The cemetery is located on what was the homestead of Daniel R. Shirley and began with the burial of an infant daughter. The next recorded burial was that of a neighbor, James Terry who died in 1872. Other family members were buried in the plot and the Shirleys deeded the cemetery to a board of trustees in the mid 1870s. The following list of burials is compiled from several resources including death certificates, family histories, a partial list of burials published in the Bethany Republican-Clipper and an old survey graciously provided by Kenneth Shirley. Other research and a compilation of information was done by Phil and Kathi Stewart.
NOTE: Photos on this site are the property of the photographer and/or contributor. They may be downloaded for personal use, but may NOT be used or contributed to another web site without permission.
Return to Harrison County main page
The Shirley Cemetery is located approximately one mile west of Eagleville in Marion Township of northern Harrison County. From Eagleville, go west on blacktop M for .7 mile. The cemetery is approximately 1/4 of a mile north of the blacktop on private property.
SURNAME GIVEN NAME BIRTH DATE DEATH DATE OTHER INSCRIPTION EDITOR'S NOTES
ANDERSON
Aley Minerva
May 4, 1824
Mar 27, 1918
Dau of Allen and Elizabeth Montgomery
Born in Kentucky
Wife of Samuel Anderson
Listed as "Minerva" in the 1870 and 1900 censuses of Harrison Co., MOBARBER
Mary Melvina
Oct 20, 1847
Aug 20, 1874
Dau of Simpson and Martha Montgomery
Born in Kentucky
Wife of James BarberBROWN
Katheryn
Apr 18, 1855
Mar 30, 1924
Dau of James and Mary McKay
Born in Ohio
Wife of Charles A. BrownCOLE
Ellen
Apr 22, 1852
Mar 22, 1921
Dau of James and Mary McKay
Wife of James Humphrey ColeDEMPSEY
Elizabeth
May 19, 1930
No Birth Date
FUNK
Frederick E.
Oct 31, 1879
Aug 11, 1905
Son of Henry and Martha (McKay) Funk
FUNK
Martha "Mattie"
May 7, 1859
May 14, 1940
Dau of James and Mary McKay
Wife of Henry Edward FunkFUNK
Robert E.
Jun 9, 1882
1924
Son of Henry and Martha Funk
Husband of Mary WelshGLENN
Larry Mac
Sep 10, 1838
Sep 10, 1838
Son of Clarence and Opal McKay
HOBBS
Buena Vista
Jul 23, 1850
Sep 1, 1928 Dau of Daniel and America Shirley
Born in Kentucky
Wife of Ezekiel HobbsKNOWLES
Nancy H.
May 23, 1809
May 9, 1873
Maiden Name Hill
Born in Delaware
Wife of Philip KnowlesMcKAY
Albert
Mar 5, 1865
Mar 12, 1898
Son of James and Mary McKay
Husband of Mary McKayMcKAY
Anna Mariah
Feb 16, 1862
Dec 29, 1929
Dau of James and Eliza Choat
Born in Indiana
Wife of James McKayMcKAY
Arthur Charles
Dec 19, 1890
Jan 12, 1946
Son of James and Anna McKay
Husband of Myrtle BentMcKAY
Elizabeth
1829
Apr 18, 1873
Dau of James and Mary McKay
McKAY
Infant Dau
Aug 5, 1883
Aug 12, 1883
Dau of James McKay
McKAY
James
June 1850
Feb 25, 1908
Son of James and Mary McKay
Husband of Anna ChoatMcKAY
James
1821
Mar 17, 1875<
Born in Ireland
Husband of Mary (Halfpenny) McKayMcKAY
James F.
Oct 20, 1885
Jan 16, 1916
Son of James and Anna (Choat) McKay
McKAY
Lydia Adelle
May 5, 1883
Mar 24, 1944
Dau of Osmond and Sarah Weltha
Wife of Patrick McKay (1st) and Joseph McKay (2nd)
McKAY
Mary J.
Aug 7, 1819
Feb 12, 1907
Born in Ireland / Maiden name Halfpenny
Wife of James McKay
McKAY
Patrick Henry
Oct 3, 1863
Apr 4, 1935
Son of James and Mary J. McKay
Husband of Lydia Weltha
MONTGOMERY
Elizabeth Ruth "Betsy"
Jun 17, 1788
Oct 18, 1885
Dau of Thomas and Ruth Vaughn, Sr.
Born in Kentucky
Wife of Allen Montgomery
MONTGOMERY
George H.
Mar 15, 1864
Jun 10, 1926
Death Certificate has year of birth as 1862
Reportedly buried in an unmarked grave
MONTGOMERY
Martha Ann
Feb 6, 1819
Jan 22, 1874
Dau of William and Jane (Shirley) Dale
Born in Kentucky
Wife of Simpson Montgomery
MONTGOMERY
Mildred "Millie"
Mar 28, 1827
May 28, 1918
Born in Kentucky
Dau of Holdman and Margaret Smith
MONTGOMERY
Simpson Kinkaid
Dec 19, 1912
Mar 24, 1898
Son of Allen and Elizabeth (Vaughn) Montgomery
Born in Kentucky
Hus of Martha (Dale) Montgomery
REEVES
Mariah M.
Oct 14, 1821
Jul 31, 1890
Dau of George and Elizabeth (Dale) Shirley
Wife of George Reeves
SHIRLEY
America E.
Aug 22, 1826
Feb 2, 1877
Dau of William and Jane (Shirley) Dale
Born in Kentucky
Wife of Daniel Shirley
SHIRLEY
Daniel R.
Jul 8, 1817
Apr 11, 1876
Son of Richard and Elizabeth (Dale) Shirley
Hus of America (Dale) Shirley
SHIRLEY
Elizabeth E.
Mar 26, 1859
Jan 1, 1941
Dau of Daniel and America Shirley
SHIRLEY
George H.
Mar 15, 1864
Jun 10, 1926
SHIRLEY
George W.
Dec 12, 1862
Jan 23, 1922
Son of Daniel and America Shirley
SHIRLEY
Infant Son
1865
Jul 17, 1868
SHIRLEY
Mariah A.
Oct 2, 1853
Oct 16, 1914
Dau of Daniel and America Shirley
SHIRLEY
Reuben
Sep 29, 1855
Sep 29, 1865
Son of Daniel and America Shirley
SHIRLEY
Ruth J.
Aug 29, 1864
Mar 10, 1871
Dau of Daniel and America Shirley
SHIRLEY
Sarah R.
Aug 25, 1857
Oct 22, 1917
Dau of Daniel and America Shirley
SHIRLEY
William J.
Dec 31, 1866
Mar 12, 1871
Son of Daniel and America Shirley
TERRY
James Walker
Mar 3, 1801
Apr 15, 1872
Born in what is now West Virginia
Hus of Lucinda (Metzger) Terry
TERRY
Lucinda
Nov 16, 1814
Nov 3, 1902
Dau of Phillip and Sarah Metzger
Born in what is now West Virginia
Wife of James Walker Terry
TERRY
Philip Marion
Jul 31, 1836
Jan 13, 1916
Son of James and Lucinda Terry
Listed as "Marion" with parents in the 1850 census of Menard County, Illinois
The 1900 and 1910 censuses list him as "Widowed", but his death certificate states he was divorced.
Return to Harrison County Cemeteries page
Copyright © 2012-13 by Barbra Chambers