SUGARTOWN CEMETERY
Great Valley , NY

NAME DOB DOD AGE COMMENTS
Ackley, Dolly   12/14/1862 82y  
Ackley, Eli       No Dates
Ball, Asa   1855    
Ball, Cora 1864 1910    
Ball, Lottie 1861 1904    
Ball, Stanley   1892    
Barrow, Benjamin       Stone broken
Barrow, Betsey E.   11/12/1863 66-5-8  
Barrow, Martha   10/29/1885 75y  
Barrow, Robert   10/31/1863 67-11-29  
Barrow, William 7/14/1831 11/2/1900    
Berry, Christine       No dates
Berry, P.O.   4/9/1888 72y  
Boillet, Harry T.M.   4/3/1857 30-11-3  
Boillett, Ella M.   12/2/1861 10-9m  
Bond, Joseph   8/10/1830 3-6 m  
Bond,Lucy   3/26/1841 9y Ch. of Deacon J. & Laura
Bowen, Cary   10/23/1874 2-4-6 Son
Bowen, Clark F. 1840 1920    
Bowen, E.A. Dean 1835 1921    
Bowen, Lucinda   1/9/1887 70-3m  
Bowen, Olivia 1845 1918   Wife of Clark F.
Bowen, Rev. I.L. 1833 1908    
Bryant, Franklin Sheldon 11/13/1851 12/18/1922   s/of Sheldon & Ruth Bryant
Bryant, Freeman Aug.6,1792 2/1/1860 67y Son/Nathaniel III & Elizabeth
Bryant, Hulda 1820 1866   Wife of A.C. & C.B.
Bryant, Julia Blair 1810 187?   W/of Rodman Bryant
Bryant, Mary F. Prigg Aug.26,1858 9/16/1941   Wife of Franklin 
Bryant, Orren Jan.8, 1808 3/12/1877 69-2-4 S/of Nathaniel III & Elizabeth
Bryant, Rodman  8/2/1803 185?   Hus/of Julia Blair Bryant
Bryant, Ruth 10/22/1817 10/4/1908   Wife of Sheldon
Bryant, Sheldon 3/23/1812 1/2/1886   Hus/of Ruth Chamberlain B.
Butler, Ephriam W. 3/28/1828 11/12/1897    
Butler, Lydia 7/25/1833 7/25/1917    
Calkins, L.D.       No dates
Calkins, Malvina D.   12/2/1890 64y  
Campbell, J.A.   12/5/1871 56-27d  
Campbell, Permelia 1820 1905    
Carnes, Martha    1/23/1893 54y  
Carnes, S.       No dates
Carnes, Spencer 1840 1922    
Chamberlain, Ada J.   5/11/1897 8d  
Chamberlain, Alta E. 1863      
Chamberlain, Frank 1830      
Chase, Abigail   2/17/1847 23-1-14 Wife
Chase, Adelaide Walrath   10/31/1851    
Chase, Jonathan   9/28/1846    
Chase, Joseph 1824 1895    
Chase, Lomas L.   Oct. 1851    
Chase, Lorenzo D. 11/29/1854 32-6-4    
Chase, Maryette 1834 1896    
Chase, Moses   2/14/1849 63-4-22  
Chase, Nathaniel       No dates
Chase, Nellie   3/19/1870 1m  
Chase, Orren A. 7-9-1847 5-19-1928   Civil War 154th NYS Vols.
Chase, Porter J.   1/7/1853 36-3-6  
Chase, Robert   5/31/1834 43y  
Chase, Robert   5/31/1843 43y  
Chase, Sarah   5/26/1871 74-9m Wife
Chase, Sophia   5/10/1834 19-1-10  
Chickering, Calvin 1809 1916 (?)    
Chickering, Dr. Calvin   11/15/1847 38y  
Chollette, Fidelia McIntosh 2/7/1819 11/2/1908    
Clark, Achsa 12/25/1805 4/1/1855   Wife
Clark, Catherine L. 3/8/1835 7/4/1870   Wife
Clark, H.S. 12/8/1830 12/12/1898   Civil War 154th NYS Vols.
Clark, Hiram 12/17/1801 3/30/1885    
Clark, Jane L. 1/7/1836 3/30/1885    
Clark, M. Jane 10/19/1835 11/1/1888    
Clark, Mary A. 3/8/1833 3/20/1863   Daughter
Cleveland, Aaron 2/3/1821 2/5/1899    
Cleveland, Betsey E. 2/14/1792 11/6/1847   Wife
Cleveland, Branard 4/15/1788 6/5/1867    
Cleveland, Catherine 10/16/1832 8/4/1904    
Cleveland, Mary A. 8/12/1826 8/20/1847    
Cochran, Jane D. 1857 1874    
Coxe, Mary J. 2/28/1826 4/23/1910    
Coxe, Mervin       No dates
Creary, Archibald       Also 4 sisters
Creary, Archie C. 1819      
Creary, Augustine 1856 1861    
Creary, Augustus, M.D. 1787 1867    
Creary, Benjamin 7/29/1811 5/4/1890    
Creary, Benjamin 1789 1796    
Creary, Betsy   9/14/1857 56y Wife of Spencer
Creary, Clark S. 1853      
Creary, Dr. Clark 1811      
Creary, Elbert   12/15/1849 4m 20d Son of A.C. & H.
Creary, Elbert 1849   5 m  
Creary, Freeman E. 1857      
Creary, H. Hale 1815      
Creary, H.H. 1815 1887    
Creary, Harmon A. 1817      
Creary, Infant   1/19/1851    
Creary, Lucy 1784 1861    
Creary, Nancy Campbell        
Creary, Prudence Hale 1784 1861   Wife of Dr. A. Cready
Creary, Rhoda 3/25/1815 1/19/1882   Wife
Creary, Sophia 1822 1911    
Creary, Spencer   9/21/1865 61y  
Creary, Spencer 1783 1846    
Creary, William 1712 1796    
Creary, William 1759 1829    
Creary, William 1785 1859    
Davidson, Lucy   1878 84y  
Davidson, Susan   1823    
Davidson, Thomas   1892 59y  
Dickerson, Charles F.   June 1851 56y 15d  
Dickerson, John W.   11/16/1844 70y  
Dickerson, Sandstone       No dates
Evans, Mercy 1/1/1831 10/23/1897   Wife
Evans, Sylvester 7/9/1818 5/8/1890    
Folts, Lyle 1922 1924    
Folts, Morris 1847 19 --    
Folts, Nina C. 1846 1917   Wife
Folts, Vernice A.   12/28/1905 27-7-16 Wife of Floyd
Foster, Edward 5/27/1833 9/9/1888   Civil War
Foyts, Catherine 1902 1909    
Frank, Jacob 3/2/1800 2/15/1884    
Frank, James D. 1832 1904    
Frank, Margaret 2/28/1801 11/20/1887   Wife
Frank, Sarah 1837 1878    
Fuller, Claude 1892     Son/Frank & Lucy
Gardner, George   11/10/1837 22-11-4  
Gardner, Granville Decatur   1/18/1864   Died in Belle I. Prison C.W.
Gardner, Horatio   1819   Civil War 154th NYS Vols.
Gardner, Julia A.   5/13/1874 50y 5m 23d Wife
Gardner, Orala   3/4/1880 59-10-8  
Gardner, Orrilla   10/13/1869 44y Wife
Gardner, Stephen   8/22/1855 84y  
Golding, Mary   8/21/1829 44y Wife of Wm Creary
Hall, Mary    9/1/1823 52y Wife
Hall, Ralph, Jr.   11/6/1825 58y  
Harrison, Alena 3/10/1851 10/2/1887   Wife of C.H.
Harrison, Clarinda 1836     Wife
Harrison, Mark 1832 1899    
Hewitt, ___________   8/12/1849 66y 4m Wife of Thomas
Hicar, Emma 1845      
Hoag, Mildred 4/7/1873 5/5/1892    
Jackson, Rev. M.A.       No dates
Johnson, Achsah 1837 12/11/1935    
Johnson, Emma C. Frank 1828 1909   Wife of John A.
Johnson, John A. 2-1827 5-1-1911   Civil War 154th NYS Vols.
Johnson, Stephen T. 1829 1909   Civil War
Jones, Betsey A. 1845 1913    
Jones, Frederick   6/21/1854 40y 2m  
Jones, Oliver A. 1836 1909    
Keir, Andrew 6/23/1840 4/26/1919    
Keir, Janet   2/1/1872 77y  
Keir, Jennie 8/11/1849 3/19/1901   Wife
Keir, William   11/21/1879 68y Born Balgonia, Scotland
Lounsbury, Lillia B. 6/19/1859 2/4/1902   Wife
Lounsbury, Thomas 8/6/1855 5/11/1926    
Marvin, A.C.   9/22/1842    
Marvin, Elizabeth 11/2/1818 5/29/1894   Wife
Marvin, Ella M. 9/23/1844 1913    
Marvin, Enoch   8/25/1850 74y  
Marvin, F.A. 6/18/1820 9/24/1902    
McCoon, Ann Creary 1845 1904   Wife
McCoon, Rev. Newton 1835 1906    
McKay, Adaline M. 1841 1914    
McKay, Oscar 1839 1917   Civil War
McKeon, Albert I. 1846 1926    
McKeon, Helen Cole 1848 1881   Wife
McKeon, Rev. D.W. 6/23/1811 6/4/1871   Died in 

Olean

Meacham, Ernest Vernon 1878 1905   Killed in a horse and buggy accident
Melvin, Antoinette   8/7/1865 40y 6m  
Melvin, C.D.       No dates
Moore, Edgar L. 1859 3/29/1941    
Moore, Eliza 6/6/1832 10/26/1878   Wife
Moore, Hattie E. 1859 1921    
Moore, Romanzo 12/23/1829 5/8/1864   Civil War Co. 154
Morgan, Harriet 4/17/1812 6/26/1887   Wife
Morgan, Hiram 10/7/1852 1/5/1875    
Morgan, Hiram   10/25/1864 58-8-10  
Morgan, James   8/30/1871 31y 19d Civil War
Morgan, Phidelia   1/5/187_ 22y 3m  
Myrick, Hattie 12/2/1857 10/17/1885   Wife of Eugene
Nelson, Jane Ann 1823 1848    
Neoson, Jane Ann   2/23/1848 25y Wife of Geo. B.
Oaks, Edgar D.   11/8/1856    
Oaks, Hattie E. 1881 1912    
Oaks, Irving C. 1898 1916    
Oaks, Nettie 11/7/1863 2/6/1908    
Oaks, Raymond H. 1908 1924    
Persons, Ephriam P. 1807 1885    
Persons, Helen Laidlaw 1802 1879    
Phillips, Juliana C. 1/22/1816 6/14/1886    
Putnam, Arthur N.   10/18/1871    
Putnam, Elsie   7/31/1890 45-9-11 Wife
Putnam, Grace Howard 1857 1929   Wife
Putnam, J.M. and C.P.       No dates
Putnam, John M. 1863 1928    
Putnam, Joseph M. C. 1-5-1841 5-21-1930   Civil War NYS Vols.
Putnam, Rose O.   2/26/1876    
Reed, Caroline Creary 1810 1901   Wife of Chickering Reed
Reed, Dr. Virgil 1814 1906    
Reed, Frank M.   1849    
Rider, Abbie   6/25/1892 30-10-4  
Rider, William Fox       No dates
Root, Betsey 3/30/1829 2/28/1906    
Root, Noah M. 11/16/1820 8/9/1877    
Salisbury, Elizabeth T. 1835 1895    
Scott, John 1816 1903   Civil War
Scott, Oliver   3/4/1857 42-10-4  
See, Margaret Brown 1851 1924    
Shepherd, Thomas N. 1839 5-22-1918   Civil War 154th NYS Vols.
Sherman, Helen M. 6/18/1854 8/12/1894   Wife
Sherman, Stephen Edward (1) 8/28/1866 in Lyndon 7/7/1958 in Portville    
Slocum, Theresa 1873 1922    
Stillman, Sally   4/28/1864 57-6-25 Wife of Erastus
Thomas Eva   6/30/1876 33-8-21  
Thomas, Charles 1828 1895    
Thomas, Eunice   7/16/1869 67y Wife
Thomas, Isaac   8/30/1867 74-5-10  
Thomas, Laura   2/12/1846 21-10-16  
Thomas, Sarah  1841 1896   Wife
Thomas, Shepard N. 1839 1918   Civil War
Torrance, Hugh 1819 1898   Father
Torrance, James 1853 1872   Died of Scarlet Fever
Torrance, John 1849 1872   Died of Scarlet Fever
Torrance, Rachel  1823 1906   Mother
VanSlyke, Birtha 1880      
VanSlyke, Egbert 1851 1902    
VanSlyke, Lora A. 1851     Wife
Walrath, Elizabeth   6/7/1873 87-3-23 Wife of David
Walrath, Mary 1828 1908    
Walrath, Walter 8-28-1826 1899   Civil War 154th NYS Vols.
Warkins, Addie E. 1870      
Warkins, Ira D. 1864 1910    
Weatherly, Charles 1829 1909    
Weatherly, Cornelia 1848 1908   Wife
Weatherly, Sandstone       P.F.C.
Whittlesey, John Pratt 1845 1904   Hus/of Mary Bryant
Whittlesey, Mary Bryant 1845 4/3/1900   Dau/of Sheldon & Ruth
Widrig, Conrad 1843 1915    
Widrig, Harriet Ayer 1847 1915   Wife
Wilson, Claude J. 1878 1917    
Wilson, Joseph G. 1843 1924    
Wilson, Juliette Harvey 1846 1907    
Wimple, Charles T. 12/14/1844 3/19/1875   Civil War
Woodard, Atcelia 1845 1907    
Woodard, Robert J. 4-14-1843 2-9-1917   Civil War 154th NYS Vols.
Wright, Franklin   10/7/1850 8y 21d  
Wright, Frederick 1/8/1819 4/12/1883    
Wright, Polly  10/20/1799 3/31/1873    
Wright, Richard   10/15/1851 65y  
This cemetery contributed by
Painted Hills Genealogical Society
(formerly Enchanted Mountain Genealogical Society)

Foot Notes

(1) Additional information provided by Candie Sherman 11/2010

Back to Cattaraugus County Cemetery Page
Back to Cattaraugus County Main Page