GRAIN V8. BARNES AND FERGCSSON. 158
The defence made by the answer was, payment in whole, or in part,
and sundry objections to the form of the bill, were urged, at the
hearing. In evidence of payment, the defendants rely partly upon a
paper filed, containing a memorandum in Comp- ton's hand writing, by
which he charges himself with "amount of Barnes' draft $500," which
draft was not produced nor was any proof offered of its payment, or to
show upon what account it was drawn. Another credit of $1500, was also
claimed by the defendants, the character of which will appear in
the Chancellor's opinion.
The first point noticed by the Chancellor, was the alleged want of
jurisdiction in the court to decree a payment of the legacy, the courts
of law being fully competent to give relief, in reference to which, he
said :]
THE CHANCELLOR:
Considering this as the will of the administrators of Mrs. Compton,
and that the right to recover, if it exists at all, is in them, it is a
proceeding, the representatives of a ward, against the executors of a
guardian, to recover a legacy which had been bequeathed the ward, and
which the guardian in that ca- pacity had received from the executors
of the testator, by whom the bequest was made.
It is a bill, then, in equity, by a ward against her guardian— that
is by a cestuique trust, against the trustee. The relation of guardian
and ward constituting, as Mr. Justice Story says, the most important
and delicate of trusts, and as this relation and the rights and
obligations which grow out of it, are pecu- liarly within the
jurisdiction of this court, its power to afford a remedy for a breach
of the trust cannot be denied, unless it can be clearly shown tohave
been taken away by some express stat- utory enactment.
In the matter of Andrews., 1 Johns. Chan. Rep., 99, Chan- cellor
Kent says, that every guardian, however appointed, is re- sponsible in
equity for his conduct, and may be removed for misbehavior, and that a
testamentary, or statute guardian, is as much under the superintendance
of the Court of Chancery as the guardian in socage.
|
|