Archives of Maryland, Volume 0200, Volume 1, Page 0152 - Reports of Cases in the High Court of Chancery of Maryland 1846-1854
Reports of Cases in the High Court of Chancery of Maryland 1846-1854
Volume 200, Volume 1, Page 152
clear space clear space clear space white space

158 HIOH COURT OF CHANCERY.

As evidence of payment of a legacy due to a ward, the defendants relied upon
a memorandum in the hand writing of C., the husband of the ward, by which
he charged himself with "amount ofB's draft of $500." (B. being the guar-
dian.) The draft was not produced, and there was no proof of its payment,
or on what account it was drawn. They further claimed a credit of $1500,
being the amount of a check by B. on the Bank of Baltimore, payable to C.
w hearer, which was paid by the bank, but to whom the money was paid, did
not appear. HELD—

That this evidence of payment was wholly inconclusive and unsatisfactory,
and that it would be a departure from the rules established for the ascertain-
ment of truth, to give it the effect for which the defendants insist.

Courts of justice are not at liberty to indulge in wild, irrational conjectures, or
licentious speculations, but must act upon fixed and settled rules. And it is
far better that individuals should occasionally suffer, than that principles,
which time and experience have shown to be essential to the ascertainment
of truth, should be broken down or disregarded.

Where no time is fixed by the will for the payment of a legacy, it will bear
interest from the expiration of one year after the death of the testator.

[By the last will and testament of Samuel Bond, dated 8th
July, l8l8, Mary Clarissa Bond Barncs, was bequeathed a leg-
acy of $3000, and also one-fourth of his slaves. John Barnes,
her father, and surviving executor of the deceased, passed his
first and final account on the l4th April, 1830, showing a bal-
ance of $38,33816 in his hands for distribution amongst the par-
ties entitled. As guardian to his daughter, he was awarded by
the Orphan's Court a proportion of the slaves, estimated -at
$2337 50, and the pecuniary legacy of $3000. Mary C. B,
Barnes;, intermarried with William P. Compton, in the year,
1825, and died in the year 1834, leaving her husband, and an
infant son, Barnes Compton, surviving her, of whom the for-
mer died in 1837. At his death, John Barnes became guardian
of the infant, and bonded as such. Said Barnes died also, in
the year 1844, and by his will appointed the defendants, Rich-
ard Barnes, and Robert Fergusson, his executors. Letters of
administration on the estate of Mary C. B. Compton were sub-
sequently granted to Peter W. Grain, and Henry G. S. Key,
who in their representative capacity, and as the next friend, of
said Barnes Compton, sued the executors of John Barnes for the
pecuniary legacy which they allege to be still due; admitting
the receipt by Coinpton and wife, of her share of the negroes.



 
clear space
clear space
white space

Please view image to verify text. To report an error, please contact us.
Reports of Cases in the High Court of Chancery of Maryland 1846-1854
Volume 200, Volume 1, Page 152   View tiff image (46K)
 Jump to  
  << PREVIOUS  NEXT >>


Tell Us What You Think About the Maryland State Archives Website!


[ Archives' Home Page || Visitors' Center || Search the Archives || Staff Directory || Maryland & Its Government || Maryland Manual On-Line || Reference & Research || Education & Outreach || Government House || State Art Collection || Archives of Maryland ]

Governor     General Assembly    Judiciary     Maryland Electronic Capital    MARYLAND.GOV

An Archives of Maryland electronic publication.
For information contact mailto:[email protected]?subject=Volume 000200, Volume 1, Page 152.

©Copyright  August 01, 2003
Maryland State Archives