Old Marriage Certificates
The following information is taken from old original records. Some are just small portions of paper containing the Minister's or JP's returns stating that he did indeed join the husband and wife in marriage on a given date. A few have the license and the return both on the same paper; some just had the license portion. On a few larger pages, the official includes reports of having married multiple couples (on the same page) so those are filed under the name of the first groom on the page and indexed by a (see__________) reference. This list was created at the Marshall County Museum.
| GROOMS | BRIDES | DATE OF MARRIAGE |
| Absheer, Ansael | Sarah Cripe | 25 October 1846 |
| Andrews, Stephen | Lucretia Harris | 7 July 1853 |
| Armstrong, John | Sophronia J. Smith | 24 April 1853 |
| Armstrong, John H. | Orlitto, Chapman | 27 April 1848 |
| Ash, Adam C. | Missouri Brown | 25 October 1849 |
| Auldridg, John | Celestia Burch | 27 Dec. 1845 (see John Trowbridge) |
| Aumaker, Godlove | Elizabeth Foegely | (see Omaker) |
| Austin, Joseph P. | Abbey E. Jackson | 4 June 1848 |
| Bailey, O. P. | Martha Trowbridge | 4 April 1847 |
| Bailey, W. N. | M. A. Rose | 14 May 1846 |
| Baker, Franklin | Elizabeth Bannan | 27 November 1845 |
| Baker, Hiram | Elisa Ann Powers | 3 February 1846 |
| Baker, Israel | Margaret Orick | 24 July 1845 |
| Barkey, Jacob | Martha E. Williams | 25 February 1849 |
| Barkus, Bartlet V. | Fanetta Monroe | 18 September 1849 |
| Beagles, Lewis | Jane James | 27 February 1845 |
| Beagles, Robert | Phebe Emily McCormick | 4 October 1849 |
| Belangee, Enoc | Elizabeth Jane Milner | 27 May 1847 |
| Belangee, Sooy | Mary Ann Millner | 21 October 1847 |
| Belangee, Wesly | Mary B. Ball | 18 December 1844 |
| Beyler, Jacob | Ann Elizabeth Berger | 18 June 1846 |
| Bigley, Edward | Amelia Fisher | 20 June 1850 |
| Bixby, Amos | Deliah Ray | 3 December 1846 |
| Blakely, James D. | Susan Garard | 30 January 1845 |
| Bliven, Robert C. | Rachel Croco | 12 December 1846 |
| Boles, L. M. | Catharine Lyons | 11 February 1849 |
| Boreon, William | Sarah Jane White | 21 April 1853 |
| Bouthen, J. Broderick | Mariah Dawson | 9 April 1846 |
| Bowles, Thomas N. | Artemecia Moore | 4 March 1849 |
| Burch, Charles D. | Rachael Crosbury | 26 March 1845 |
| Burch, George W. | Nancy Shirley | 17 October 1848 |
| Burch, John G. | Elizabeth Smallwood | 4 September 1845 |
| Burch, Norton | Elizabeth Smallwood | 25 January 1846 |
| Burden, Thomas | Sarah Gibson | 1 September 1853 |
| Burns, Calvin | Eliza E. Pumphrey | 20 March 1853 |
| Bush, John | Mary Moritz | 7 April 1849 |
| Butts, Aaron | Anna Burns | 10 June 1849 |
| Camp, Jonathan | Mary Primley | 9 March 1848 |
| Carpenter, Nicholas L. | Abigail Brown | 20 October 1849 |
| Carter, George | Minerva Jane Stark | 21 May 1846 |
| Case, James H. | Jane Crum | 6 December 1849 |
| Chamberlan, Alexander | Irene Taylor | 1 September 1850 |
| Chapman, Clark | Bethiah Barnhill | 2 October 1847 |
| Chapman, Clinten | Mary Knap | 5 March 1847 |
| Chapman, Courtland | Emily Bently | 23 August 1849 |
| Clark, Chester | Alma Norris | 12 March 1846 |
| Clark Jesse D. | Pheby Houghton | 18 January 1846 |
| Clark, John H. | Mary Ann Morris | 1 April 1847 |
| Clark, William | Mary Justice | 29 January 1849 |
| Clemmons, Franklin | Margaret Akins | 22 October 1848 |
| Conner, Andrew J. | Mary Ann Collins | 12 March 1848 |
| Cooper, Benjamin D.(?) | Ellen Justice | 22 August 1847 |
| Coopper, John G. | Nelly Ann Rhodes | 8 July 1845 |
| Corbaly, Richard | Jane Croco | 6 May 1847 |
| Cornwall, Andrew | Jain Nash | 28 August 1845 (see George Nitcher) |
| Cotten, Isaac | Phidelia A. Aiken | 17 November 1849 |
| Crimer, Levi | Ruth Ann Murphey | 7 August 1853 |
| Croco, John | Minerva Lewis | 16 June 1853 |
| Crum, Peter | Elizabeth Sluyter | 26 April 1846 |
| Cruzan, Andrew J. | Catharine Sults | 18 October 1849 |
| Cruzan, Lemuel | Mary Ann Barcus | 21 August 1844 |
| Cumans (Cummins), William | Marthy Jane Butler | 11 January 1845 |
| Cutshaw, Amos | Sarah Dilworth | 27 March 1853 |
| Cutshaw, Jacob | Jemima Moore | 30 May 1848 |
| Davis, Loyd I. | Sarah Jane Gordon | 28 April 1853 |
| Dawson, Daniel | Elizabeth King | 3 October 1852 |
| Dawson, Gabrial F. | Susanah Elden | 28 January 1847 (license only) |
| Dawson, Uel | Leurana Harris | 6 August 1853 |
| DeCamp, Joseph | Abigal Ousterhout | 3 January 1847 |
| Dewit, Samuel | Lydia Mulkins | 25 December 1847 |
| Drake, Joseph N. | Roxey Carry Lyon | 20 June 1852 |
| Dwinnells, Edwin | Nancy Abrams | 4 December 1845 |
| Elder, Daniel | Maria A. Gerard | 16 August 1849 |
| Elles (Ellis), John | Jane Coil | 5 September 1852 |
| Ernman, John | Catharine Hogate | 6 June 1847 |
| Finley, John | Elizabeth Cornwall | 31 August 1847 |
| Fisher, Adam | Catharine Ringle | 25 November 1847 |
| Fisher, Jacob | Meahnor Henershaitz | 6 July 1848 |
| Fits (Fitz), Christian | Electa E. Moore | 27 August 1850 |
| Franklin, Thomas | Martha Arbuckle | 16 May 1850 |
| Franks, Isiah | Mary Yockey | 20 February 1847 |
| Fuller, Horace | Manerva Harvy | 15 December 1844 (see Jos. Griffith) |
| Fuller, John B. | Elizabeth Harvey | 6 June 1849 |
| Gerard, Andrew | Susan Hindle | 30 November 1847 |
| Gibson, Thomas | Rebecca Burden | 2 February 1853 (license only) |
| Gillum, James | Elizabeth Fish | 7 August 1853 |
| Glass, Henry | Elizabeth Baker | 29 March 1853 |
| Goble, E. | Mary Wiley | 2 August 1849 |
| Green, William | Polly Henderson | 16 January 1845 |
| Greer, Moses | Emly (Emily)Baylor | 22 January 1845 |
| Greer, Moses | Mary Jane Pumphrey | 16 October 1849 |
| Greggs, Algernon | Phebe Hutchinson | 20 April 1844 (see Edwin Patridge) |
| Griffith, Joseph B. | Mary Ellen Dorsey | 27 November 1844 |
| Guiselman, Josiah | Mary Ringle | 29 March 1849 |
| Hagerty, Charles | Catharine F. Bailey | 24 July 1847 |
| Hakes, James | Margaret Murphy | 7 June 1846 |
| Hall, Andrew J. | Persis L. Martin | 16 April 1850 |
| Hance (Hand?), David | Cylda Walkins (Watkins?) | 16 May 1847 |
| Handly, Lucious | Sophia Ramsly | 10 June 1849 |
| Hardy, Valentine H. | Mary H. Hughs | 26 September 1850 |
| Hawkins, Thomas R. | Phebe McKlewrath | 15 February 1849 |
| Hay, Adam | Elizabeth Fisher | 13 Juni 1847 |
| Henderson, Charles | Jerusha Updike | 21 November 1852 |
| Hicman, Samuel H. | Amy Rodgers | 5 May 1845 |
| Hime, Christian | Margret Bailar | 20 February 1847 |
| Hooker, William | Neoma Moore | 7 October 1852 |
| Hosford, Myron W. | Esther Jane Burnie | 22 April 1845 |
| Houghton, John | Elizabeth McLoughlan | 18 April 1844 (see Edwin Patridge) |
| Hughes, William H. | Catharine Murphy | 16 March 1845 |
| Hughman, Isaac | Jemima Tod | 20 March 1845 |
| Hullinger, John W. | Sinthy Ann Case | 17 June 1848 |
| Hupp, Jacob K. | Eliza McFarlin | 14 July 1853 |
| Hussey, Seth | Rebecca A. Logan | 23 June 1844 |
| Hutley, James W. | Mary Williamson | 3 October 1847 |
| Huts, Joseph L. | Mary Jessop | 10 May 1845 |
| Imus, Charles | Amanda Bashford | 11 July 1849 |
| Jackman, Hugh | Caroline Graves | 28 March 1849 |
| Jackson, Thomas J. | Mary Ellen Short | 4 October 1848 |
| Jacoby, William | Hannah V. Taviner | 9 December 1852 |
| James, Joel | Philomelia Ruggles | 12 October 1848 |
| Johnson, Andrew J. | Mary Vinedge | 2 January 1848 |
| Johnson, Arthur | Mary Ann Newhouse | 10 September 1850 |
| Johnson, John | Margret Ousterout | 27 April 1844 |
| Johnson, Robert | Manerva Lemant | 25 September 1848 |
| Juda, Paul | Josephine Bailey | 20 June 1850 |
| Justice, John | Betsey Smith | 7 March 1849 |
| Kesling, Absalom | Barbary Rhinehart | 12 August 1849 |
| Kinsey, Abraham | Mary K. Malosh | 1 November 1849 |
| Knoblock, Frederic | Elisabeth Laudeman | 13 March 1849 |
| Lafer(t), Harmon | Catherine Lolmaugh | 13 February 1849 |
| Lake, Elisha | Lorrain No(rris) | 9 November 1847 |
| Lambert, Enos | Mary Gray | 11 October 1849 |
| Laudeman, Frederick | Catharine L. Hagemann | 30 November 1848 |
| Laudeman, Jacob | Elizabeth Stine | 15 February 1845 |
| Laudemann, Peter | Anna Herzoik (Hartsock?) | 27 October 1845 |
| Lauderman, John | Carolina Knoblock | 20 August 1846 |
| Linsay, John | Mercy Bass | 2 January 1853 |
| Lish, Hiram | Mary Jane Yeakley | 4 July 1846 (see John Snyder) |
| Little, Josiah | Marthy Ann Graves | 22 October 1848 |
| Logan, James W. | Catharine Lopp | 24 November 1850 |
| Lowry, John | Eliza Ann Bailey | 13 August 1846 |
| Lumbard, Hiram | Ann Mariah Anderson | 9 August 1850 |
| Marsters, Charles B. | Catherine Thornburg | 28 September 1848 |
| Martin, Squire | Jane Pittman | 17 July 1853 |
| MacDonald, David A. | Casandina Camble | 30 November 1848 |
| Mayer, Minard | Susett Reprogle | 18 May 1853 |
| McDearmot, John | Mariah Packard | 11 November 1844 |
| McDonald, Samuel | Mary Brownlee | 8 July 1849 |
| McElwrath, Niles | Racheal White | 24 November 1844 |
| McFarlin, John | Hellen, Taylor | 14 August 1845 (see George Nitcher) |
| McGuire, George | Mary McCoy | 25 May 1853 |
| Metcalf, Uri | Jain McFarling | 1 August 1847 |
| Miller, Andrew | Peggy Lashbaugh | 21 May 1846 |
| Miller, Jacob H. | Mary Singleton | 13 August 1847 |
| Millner, Thomas | Ruth Hoper | 21 December 1848 |
| Mooney, Jonas | Mary Baringer | 1 July 1849 |
| Moore, John | Emma Sherland | 23 February 1849 |
| Morris, David C. | Elenor English | 7 December 1848 (see Andrew Gerard) |
| Morris, Washington | Elizabeth Snyder | 3 April 1845 (see Solomon Stephens) |
| Munson, Lewis | Cillistia Tibbatts | 17 September 1845 |
| Myer, John Melcher | Elizabeth Adler (Cedler?) | 16 September 1847 |
| Neidig, David | Emeline Myers | 26 June 1853 |
| Newhouse, Thomas | Martha Hughs | 30 October 1849 |
| Newhouse, Thomas | Lucetta Brown | 2 December 1852 |
| Nitcher, Daniel | Matilda Reding | 29 March 1846 (see Norton Burch) |
| Nitcher, George | Lucinda Snyder | 13 March 1845 |
| Nitcher, William | Elizabeth Reding | 29 August 1844 |
| Nott, Jesse G. | Mary Roberts | 13 September 1849 |
| Oaks, William | Susan Downes | 11 June 1848 |
| Omaker, Godlove | Elizabeth Foegely | 18 August 1850 |
| Osborn, William | Louisa Janes Owens | 11 February 1849 |
| Palmer, Adelbert D. | Mariett Burch | 16 January 1849 |
| Parker, Joseph | Francina Campbell | 14 March 1848 |
| Parks, Isaac, A. | Cynthia Ann Blakely | 28 April 1849 |
| Patrick, Asariah K. | Mariah Willard | 9 May 1844 |
| Patridge, Edwin | Rachel Logan | 18 August 1844 |
| Pershing, Hezekiah P. | Katharine Trowbrige | 9 April 1846 (see Broderick Bouthen) |
| Plake, John | Rosanna Kilgore | 15 November 1849 |
| Pomeroy, Hiram | Harriet Tayler | 13 April 1847 |
| Powell, David | Nancy Ann Silvy | 4 May 1849 |
| Preston, John | Sarah Uttinger | 27 January 1848 |
| Prophet, James A. | Hannah Studebaker | 2 April 1850 |
| Ranes, William | Ann Symons | 18 October 1847 |
| Ranstead, Archibald | Christian Yockey | 20 March 1853 |
| Rarick, Jacob | Elizabeth Eleat | 18 March 1845 (see George Nitcher) |
| Reed, James | Mary Murphy | 20 October 1846 (see John Snyder) |
| Reed, Martin | Emaline Town | 9 April 1848 |
| Reed, Royal A. | Jamyma King | 23 December 1847 (see Andrew Gerard) |
| Reelhorn, Daniel | Polly Ann Lewis | 20 April 1851 |
| Reprogle, Elias | Catharine Justice | 27 April 1848 |
| Reprogle, Noah | Mary Ann Winans | 24 May 1849 |
| Rhinehart, Andrew | Eliza Rhodes | 5 November 1846 |
| Rhinehart, Andrew | Almina Rhodes | 12 November 1848 |
| Ross, Jonathan | Harriet Jones | 28 May 1853 |
| Ruggles, G. A. | Elizabeth Case | 9 July 1848 |
| Russel, James | Zenobia Houghton | 4 October 1845 |
| Russell, Thomas J. | Livonia Smith | 3 May 1853 |
| Sampson, George | America Ocheltree | 7 November 1849 |
| Sampson, William | Phebe Morris | 18 September 1845 |
| Schroder, Peter | Kesiah Williams | 28 March 1849 |
| Sealy, George | Secele Shufler | 24 August 1846 (see John Snyder) |
| Sellers, Levi P. | Martha Jane Curtis | 16 June 1853 |
| Shadle, Jacob | Hannah Jane Mow | 17 July 1853 |
| Shafer, Henry B. | Catherine Secrest | 20 November 1848 |
| Shenebarger, Anson | Sarah Jane Burch | 22 April 1847 |
| Shinebager, William B. | Sarah Butten | 5 June 1848 |
| Shurley, Samuel | Elizabeth White | 2 December 1845 |
| Slayter, Abraham | Isabella Tate | 1 July 1847 |
| Smith, David | Nancy Gibson | 7 September 1845 (see George Nitcher) |
| Smith, Henry | Lorian Sechrist | 14 December 1844 |
| Smith, John | Ann Hittle | 10 September 1848 |
| Smith, John | Helen Rish(er) | 30 September 1849 |
| Smith, John | Leah Sult | 9 November 1849 |
| Smith, Joseph | Mary Pratt | 19 November1848 |
| Smith, Samuel | Martha J. Butler | 6 January 1849 |
| Smith, William A. | Catharine Walker | 2 September 1847 |
| Snider, Solomon | Lucinda Morris | 24 April 1845 |
| Snyder, John | Sarah McCormick | 29 June 1846 |
| Sparrows, John | Hannah J. Staly | 18 January 1849 |
| Stephens, Solomon | Nancy Johnson | 9 March 1845 |
| Stephens, Thomas | Charlott Trobridge | 1 April 1845 |
| Strawderman, Adam | Annah Jacoby | 3 June 1851 |
| Sturgeon, William | Melissa Ann Stark | 7 January 1849 |
| Sutphen, Mathew | Pruda Pomeroy | 23 April 1846 |
| Taylor, Josiah | Elizabeth Cook | 19 June 1845 (see George Nitcher) |
| Taylor, William O. | Calesta Tibbets | 28 December 1847 |
| Thomas, Daniel | Francis Ann Rector | 8 May 1857 |
| Thompson, Isaac | Eliza Short | 2 November 1848 |
| Tibbets, Charles S. | Sarah Angelin McElwrath | 16 June 1844 |
| Tipton, James | Hannah Rockhill | 16 August 1849 |
| Trottles, William | Jane Tibbets | 2 November 1847 |
| Trowbridge, John | Elizabeth Snyder | 29 January 1846 |
| Truax, William | Catharine Oneal | 4 January 1846 |
| Truman, Wells | Mary Ullery | 2 January 1847 (parental consent only) |
| Tucker, Joseph | Ann McAlister | 15 March 1849 |
| Turner, James | Sarah Case | 30 December 1846 |
| Tuttle, Major | Eliza C. Ramsey | 23 January 1848 |
| Tuttle, Washington | Julia Ann Inks | 1 September 1850 |
| Vinage, William | Eliza Jane Gates | 8 April 1847 |
| Vinnage, David Sr. | Hannah Flood | 8 November 1849 |
| Waits, William | Susan Replogle | 1 January 1846 |
| Waldo, Chancy | Sarah Jane Brewer | 11 May 1848 |
| Walker, Heram | Catherine Hittle | 29 December 1845 (permission to marry) |
| Walker, Hiram | Catharine Hittle | 1 January 1846 |
| Walker, James | Sophia Brewer | 20 August 1846 |
| Wallace, Isaac R. | Isabel E. Snyder | 5 May 1853 |
| Wamsley, Joseph | Julyann Tuttle | 5 February 1848 |
| Watkins, Jonathan | Catharine Ulry | 1 April 1847 |
| Watkins, Perry | Elizabeth Evins | 19 October 1848 |
| Webb, Nelson | Elizabeth Daws | 5 November 1851 |
| White, Thomas J. | Elizabeth Weir | 16 August 1850 |
| Wilson, Joseph | Martha Ann Price | 13 February 1845 |
| Woodden, James | Catharine Linn | 23 December 1852 |
| Yackly, Adam | Elizabeth Nash | 13 August 1844 (father, James, permission) |
| Yeakley, Adam | Elizabeth Nash | 15 August 1844 (see Edwin Patridge) |
| Yockey, David | Elisa Ann Ransted | 22 August 1844 |
| Yockey, John | Dorotha Lock | 30 November 1845 |
| Yockey, John | Elisabetha Bower | 28 July 1853 |
| Zahm, Anthony | Catherine Miller | 7 April 1847 |