.
162. Temple, Hester, w. of Aleander, d. 1833, Sep. 16, a. 35 y.
163. Thompson, John, d. 1881, May 2, a. 74 y.
164. Traver, Mary, w. of William L., d, 1845, Aug. 1, a. 38 y. 10 m.
165. Traver, William L., d. 1872, June 13, a. 71 y. 28 d.
166. Tripp, Elisha, d. 1844, Nov. 6, a. 30-4-8.
167. Turner, Abram T., d. 1865, Mar. 29, a. 33 y. 10 m,
168. Turner, George W., s. of John W. & Mary A., d. 1867, Feb. 6. a. 1 y. 9 m.
169. Wesley, Charlotte, dau. of John W. & Charlotte A., d. 1848, Oct. 2, a. 10-3-20.
170. Wesley, Mary E., dau. of John W. & Charlotte A., d. 1848, Oct. 13, a. 14-4-6.
171. Whitney, A., d. 1833, Mar. 5, (slate stone, nothing more decipherable)*See below.
172. Williams, Maria, w. of Peter, d. 1868, Sep. 10, a. 35 y. 5 m.
173. Williams, Peter, d. 1856, Feb .27, a. 41-6-4.
174. Wolf, Margaret, w. of Henry, d. 1848, Feb. 24, a. 53 y.
Miscellaneous
175. (?), Mary Nellie, d. 1875, Aug. 25, a. 9 m. 20 d.
*This is the grave of Asahel Whitney. Born Feb 15, 1833. Died March 5, 1833.
Asahel is the son of Asa Whitney and Julia Ann Whitney (nee Quick). He was the fifth child of 12. Submitted by Theresa Briccetti on 1/9/2013.
Copied by Charlotte Carey Dingee and transcribed and submitted by Liz DuBois